Do facebook shares pass share juice the same way links pass link juice?
-
If i have a page on my domain say PAGE-A and let's say it's located at:
http://www.mydomain.com/something/page-a and this page has quite a lot of page authority from many many inbound links. It is my understanding that if i "sculpt" the internal links on PAGE-A to point at only my primary targets, let's call the PAGE-B, PAGE-C, and PAGE-D; then those pages would gain some benefit from this link juice flowing through.
Consider a similar situation where i have a page, say PAGE-F located at: http://www.mydomain.com/anotherpage/page-F
and page-F gets 150 facebook shares. would the links on page-F pass this benefit on in any way? Or is only the direct target of the facebook share gaining benefit from this facebook sharing?
Furthermore, lets consider a scenario where there are 30 or 40 similar pages like PAGE-F all with links out to my primary targets. Would these primary targets gain anything as these 30 or 40 pages gained facebook shares?
Repeat above question, replace 'facebook' with 'twitter'. repeat again for 'google+' ?
-
Exactly how and if Facebook shares affect ranking is the subject of speculation. The only hard facts are what Google tells us:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxTmZulcQZ0
Everything shared in the video is exactly what I mentioned in the initial reply.
Beyond this point we can only analyze, test and draw conclusions (i.e. best guesses). Some great analysis of the topic:
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/does-google-use-facebook-shares-to-influence-search-rankings
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/facebook-twitters-influence-google-search-rankings
A conclusion drawn from the above, which I agree with is "Earning Facebook shares (probably) will not directly boost your Google rankings (though it may have positive effects that indirectly promote links, tweets and other signals Google may use)."
Based on the above sources, I maintain the position shared in the original reply. I absolutely could be wrong which I freely acknowledge. I am simply sharing the knowledge I have acquired on this topic.
-
Hmmm I see your point but it seems naive to assume that google can't see how many times a link has been shared on facebook. It seems like a pretty simple bit of code to hook into their API and return the total number of shares. Who's to say they wouldn't use this data?
Let's assume for a moment that there are T number of total shares, and X visible shares, while I invisible shares for a given link. We could say that T = X + I.
Further more if we assume that each share on facebook has an associated Page authority, lets call it Pa. And let's also assume that each page that is invisible to google has an unknown page authority Po. Then it would follow that the total link juice passed by a facebook share would be something like:
Link Juice = SUM-of-Pa-from-0-to-X + SUM-of-Po-from-X-to-T
If we were to assume that on average Po was equal to the average page authority of the visible share pages, then we could conclude that
Po = (Sum-of-Pa-from-0-to-X) / X = PAverage
So you'de get: Link Juice = SUM-of-Pa-from-0-to-X + PAverage*(T-X)
Since they are capable of caluculating both of these quantities (all known variables) then i think it follows they they would be able to calculate the rough value of a link shared via facebook.
If i can do this pseudo math on the back of a napkin, who's to say that Google's engineers couldn't figure this one out?
So can we still safely assume that google treats facebook shares the same way they treat other links? I highly doubt it. Espcially because of the fact that most of them, like you say, are nofollow, yet despite their nofollow and invisibility, they still effect rankings (at least they do in my experience).
-
The first question is, are the facebook shares visible? Try logging out of facebook and then viewing the link. Can you see it?
Many facebook shares are not visible due to various settings. If the sharer only shares links with friends, then you wont see the link. Another example is if the topic is flagged as adult by facebook, or if it has any age restriction, you wont see the link. By "you" I mean a user which is not logged in such as the Google crawler. Those links do not flow link juice.
Additionally, if the link is nofollow which they usually (?always) are, then they do not pass link juice.
In short, a facebook or twitter share is not different then any other web page. The basic questions are: can the crawler see the link? is the link followed? does the linking page have any PR? etc.
With respect to Google+, it is the newest server and only recently out of beta. Clearly Google crawlers can crawl their own site as they wish. With that said, in the past Matt Cutts has shared Google crawlers respected the privacy from other Google properties so my guess is the same website rules apply. I am not aware of any study which confirms or rejects this information.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Does anyone have a great way to determine where your new Twitter followers are finding you?
We are enjoying some good success with finding new Twitter followers for our account, but the majority of the new followers do not seem to be coming as a result of our posts. How can I determine where these new followers are finding us? Google Analytics can explain those coming from our website but what about the others? Thanks to all for helping!
Social Media | | tempegov
Kris0 -
Facebook Business page query
Hello Expert, I want to check how many facebook pages do my competitor have created? Is there any way to check or tool available? Is there any way to check profile page of competitor from there facebook page? I am providing 4 services on my website so do i create seperate page for all services? or one common page for all 4 services? what type of name should i create for profile and business page?
Social Media | | bkmitesh0 -
Social shares: A ranking factor or not?
Open Site Explorer lists them and every so-called SEO expert says social signals/shares are a ranking factor. Everyone but Matt Cutts, it would seem. So if they're not a ranking factor, why show them in Open Site Explorer?
Social Media | | Jeepster0 -
Facebook Likes gone through the roof
Howdy, We have seen our Facebook Likes increase by a staggering 20k in a week. At the beginning of last week we were sat at around 21k and it has been steadily increasing, but just 7 days later we now have 42k - Has their been some sort of algorithm change for this to happen, or should I be suspicious that something is not quite right? Thanks, James
Social Media | | Wedideas0 -
Social data for links
Hey can anyone recommend a tools out there, which can look at a list of urls (over 20+) and it will show the social stats for each url (e.g. number of Facebook Shares, Tweets, etc)? Or a tool which searchers within a certain category or niche (might be based on the keyword you entered), and finds the most shared content? Cheers, Chris
Social Media | | MBASydney0 -
What is regular link building plan ?
what type of link i need to build on regular basis? blog article directory any more ?
Social Media | | constructionhelpline0 -
Facebook corporate child pages
Any word on if this ever launched http://www.insidefacebook.com/2011/07/11/parent-child-corporate-local-locations-pages-places/ and if so how do I enable?
Social Media | | webfeatseo0 -
Moderate blog comments Yes/No? Facebook comment plugin?
I was reading outbound marketing and they suggest that a good blog "does not" moderate comments. I have always taken the moderate approach, but their thought was this inhibits a conversation from taking place on the blog. I am wondering what thoughts others may have on this and its potential positive and negative impacts, both SEO and in general. Also I am thinking about using a Facebook plugin with my blogposts. I think this may be a good way to help get social visibility... Has anyone tried this yet?
Social Media | | mmaes0