Duplicate Content Report: Duplicate URLs being crawled with "++" at the end
-
Hi,
In our Moz report over the past few weeks I've noticed some duplicate URLs appearing like the following:
Original (valid) URL:
http://www.paperstone.co.uk/cat_553-616_Office-Pins-Clips-and-Bands.aspx?filter_colour=Green
Duplicate URL:
http://www.paperstone.co.uk/cat_553-616_Office-Pins-Clips-and-Bands.aspx?filter_colour=Green**++**
These aren't appearing in Webmaster Tools, or in a Screaming Frog crawl of our site so I'm wondering if this is a bug with the Moz crawler? I realise that it could be resolved using a canonical reference, or performing a 301 from the duplicate to the canonical URL but I'd like to find out what's causing it and whether anyone else was experiencing the same problem.
Thanks,
George
-
So glad to help, George!
-
Hi Chiaryn,
Thanks - you've been really helpful! I had assumed that as the referrer wasn't in the Web UI (per WMT), it wasn't available anywhere. I'd also assumed it was a copywriting issue and not a product data issue.
Need to readdress my assumptions
George
-
Hey George,
Thanks for writing in.
I looked into the pages with the ++ in the URL and it seems that they do actually exist on the site, so it isn't an issue with our crawler that is causing these in your crawl errors. For example, a link to the URL http://www.paperstone.co.uk/cat_553_Desktop-Essentials.aspx?filter_colour=Green++ can be found in the source code of the page http://www.paperstone.co.uk/cat_553_Desktop-Essentials.aspx here: http://screencast.com/t/HpHTlSs5gH8H
You can find the referral pages for the ++ pages on the site by downloading the Full Crawl Diagnostics CSV. In the first column, perform a search for the ++. When you find the correct row, look in the column labeled referrer, AM. This tells you the referral URL of the page where our crawlers first found the URLs that include ++. You can then visit this URL to find the links to those pages.
Since these URLs with the ++ do resolve with a 200 http status and they have the same code and content as the pages without the ++, our crawler will count them as duplicate content. I'm not certain why Screaming Frog and GWT are not find or reporting these pages; it may be that they parse the + signs in the URL differently than our crawler does.
As Keri and bishop23 mentioned, this is most likely not a major issue if GWT isn't reporting the errors, but we prefer to report the issues because we would rather be safe than sorry.
I hope this helps. Please let me know if you have any other questions.
Chiaryn
-
I'm not seeing an answer that jumps out at me for this one. For the immediate future, don't sweat it if you're not seeing it in GWT. This is assigned to our help desk, and we'll have someone from there investigate more and get back to you, though it might be a few days because of the Thanksgiving holiday (if you don't get an answer today, it may be Monday before we have a chance to respond).
-
If they're not appearing on WMT than you should ignore unless it's an exact duplicated content, then delete
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Keyword rankings "soon"?
On the insights portion of one of my campaigns, I continually see this message: " You will see rankings for the 100 keywords we found for you very soon. In the meantime, add more keywords for [XXXXX].It has said "very soon" for quite some time. How do I get this section to work?
Product Support | | seo-nicole0 -
What is the difference between the "Crawl Issues" report and the "Crawl Test" report?
I've downloaded the CSV of the Crawl Diagnositcs report (which downloads as the "Crawl Issues" report) and the CSV from the Crawl Test Report, and pulled out the pages for a specific subdomain. The Crawl Test report gave me about 150 pages, where the Crawl Issues report gave 500 pages. Why would there be that difference in results? I've checked for duplicate URLs and there are none within the Crawl Issues report.
Product Support | | SBowen-Jive0 -
Is there a report that will show Keyword Rank History for the life of an active campaign?
I want to get a history of the keywords that have been tracked in an active campaign. This will allow us to see improvements over time.
Product Support | | liftedlogic1 -
"Branded Reports" not branded email
I am a new Moz customer and specifically chose the $149 plan to get "branded reports" My Logo shows on the pdf report but when that report is emailed to the client there is a big black banner at the top of the email that says MOZ! I chose branded reports so that the customer would see my branding not MOZ. This is very frustrating and there does not seem to be a solution from MOZ, I know that you can send the email with my return email address but why do you have to put the MOZ branding in the email.
Product Support | | GEWEB1 -
Why can't the dates be changed in automatic reports?
I want to be able to change the publish date of automatic reports in my campaigns. One such campaign, which is a client campaign, it's set to run on the 8th after I selected "monthly". However, this doesn't work for me as this client want's to meet each month on between the 2nd and 5th of each month and I have to have this report data. So, I need to run this report on the first. Not the 2nd, not every 4 weeks... on the first. It seems like you guys have a fundamental flaw in the design of this tool, as great as it is. You've set the projects to auto run each month from the date it was added (at least from what I can tell). Provided that's true, then this would explain why the monthly reports won't work on my schedule because their on a weekly schedule instead. We, as clients, should be given the option to schedule when our scanning runs, when our reports get generated, etc. Every company runs their SEO and marketing differently, but the away you've set this up with the lack of options for us, forces us to work around your tools scheduling and not the other way around. Also, out of all of the SEO tools I've tried (quite a few), none have had this limitation. This should be addressed immediately. Thanks, Micha
Product Support | | Multiverse-Media-Group1 -
Tracking keywords and SERP Analysis Reports
My question is regarding the "Track up to 50 keywords over time." and the "x of 100 full SERP Analysis Reports run this month" Is it possible to increase these fixed numbers? or do I have to use a secondary account? It would be nice to have history for more keywords then 50. and the same goes for the SERP analysis report.
Product Support | | Justian0 -
Why has my Google Analytics dropped completely from the results on this weeks crawl?
The Account code hasn't changed in either Moz or on site? Also I added 53 new keywords to my campaign and they haven't all been ranked, it's like Moz has done half a job?! S.O.S.
Product Support | | danwebman0 -
Anyone else receiving several duplicate Moz Weekly Rankings Report today?
Anyone else receiving several duplicate Moz Weekly Rankings Report today? I think I have received about 15-20 email duplicate reports on my weekly rankings. David
Product Support | | David-E-Carey0