Are web directories worth the effort?
-
I'm looking to see what sites my competitors are linked from via the open site explorer and all I see are web directories and when I visit these sites it seems they want you to part with $20 in exchange for a link.
It obviously works as the sites I am researching are on page one for the keyword I am targeting.
For example
Site 1
- Has 18,222 followed links and 1,089 no followed links
- Has 243 linking root domains and 17 NoFollowed linking root domains
Site 2 & 3 are very similar
My site is only 2 months old and has 85 followed, 10 NoFollowed and 4 linking root domains and 3 NoFollowed.
My domain Authority is 15 my 3 competitors I'm tracking are between 30 and 45.
In spite of this huge gulf I still rank half way up page two!
I'd be really grateful if someone could explain to me what the followed links, NoFollewed links etc all means and also the opinion on getting links from web directories.
Thanks for your time - Jay
-
Thanks guys for the really in depth responses.
As a novice the feedback is very much appreciated. I've been concentrating on getting what I consider to be high quality links from relevant sites to my business and I think it has had a big impact but am keen to learn other ways I can increase my ranking from on page seo -
The term I'm targeting in the UK is independent mortgage advice and my site is at www.keystonemortgages.co.uk
If anyone has time to have a quick glance and inform me of any glaring mistakes I'd be eternally grateful!
Thanks again
Jay
-
thanks EGOL. I'm just in a near panic - getting close to that "guru" label in mozPoints. So I need to find a way to get them to let me keep the "authority" label if/when I cross that threshold
-
Enjoyed this answer, Alan. Thanks!
-
Some outstanding replies shared by Alan and Ross.
-
Hi Jay,
I agree with Alan on this one. There are so many factors effecting how you rank that simply counting up the links is not the way to do it.
The best way to go about your online marketing practices is to take a more holistic approach and start looking at metrics that matter more to your bottom line. Lets have a look at the traffic trends and the top reffering keywords to your site.
Plugin webmaster tools to your analytics and take the average rank data fir the top keywords and create a customer report to show you what keywords are the highest converting and spend more time and effort cultivating a search engine friendly environment targeting those keywords.
Look at the conversion rate of your site and think of ways to increase it through adding different elements like Testimonials or video content.
To answer your question more directly: yes getting links from directories do work to an extent just like any link building activity will work to an extent but like Alan said it is all relative. The is no way to answer the question directly as there are so many factors involved in how your page ranks in the SERPs.
Hope this helps.
-
Jay,
There are hundreds of factors in SEO. Each of those cross-relate to each other, to make tens of thousands of sub-factors. Just because competitors appear to get links from paid directories does not itself mean that's how they got higher domain authority, ranking, or anything else. This is a great example of a common phrase in our industry - "correlation does not equal causation".
So essentially, there could be many other factors involved you're not mentioning, and that I assume you're not necessarily considering as truly important.
How many pages does each of those sites have? How well optimized are each individual page, each section of each of those sites? What is the depth quality of content on any individual page, or section of those sites? How well do those sites convey topical relevance to a specific search phrase compared to your site? What social signals do those sites have that you don't? What is the quality of those?
What does the rest of the inbound link profile look like for those sites?
The list goes on an on.
So - to answer your broader question - are web directories worth the effort? They may be. Are those directories relevant to the topical focus of your site? Are they relevant to the market you are trying to reach for your site? Are they trust-worthy directories that are less likely to be flagged by Google as link farms?
These are the kind of questions you need to be asking to see if they're worth investing in. Yet only after you consider all of the issues I described above, and see where you can improve any of the factors I described as relate to your own site.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Best of the Web Still Prime Backlink Real Estate
Hello, I was doing competitive research and our top competitor has a clean backlink profile that includes the Best Of The Web directory. The top people on this Q&A used to recommend them and DMOZ for the only true good directory links. Is this still true or is Best Of The Web less important now? We only are listed in a small handful of directories, and not anything recent besides DMOZ. Thanks, Bob
Competitive Research | | BobGW2 -
Blocking Competitive Analysis Tools in robots.txt.... Worth it?
I've been considering blocking third party crawlers for a while – specifically those crawling my website for the sake of competitive analysis, such as SEMrush and Ahrefs. I'm familiar with how to do so, but when researching the question I found practically no one asking the same question. The guides I've found on what to put in your robots.txt make no mention of whether to block competitive analysis crawlers. Which makes me wonder whether this is a good idea after all. My chief concern here is rival sites going after the same search terms we target – one of our competitors in particular has an uncanny way of going after the same searches we are. I know blocking crawlers won't prevent competitors from watching our content, but it will make it slightly harder for them. Is there any major drawback I'm missing? Any big reason not to go ahead and block SEO analysis crawlers?
Competitive Research | | davidwaring0 -
Currently Number 2 - Worth Shooting for 1?
Hello SEO Community, So I was able to rise to #2 in a highly competitive search term after a guest blog post that I wrote really took off (wish I could recreate that for my other terms, haha) Anyway, I steadily rose from 30ish to number 2 and have obviously seen more traffic, which is awesome and I'm happy. But still, in terms of the amount of traffic that google estimates the keyword gets, and the amount I'm getting at #2, it seems like #1 is getting the VAST majority (I know this is how most markets work). Judging from my link profile compared to #1, it would be extremely difficult to dethrone them. So what do y'all think? Is it worth spending time and resources shooting for the glory and traffic of #1 and potentially never getting there - or focusing my efforts on my middling keywords and getting those on the first page as well?
Competitive Research | | CleanEdisonInc0 -
Analysis tool that returns all possible phrases that a web site ranks for
Is there anything out there similar to the semrush.com's competitor research that can tell you a web sites total amount of appearances on Google that includes the phrases for which the domain ranks?
Competitive Research | | thebaldman30 -
Www.seoprofiler.com - anyone knows the service? worth the investment?
A little help just to check if the service worth the money spend.
Competitive Research | | Naghirniac0 -
What's the best way to make sure a link is worth getting?
I know what tools to use and I use all of SEOmoz's tools daily. PA, DA, MR, & MT are all things I take into account, but sometimes all you have to do is look at a site and you can tell it's not worth it. I'll analyze the page's backlink's and everything in between. Are there any tricks out there that can help the decision making process? I'm tired of trying to get links on sites that clearly are not worth it, but all of their stats say otherwise. So do you stick with stats, or is it a judgement call? I'm particularly curious about determining the amount of possible traffic from a link. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!
Competitive Research | | MichaelWeisbaum0 -
Business Directories and Spammy Link Profile
Hi, have been reading a lot about submissions to directories and posting spamming blogs and forums and how they're a bad idea, saw a great post on it by Rand in a white board Friday lecture, the only thing is I've been analysing a company and that appears to be what makes up its entire link profile, all the links point to their home page with their primary phrase as the anchor text. Just wondered how a company with some 4k links the majority being follows, hasn't been penalised for what are a really bad set of back links. Should add that this is an insurance company, they're no light weights in their industry but certainly not one of the big boys. Thanks, Lee Example here
Competitive Research | | LeeMiller0 -
Multiple links from Dmoz/Google directories worldwide
I came across www.soundandvision.com and did a Link Analysis on them.... http://www.opensiteexplorer.org/www.soundandvision.com/a!links I noticed that the top links they have are from Google directories or Google IP's. How has this happened? I am listed in Dmoz in the UK does this mean I have automatically appeared around the world. Dmoz is pretty strict about rejecting links how can a company be listed so much? Is this a good practise? Cheers
Competitive Research | | JohnW-UK1