What happens now? Guest blogging dead?
-
Today, Matt Cutts published an article on his blog saying pretty much "Guest blogging is dead". Seemed a little harsh to me, but what happens now?
Is GOOD guest blogging still allowed or will it be seen as spam too?
I even picked up a chatter on Twitter about YouMoz: https://twitter.com/rustybrick/status/425374254465445888
-
I have mentioned this a number of times but will rgab the opportunity and say it again.Nobody can fix google's algorith, not even Google itself. It's out of their hands, always was, always will be. The past already shows, that their algorithm gets a lot of things wrong and penalized small biz and ranks spam high, you all got examples of that. They are already bad at identifying machines or humans.
Assuming they will go for keyprhases such as Marie Haynes is a writer for example.com...", or "Visit my website at example.com" is simply impossible, for thishappen 99.9% of the guest post authorship tag must include the same keyphrase which i doubt. I find more likely to devalue for example ALL authorship links or even anything with /blog/ in its url, but for that to happen it would mean that 99% of the blogs have the same phrasing which I doubt.
If you are wondering how they will try to minimise that, my pov is that they will take into account a couple things such as 1)frequency of posts, 2) how many of these posts are original content and 3)OBL which to my surprise noone mentions here.
Matt refers to spam sites that are there for link selling purposes. If you follow his tweets and his latest activities you would know he is after the private blog networks advertised on the most popular black hat forum on the internet. What does that mean? that the algorithm cant track them thus he is trying to figure it out manually.
Black Hat SEO is the art of making a machines work to look like it has been done by a lot of humans. Google's job on the other site is to find out who's the human and who's the machine. Google gets better at identifying machines, so the SEO industry gets better at mimicking human behaviour. Guest Blog is an area that got abused but trust me there is a difference having a guest blog on a PR5 site, with unique content and 1-2 links and a total OBL of less than 30 than a guest blog of 500 words with 3 EM ancor links on high competitive keyprhases and roughly 20 comments with link in them. Then again in this case OBL would explode so why would you want a link like that anyway? You lose the value thus wasting money, time and resources.
-
_I personally believe that the next Penguin algorithm is going to discount any links that Google can tell are from guest posting. It may devalue links that are in sentences like, "Marie Haynes is a writer for example.com...", or "Visit my website at example.com". When those links get devalued then it's going to look like a penalty to sites who have relied heavily on guest posting. _
Let's assume I put a quality guest post on a quality site, with the do-follow link to my site embedded naturally in the copy and among one of half a dozen links to half a dozen sites (ie, the thing doesn't remotely look or smell like a guest post).
Does that pass muster? -
It is really interesting. I had been thinking about stopping this for a while, because as Rand says whats starts as an authority source i.e you look for the best sites, you slowly try and scale as you get more clients. I have used Myblogguest and Postjoint for a while now but never did any "exact match" anchor text and also avoided "so-and-so writes articles on (example.com). I tried to only go for authoritative and relevant sites, but yes hands-up this just for links.
I think it is time to sit up and realise we have to adapt our skillset to become digital marketers, not just SEO's. Is this the end for SEO, of course not!!!.
My question is if we do have a few links we feel although relevant and authoritative, could be called into question, do we get them removed or leave them as is?
-
I think that the message Matt was trying to get out is that if guest blogging is a linking strategy then stop doing it! However, when he changed the post to say that some high quality guest blogging is ok, I feel that SEO's are going to misinterpret this.
What I hear Matt saying: You can guest blog, and it's even ok to get the occasional link out of it, but don't use it as a way to get links. Only guest blog somewhere where you would have taken advantage of the opportunity even if there was no link. (For example, I guest blog on Moz for the exposure and the link I get is just an added bonus.)
How I feel a lot of SEOs are going to interpret Matt's change: Don't do glorified article syndication, but as long as it's not a spammy site, sure, go ahead and do a guest blog.
I think that a lot of SEOs are going to justify their link acquisition through guest blogs by telling themselves that they would have done the post even if there was no link, but in reality they are fooling themselves.
I personally believe that the next Penguin algorithm is going to discount any links that Google can tell are from guest posting. It may devalue links that are in sentences like, "Marie Haynes is a writer for example.com...", or "Visit my website at example.com". When those links get devalued then it's going to look like a penalty to sites who have relied heavily on guest posting.
-
Have you read the post? First he was talking about ALL guest blogging. Then he retracted and fixed both the title of the post and added a note to it.
FYI: This wasn't a video. It was a blog post on Matt's blog.
-
if Matt Cutts said it, that means it works.
Joke aside, guest blogging is not bad but getting links ONLY from guest blog is I guess. I dont think matt cutts referfs to guest blogging opportunities between good web sites, news and organisations he is more into the unsolicited spam emails I get every day by hundreds offering 400 word articles with links in exchange of guest blogging to their site as well. This will leave a footprint between my site and his/her site. My assumption is that if you have a profile with hundres of these you will get devalued. No need to panic every time Matt releases a video
-
It's nothing new and its been coming for a long time, did you see rands blog a while back on the subject - http://moz.com/blog/guest-posting-blogging-slippery-slope-whiteboard-friday
Guest blogging is still great for communicating but not for gaining links. If in doubt use a no follow link, or write a blog on your site and try to get people to organically link to it.
-
This is extremely funny. A bold guy is offering Matt Cutts something he is going to love...Lolzzzzzzz
A part of it. Sometimes, I get confused. Let me recall
- Google spammed millions of websites on April, 2012 (Penguin 1) on account of low quality directories (I got an email from an eCommerce Store which was penalized by Unnatural Notice. Somehow we could not make agreement. But I analyzed his back-links. Just hundreds and hundreds of low quality directories nothing else)
- On 20th Oct, 2013. I got email from same source with amazing words "We have started to get leads from our website suddenly. We havn't done anything on it in last 1 and half year. We are ranking on many keywords as well"
Directory Submission was crushed and now we can see directories pages ranking even for competitive keywords.
Similarly, Guest Blogging (Particularly For SEO Purposes) was promoted too much in last 1 year and I was anticipating this from last couple of months. Finally, it comes. Don't worry. Guest blogging will be revived in next few updates;)
Guest Blogging for branding purposes (Nofollow Linking) will not be penalized by the way!
Regards
-
Hi Federico,
I saw the title change too. I'm sure the social chatter was going nuts all over the world seeing something like that initially. Hopefully, SEOs and content marketers have settled down a bit, like I have.
Guest blogging will continue, I believe, so long as it doesn't look spammy and/or paid for. I mean, how else will we be able to distribute content all over and build relationships?
Building the brand with guest posts should be a focus, rather than linking out to exact keyword phrases as many do and have done. I'm guilty of it for our site and clients. Things now need to change and that's our goal. Adapt and improve and be as proactive as possible. Much like you keeping up on the latest from Google HQ
We'll be the ones adding value to our service offerings and ultimately for our clients. - Cheers! Patrick
-
And just minutes ago, Cutts changed the post title and clarified he was referring to "guest blogging for the sole purpose of SEO"...
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Blog SEO strategy
Hi Moz community, we are looking for some advice on our blog/SEO strategy. I hope to find some people who faced similar challenges in the past. Wishlist currently has one blog (http://blog.enjoywishlist.com/), which has two main focus points. One main focus is to portray and encourage a lifestyle that is conducive with our product offering. The main driver behind the content we post is for SEO optimization for our B2C clients. The other focus for our blog is to target current and potential clients on the B2B side of things. That content is much more driven by a target audience and different topics. It is hard to address two audience in one blog and we are working with the idea of separating the blog into two different host domains. Along with the blogs we will also move the landing pages for B2C and B2B into different domains and link these as appropriate. The challenge we face is understanding if it would benefit us to host these two blogs on different domains. We are also wondering if it would help our hurt our SEO to take the content related to our corporate blog and move it to the new domain? Advice appreciated! Thanks Andreas
Branding | | AndreasD1 -
YouTube transcript being used for junk blog?
Should I be concerned about youtube transcripts with our brand name being used to populate junk blogs? I just noticed this with freshweb this morning: http://www.sharehomevalue.com/blogs/11567. There are about 4 pages of results like this... mostly Korean websites.
Branding | | SSRMarketing0 -
Commentluv enabled blogs for inbound links?
Question 1: What is the general consensus on gaining links through blog comments on blogs with CommentLuv enabled? Backstory: I was studying our competitor's links and tripped upon something I haven't seen before. There were a number of blog comments created in 2011 by an individual who was probably an SEO hired at least partially for the purpose of making blog comments to gain inbound links for the competitor. I haven't dug deeply enough to find if there are any more recent than 2011. The interesting part was the name/link of the company for this individual which was not the company's actual name but a URL crafted from a main keyword. It obviously has a redirect to the actual competitor's website which is where the link took me AND a link to this individual's "most recent blog post". This blog post on the company site was written by someone else entirely. Question 2: Clearly some manipulation to build links- would these links be considered unnatural? Question 3: Would it be smart for me to find blogs with CommentLuv to gain links to my blog?
Branding | | gfiedel0 -
Moving Blog from www.topic.domain.com to www.domain.com/blog
Hi Fellow Mozzers, Just started off here on seomoz.org and am super happy to have joined the community! I've recently started a new job as web optimization manager for an education company. There is a lot to do and one of my first tasks is to figure a better strategy for our current blog. I've convinced our management to move our blog from topic.domain.com to domain.com/blog. My research has shown that this is a better strategy so that our blog can receive the DA of our root domain, get more people to click through our site, and even receive more natural searches (PLEASE, someone correct me if I'm wrong on this). Anyway, our blog is currently hosted as a Wordpress blog and we're wondering if it's more worthwhile to build a blog platform ourselves or continue using Wordpress. I am not a technical guy and don't know the backend stuff to make it happen, but my concern is primarily for the optimum search capacity. Also, our bloggers frequently put links to different portions of our website - does this hold any negative SEO value in terms of too much internal linking? I personally wouldn't assume so, but then again I could be wrong. Finally, we also track our main website using Google Analytics- currently, the only tracking we have installed on our blogs is the default provided by Wordpress (yes yes I know, but that's why i'm here -- to fix these weaknesses). I'm assuming we will be able to better track using GA when the switch is made. So, I guess my questions are: (1) Is my research correct in that it's better to have our blog hosted as domain.com/blog over topic.domain.com (2) Are there any best practices in making this switch and/or any negative implications with continuing to use Wordpress or should we build our own platform (we have the internal resources to do so, but would prefer to take the easiest and best route in terms of SEO and community building). (3) Will it still be just as easy to track using GA. Thank you!! Pedram
Branding | | CSawatzky0 -
How to leverage blog articles?
"Hello Moz Fans!" I've been writing blogs for our new site (bizinka.com an e-commerce,website design company) and posting links on our social media pages, however as we're in our infancy and so there's limited traffic that comes from social media so I want to know what the best practices and avenues to take in leveraging these blogs? I've heard a lot about article sites such as Ezine holding little weight and there's a lot of forums out there that don't seem to offer much at all in terms of traffic and credibility. Could anyone suggest some sites please?
Branding | | SimonDixon0 -
Tips for promoting the blog section of our eCommerce site
Hi, With the recent Google updates we're thinking that unique content is more important than ever in order to gain high quality, natural links from genuine users. As such we're thinking that our blog (http://www.refreshcartridges.co.uk/igloo/) might be more important than ever. Don't be put off by the lack of Page Authority or Google Page Rank; we've only just moved to this address from the subdomain igloo.refreshcartridges.co.uk. The content is certainly rather niche; an article like http://www.refreshcartridges.co.uk/igloo/how-to-the-reset-purge-counter-on-a-brother-printer-with-a-numerical-pad/ will be helpful to thousands of users who own this particular range of printer but it's debatable as to whether it is sufficiently mainstream to be openly shared and linked to. We ping to sites such as Technorati, produce videos to accompany much of the content (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-dxmm4-blN8&list=UUH93Kwax4CcEIAOsXWb6CiA&index=1&feature=plcp for example) and provide easy sharing buttons. I do however think that we could be doing more to actively ‘push’ this content on to potential customers. I'm not naive enough to think that niche articles like this will be enough to get hundreds of links and tens of thousands of reads but printer news, reviews and support is pretty much the only thing we can write about while being relevant to our core business. I would however like to get the best exposure that we can for these articles which is why I’m asking for your advice today. I would really appreciate any ideas you may have as to how else we could gain the best value from these unique articles and videos. I apologise for this being such an open ended question but any and all advice on how to maximise this resource would be appreciated. Many thanks!
Branding | | ChrisHolgate0 -
Need Help Regarding Guest Blog Posts
Hello, I have recently joined here to read up about SEO and to access the tools for my in-house “SEO guy” who has just started. So I’m a little bit green to all of this and have a quick question regarding guest posting. He says that there is a lot to do with my sites; building links, correcting errors on some of my sites, etc. He showed me from the reports on here and he is an honest trustworthy guy, so not worried about being scammed. A lot of this stuff goes over my head though, so he directed me to the question and answer area/blog if I have any worries or queries. He wants to put a section on the home page of my blog promoting the fact that I accept guest posts. I understand that this will help me rank higher (hopefully!) and also he says I should be trying to post on other blogs to get these links for my sites. I think this might be a good idea because I have a few websites and not a lot of time or money to do a great amount of content (which I’m told needs to be regular and of high quality), perhaps a post a week on each site I can manage at the moment. I think that some competitors might want to use this opportunity to get a link from my website to theirs. I must admit I’m a little bit hesitant about doing this if it helps them. He is telling me that just one link in the author area of the post is fine, and only to accept good quality posts. But I just want some other people’s opinions as well. Are there any ground rules that someone can recommend I stick to? Along the lines of, how many links I allow them to have in their post, where these links should be, how long the content should be as a minimum, etc. Thanks in advance. Jeff
Branding | | JonathanRolande0 -
Guest Posts/Blogs/Articles Link Building
Is it me or are the usual places you used to go for to find quality blogs to guest post to seem to be full of low quality spammy blogs. And doing a search brings up loads of poor quality sites/blogs too. I was thinking of creating a high quality content site for link bait. Any suggestions on "refreshing" a tired link strategy. Where do you find your guest blog/posts?
Branding | | JohnW-UK0