Image Links Vs. Text Links, Questions About PR & Anchor Text Value
-
I am searching for testing results to find out the value of text links versus image links with alt text.
Do any of you have testing results that can answer or discuss these questions?
If 2 separate pages on the same domain were to have the same Page Authority, same amount of internal and external links and virtually carry the same strength and the location of the image or text link is in the same spot on both pages, in the middle of the body within paragraphs.
-
Would an image link with alt text pass the same amount of Page Authority and PR as a text link?
-
Would an image link with alt text pass the same amount of textual value as a text link? For example, if the alt text on the image on one page said "nike shoes" and the text link on the other page said "nike shoes" would both pass the same value to drive up the rankings of the page for "nike shoes"?
-
Would a link wrapped around an image and text phrase be better than creating 2 links, one around the image and one around the text pointing to the same page?
The following questions have to do with when you have an image and text link on a page right next to each other, like when you link a compelling graphic image to a category page and then list a text link underneath it to pass text link value to the linked-to page.
-
If the image link displays before the text link pointing to a page, would first link priority use the alt text and not even apply the anchor text phrase to the linked page?
-
Would it be best to link the image and text phrase together pointing to the product page to decrease the link count on the page, thus allowing for more page rank and page authority to pass to other pages that are being linked to on the page? And would this also pass anchor text value to the link-to page since the link would include an image and text?
I know that the questions sound a bit repetitive, so please let me know if you need any further clarification. I'd like to solve these to further look into ways to improve some user experience aspects while optimizing the link strength on each page at the same time.
Thanks!
Andrew -
-
Gotcha. This is a total guess, but I'd venture to say that PageRank is probably passed in the same quantities (mozRank definitely is).
Page Authority is harder to say because it doesn't actually "flow" - it's a metric we calculate AFTER the rest of the link graph and the metrics are done processing and represents a machine-learning based algo with inputs of every other kind of link metric. One of these could certainly be the ratio of images to text links or the existence or non-existence of both, but as with any machine learning system, it's hard to know what's actually (even for the folks who wrote it!)!
-
Hi Rand, thanks so much for the feedback. I agree and see it the same way.
For sites with great images and compelling media, it would make sense that a lot of their back links are image links pointing to their home or internal pages where the images are located. Anchor text links likely influence keyword rankings a bit more since they likely add more context to the link than an alt tag and the surrounding content around an image link. But a link from a great source is ideal indeed.
The question that I guess I haven't fully answered is whether or not Page Rank, Page Authority, Link Juice. etc gets passed as the same AMOUNT when flowing through an image link versus a text link. Using the page example I mentioned above, would an image link that flows from a Page Authority 50 page pass the same AMOUNT of Page Authority as a text link from a Page Authority 50 page? It's a geeky question, but so are so many elements of SEO
And the effectiveness of wrapping an image with text link are still kind of unknown by our crew or others I've talked to about it. At a glance, it's less code on the page, less links, and a good user experience, so on paper I think doing category grid links on ecommerce sites might serve the user and bots well if more sites would link the image AND text link together.
Thoughts?
- Andrew
-
Hi Andrew - it's been a while since I ran this particular test (almost 2 years!) but, back then, we saw that a straight HTML text link with anchor text appeared to pass slightly more ranking ability/value to a page than the same link with an image + alt text. Now, that said, I'm still a huge fan of image links - they're natural, they make sense in a backlink profile, etc. - and it certainly could have changed since then.
Honestly, from a practical standpoint, I usually wouldn't sweat image vs. text (get what you can if it's a great link source!), but from a technical level, my guess is that anchor text in HTML text is still slightly more influential than an image + alt attribute.
-
I am not aware of any search engine throttling the amount of PR or authority that is passed on by a link based on link type. If you or anyone else has any information on this topic, I would love to take a look at it.
-
Exactly, same idea that I'd like to test out too. Hopefully we'll hear feedback from others too on this.
In regards to PR and Page Authority going through and image link or text link, do you feel like the same strength would be passed through either form of link? (Not taking anchor text into consideration, just PR/Page Authority)
-
I thought about this same issue recently. On my next project where I encounter this topic, I plan to experiment with creating a div which contains the text and the image, then providing a single link for the div.
Basically, if you have a page with a linked image, and then a text link below the image, I would rather make that area a single clickable link rather then two separate links. I would need to do a bit of experimentation from a SEO perspective but it is something to think about.
-
Thanks for the solid reply Kent. I agree with your feedback and I'm looking a bit deeper to see if it would be smart to link an image and text phrase together.
Any thoughts on that? It could be easier for the user because they could click on both, and there would be less links on the page which could be good. But I wonder if search engines would attribute the anchor text to the link if it also includes an image?
-
Search engines are constantly changing their algorithms but to the best of my knowledge the below is accurate:
-
the first link to a given URL on a page is what's counted. The anchor text from the 2nd and further links would not offer value.
-
the order search engines go by is the order the links are seen as they read the page's code which may differ from how you see the links on the page
-
I believe link text offers more value then alt text. We know Google would prefer to weigh factors that a user can see such as text on a page, over a tag which can be stuffed with anything. With that said, since Google cannot see an image they are vulnerable and have to rely on us to tell them what is in the image. Lindsay offers a different opinion, see link below.
Additional reading:
http://www.seomoz.org/qa/view/26507/alt-text-vs-anchor-text
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/results-of-google-experimentation-only-the-first-anchor-text-counts
-
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How can I identify links that point to a specific landing page with a specific anchor text on my own website?
I am trying to identify buttons and links that point to a specific landing page on our website that have a certain word in the anchor text and I would like to know the referring page URL too. Does anybody have an idea on how to do this? We have above a hundred landing pages and I would rather not go through them one by one 😄 Thanks for the help
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | 10to8-Moz0 -
AMP Benefits
Hello, Does AMP have ranking benefits ? Should I just AMP my post or all the pages of my website, product page, homepage etc... Thank you,
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | seoanalytics0 -
Google WMT/search console showing thousands of links in "Internal Links"
Hi, One of our blog-post has been interlinked with thousands of internal links as per search console; but lists only 2 links it got connected from. How come so many links it got connected internally? I don't see any. Thanks, Satish
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | vtmoz0 -
OK to change the anchor text of a link?
I have built a link on behalf of a ciient in a long, well-written article on a reputable website that accepts contributor accounts. I therefore control the link. I have since realised that the anchor text of the link could be optimized much better than it currently is (while still only being a partial match). Would I be punished by the algorithm for going in and changing the link? I know it's not 100% "natural," but then we're SEOs, and i don't think it's too implausible that a website owner may go in and do the same... Maybe if I add some text as well, it would make things look more natural?
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | zakkyg1 -
Does Navigation Bar have an effect on the link juice and the number of internal links?
Hi Moz community, I am getting the "Avoid Too Many Internal Links" error from Moz for most of my pages and Google declared the max number as 100 internal links. However, most of my pages can't have internal links less than 100, since it is a commercial website and there are many categories that I have to show to my visitors by using the drop down navigation bar. Without counting the links in the navigation bar, the number of internal links is below 100. I am wondering if the navigation bar links affect the link juice and counted as internal links by Google. The Same question also applies to the links in the footer. Additionally, how about the products? I have hundreds of products in the category pages and even though I use pagination I still have many links in the category pages (probably more than 100 without even counting the navigation bar links). Does Google count the product links as internal links and how about the effect on the link juice? Here is the website if you want to take a look: http://www.goldstore.com.tr Thank you for your answers.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | onurcan-ikiz0 -
More bad links
Hi, After a recent disastrous dalliance with a rogue SEO company I disavowed quite a few domains (links he had gained) which I was receiving a penalty of about 23 places. I cleaned up the site and added meta descriptions where missing, and deleted duplicate titles and pages. This gained me another 5 places. In the meantime I have been getting a few links from wedding blogs, adobe forums and other relevant sites so was expecting an upward momentum. Since the high point of bottom of page 1 I have slowly slid back down to near the bottom of page two for my main keywords. Just checked my webmaster tools latest links and another 4 domains have appeared (gained by the dodgy SEO) : domain:erwinskee.blog.co.uk domain:grencholerz.blog.co.uk domain:valeriiees.blog.co.uk domain:gb.bizin.eu They all look bad so I am going to disavow. I expect to find an improvement when I disavow these new domains. As I have said, have started using the open site explorer tool to check my competitors backlinks and getting some low level links(I'm a wedding photographer) like forum comments and blog comments and good directories. I know there is much more than this to SEO and plan on raising my game as time progresses. I have also gained more links from the domains I disavowed on the 8th January mostly from www.friendfeed.com. will webmaster tools ignore any new links from previously disavowed domains? Like I have said I know there are better ways to get links, but are these links (forum comments, blog comments and respectable directories) one way of raising my rankings? To be honest that is all my competitors have got other than some of the top boys might have a photograph or two on another site with a link. No-one has a decent article or review anywhere (which is my next stage of getting links). Thanks! David.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | WallerD0 -
Too many links?
I've recently taken over a site from another agency, which has hundreds of linking root domains. These domains are of very low quality and, in my opinion, are being ignored by Google. Is it best to 'clean up' some of these links, or leave them and start building quality links? I just don't want to waste time cleaning link profiles if there's no need.
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | A_Q0 -
Maximum of 100 links on a page vs rel="nofollow"
All, I read within the SEOmoz blog that search engines consider 100 links on a page to be plenty, and we should try (where possible) to keep within the 100 limit. My question is; when a rel="nofollow" attribute is given to a link, does that link still count towards your maximum 100? Many thanks Guy
Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Horizon0