Mismatch on the City and Zip Code as strategy?
-
I have never seen this before, but I recently took over a client that for all intents and purposes is considered to be in Metro A. They're just south of the border and everyone (customers, etc.) consider them in Metro A. The problem is their physical address puts them in Small Town B. For whatever reason, this client has decided that they are going to put their address as follows:
Street
Metro A, Zip Code Small Town BThey've mismatched the city and zip code in attempts to have a stronger showing in Metro A organically. I've never seen this strategy before, my gut tells me bad, bad, bad. So I'm looking for a better strategy, advice, etc.
-
So glad if that will help! Good luck - you have a really important chance to help this business
-
Thanks Miriam. They do at least have the correct format on their G+ listings, but if it's a mismatch everywhere else, then they're a fish out of water.
It's great to read some solid resources advocating against it. I know this client is willing to do the right thing. I just needed the right pieces of information to make my recommendation stronger.
Thanks again!!!
-
You're welcome! I think the most influential resource you can share with the client will be the 2014 Local Search Ranking Factors survey, which is based on data provided by some of the top Local SEOs in the world.
The #1 negative ranking factor in the most recent survey is:
Listing detected at false business location.
See: http://moz.com/local-search-ranking-factors
By intentionally falsifying part of their location information, your client is putting their business at the #1 risk - if this statistic doesn't convince them, they may be a client you'll want to part company with.
The other piece of data I would give this client is that, because many of the major local business aggregators rely on USPS to standardize addresses, the use of a false zip code is likely to be auto-corrected by some or all of them at some point, creating NAP inconsistency. Google will then pool knowledge about this NAP confusion around the web, and this takes us to negative ranking factors 3, 4 and 5 in LSRF 2014. So - uh-oh, the business is running the risks inherent in 4 of 5 top negative ranking factors. That's about as drastic as it gets.
Moreover, messing up their zip code could be driving their legitimate clients away. If I'm looking for tacos in zip code 32201 and this is the location of your client's taco shop, but Google no longer trusts that it's located in that zip code, I'll be going to a competitor's taco shop with correct NAP because consistency has allowed it to outrank the business with the mismatching NAP. There's just no good reason for a brick-and-mortar business to do this to themselves. Hope you can help him see the light on this one. If not, I'd personally walk away.
-
Uh oh. Miriam's advice is spot on. They should best get that cleaned up.
Per the guidelines: https://support.google.com/business/answer/2853879?hl=en, "Enter the complete and exact street address for your location."
-
Thanks Miriam. It definitely does output an invalid address because the city & zip don't match. Do you have any specific resources you'd recommend that I can use to back up my recommendation that this is not a good idea? Aside from the traditional you need a correct address and your NAP must be consistent? I have a feeling their argument might be "But if all my address citations match (even though it's incorrect) in the major local ecosystems, how will Google know? I'd love to be able to counter that with something more solid, or an example where someone else did something similar and their results went sour.
-
No. They're not an SAB. Brick and mortar.
-
Sounds not quite right - agree. Have the client look up their own business on SmartyStreets.com to see how the USPS officially recognizes their address. If they deviate from this, they may be headed for trouble
-
That's odd. Are they a Service Area Business (SAB) that's attempting to show up in results for those given areas?
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
For a URL, is it better to have Keyword +City?
I am working on some landing pages and trying to do well in Local areas. Is it better to have my landing pages set as mysite.com/keyword+location or mysite.com/Location+keyword. or does it even matter anymore? So for a plumber selling water heater services. is it better to be: site/hot-water-heaters-jacksonville-fl or site/jacksonville-fl-hot-water-heaters? I normally do keyword+city.
Image & Video Optimization | | netviper0 -
What is the SEO value of images of geographic areas (states, counties, cities) on a page?
We want to put images for specific geographic locations on some new pages we are building and I am wondering if: A) What the SEO value of adding these images would be? B) Suggested Sources for the images. Right now we are looking at using panoramio, but would love some MOZ community advice! Thank you for your help MOZ Community!
Image & Video Optimization | | AlyssaN0 -
Google+ Local City Centroid Bias
It's well-known that Google has a bias towards businesses located closest to the center of the city being searched in. How can you tell where exactly Google considers to be the center of the city? I think that the way is to just search the city name on Google Maps and the marker will appear at where they consider the center of the city to be but just wanted to double check on that first.
Image & Video Optimization | | ChaseCameron0 -
City names in URLs
Hey guys. When targeting a specific keyword that mentions a city (eg. Dover Used Cars) would it be a good practice to include that city in the URL when creating additional pages (eg. placethatsellsusedcars.com/dover-used-fords)? Thanks!
Image & Video Optimization | | Web3Marketing870 -
City/Town content pages for a local business
Earlier this month I asked a private question on the use of schema for service area pages on a home improvement contractors website. The question led to Miriam Ellis giving me some great ideas about creating content for pages specific to the clients service area. The goal here would be to rank for [roofing contractor + city] using a URL similar to: mycompany.com/service-areas/city-state A great idea Miriam gave me for creating content for these pages: Showcasing a previous project in that city/town with a well-written project description, photos, videos and client testimonials. Her advice is excellent and I wanted to share it with you. I also wanted to open up the discussion and see what others have had success with. If the company is relatively new, and doesn’t have the work history to create pages such as this, what would you do?
Image & Video Optimization | | WilliamCarr0 -
Setting Up Localized City Pages and Duplicate Content issues
We are setting up landing pages on our site that will cater to specific cities, in an effort to be more relevant to the users in those cities and also capture more localized traffic. These regional pages will each have a unique paragraph at the top, but below that is a sentence or two about each product line that would be difficult to rewrite with quality more than 10 - 15 times. Would the paragraph at the top of the page be enough unique content (about 4-5 sentences)? Obviously the duplicate content wouldn't be to my advantage, but is it really necessary to rewrite the other sentences about the product lines? What's the most efficient method to complete this project in a whitehat fashion?
Image & Video Optimization | | InetAll0 -
Does adding the city to your business name in a Places page help or harm Local SEO?
Hi, All! Another local SEO question... For one of our clients, the title on their Place page is <official business="" name=""><city>. Example: John's Sporting Goods Detroit. Now, most citations will say "John's Sporting Goods." Is having "Detroit" as part of the business name in Places problematic (NAP inconsistency) and we should remove it, or is it helpful for ranking for "sporting goods detroit" or is it neither?</city></official> Thanks! Aviva
Image & Video Optimization | | debi_zyx0 -
How does google decide what city a blog belongs to?
I'm trying to build links from more local blogs at the moment and considering a huge list of blogs that are in my city, of which many do accept guest posts. I'm trying to discover a metric to thin this list down further. Is there any way of finding out if google considers a specific blog to be local to a certain area? What signals does google consider when it is making this analysis? Is it the content? or is it the "about the blog author" section? Thanks, Storwell
Image & Video Optimization | | adriandg0