Stolen Content and a Panda Penalty
-
Hey Folks
Question for those folks that have spent some time helping people with the recent penalties and the like.
I have a client who has a clear Panda Penalty, huge drop in traffic on the initial Panda date and a further drop on the second date. Much smaller incremental drops on subsequent recent updates as well.
From digging in it seems fairly cut and dry - copyscape shows another 250 or so sites with content from this site and there are nearly 2000 external URLs with duplicate content across these sites.
We are talking complete, shameless copies of all of the text, sometimes the images as well.
The client claims the content is all 100% unique and is his content and that the other blogs must have stolen his content resulting in the penalty - which, if it is true, and I have no reason to suspect otherwise, kind of sucks.
Now, many moons ago, way before Penguin or Panda (maybe around 2006) I had a client that had suddenly lost all traffic and their historical rankings. No funny business, it was a small company, had been online since around 2000 and they were pretty much the first of their kind and always did very well from organic search.
As it turned out, the content from the site had not really changed since it was set up and as lots of companies had sprung up offering a similar service they had seen their content copied wholesale, across many sites, all over the world.
We attempted to contact many of these sites and got some results but many were just old, abandoned copy cat sites on advert supported hosting that had ceased to trade so we maybe got rid of about 20%.
Well, in the end we just decided to rewrite the content, we did this and sure enough, the site bounced back to it's previous standing and has been pretty much there ever since.
Now that was kind of easy, the site had maybe 20 pages, and it needed a sprucing up but in this case the site has around 500 pages so doing a rewrite is not going to be so easy.
Problem is, I don't see removal requests being particularly successful either.
So, I see the options and steps as being.
- Contact all the sites and request the removal of the content
- use the Google content removal facility:
https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/removals - File a DMCA takedown for anything remaining
- Report Scraped Pages to Google:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/viewform?formkey=dGM4TXhIOFd3c1hZR2NHUDN1NmllU0E6MQ&ndplr=1 - Submit a spam report for all sites involved ?
- Submit a reconsideration request to let Google know what we have been doing (unlikely
In a nutshell, do everything we can to get this content removed and then documenting this to Google in the hope we catch hold of someone who hears our plight.
Interestingly enough, this is a sensitive one, so no URL but I would welcome any thoughts or experiences any of you may have had with similar problems.
There is a little extra info here from Matt Cutts + Barry Schwartz that kind of tallies with my approach above but would really like to hear any feedback.
http://www.seroundtable.com/google-stolen-content-13243.html
Cheers all
Marcus
-
Hey, I used copyscape to locate all the content and have suggested copyscape sentry going forward. The problem is for this site the scale of the copying, it seems to go back several years and is pretty widespread.
Cheers!
Marcus
-
Hey Egol
Well, this was kind of my initial suggestion to the client. I simply don't think that the pain and suffering and ultimately waiting to get this resolved is worth the effort and a rewrite is likely the easiest (if still painful option).
I guess, I just want to give this guy all of the options, and my advice so if they want to have a shot at getting the content taken down then they can have at least have a go. This way, I can advise, show the various pathways and my experience but they can choose how to tackle the issue.
At times, this job is a lot like dealing with my kids, I give advice based on years of painful experience, they choose the difficult path, what can you do?
For some folks, the fact that this happens is too much for them to take on board and despite it being exactly what it is - I do understand the 'digging your heals in' approach to wanting to get other sites to take it all down - i also from painful experience know that sometimes you just have to take your punches and get on with a rewrite.
Thanks for the input!
Cheers!
Marcus -
Well DMCA will hurt more than help. (the time you lose) but what you can do is to grad a copyscape account, upgrade it at pro and keep track of all your unique content. If your sales are based on this factor is worth trying. Also have a look at the hosting providers, they may have the same rules.
Act as fast as copyspace announce you there is a problem. Now you may ask me how to act? Well all the steps are listed above. Google rules still apply for filling a DMCA request at chillingeffects they can remove content from google search results.
Take a look at this screenshot Is in romanian, but it says that Chillingeffects took actions are removed x pages/websites duo to DMCA.
-
Glad to hear. Please give us updates on how everything is going.
-
I sell a few specialty outdoor sport items that are branded by a US company but manufactured in China. Several years ago I wrote unique, detailed descriptions for these items that were much more detailed than the brand owner's.
My pages used to rank really well for the generic item names (similar to "rock climbing shoes"). Then at least 100 "made in China" websites grabbed my descriptions and posted them verbatim. My rankings tanked in Google. I didn't even get much long tail from google.
I felt that it was a waste of time to contact all of those websites and try to get them to stop using my content. They are outside of the USA and they would probably laugh at a DMCA.
So, I have a choice of rewriting that content or discontinuing sales.
-
Hey, great advice, many thanks. The hosting provider is a great idea, allows us to go in via the back door, I like it.
-
I may not be a guru, but if the story is true (uniquer content), there are several steps you can take to regain the traffic and lose the penality. I'm glad to see the steps already listed on your comment, but there are too many and I would recommend you to focus on this 3 steps +1 extra step.
-
Remove any website which stole the content from your client using the link you have provided.
-
File a DMCA - This is a must! Stolen content is stolen so you have all the rights to file a DMCA.
-
Report the scrapped content. Now here is the catch. Give clear informations. Google staff will not sit to check the original post dates, names of who made the content or anything else so besure to offer this informations, even screenshots if you/your client have. Also have a look on waybackmachine and if the pages are stored there be sure to give the link to it!
You need to do all this work to prove your client content is unique and it was scrapped/copied.
Extra Step: Try to find where are that websites hosted and file a DMCA to the hosting provider (fastes way). Let them know they are hosting website which have copied/scrapped content and that you are going to take all the actions against them if they do not take that website/page down. 95% of the hosting providers have a rule which says "no illegal content allowed".
This is how I normally act with this kind of situations.
I may not be to helpfull in your situation, but this is how I normally act.
-
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
How important is exact keyword match in content for SEO in 2018?
Is it necessary to have the exact keyword which you are trying to rank for within the first sentence of the content on your web page? For example if we are selling men's shoes, is it ok to have have the meta title and h1 on page say men's shoes and just talk about shoes within the first sentence of the content on the page. Is it obvious to search engines that this page is selling men's shoes even if you don't have the word men's shoes in that first sentence or is it necessary to have the exact keywords which you are trying to rank for written there?
Content Development | | whiteonlySEO0 -
Content - Similar but not exactly the same content - Duplicate or Spammy?
Hey, so I have been wondering for some time now as some pages will get indexed and others won't appear at all. That makes me think that I am either creating to similar content or it is becoming too spammy. Take these two pages I created for example. The body content is very similar but h tags, meta tags and title are different. So my questions is; would pages not be displaying due possibly being too similar and spammy or duplicate? I have linked two pages that are very similar below and would love to hear any thoughts about it. https://www.dlmremovals.com.au/queensland/interstate/removalists/gold-coast-to-ballarat-removalist-backloads-and-moving-service.html https://www.dlmremovals.com.au/queensland/interstate/removalists/gold-coast-to-bendigo-removalist-backloads-and-moving-service.html Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.
Content Development | | Niclasfa0 -
Images & Duplicate Content Issues
Here's a scenario for you: The site is running WordPress and the images are uploaded to the media section. You can set image attributes there such as the Description & Alt Tag. Let's say you'd like to reuse the same image in two different blog posts. The image keeps the same Description & Alt Tag associated with it in the media section. Would this be considered duplicate content? What would be the best practice in this case to reuse the same image in multiple posts?
Content Development | | VicMarcusNWI0 -
Duplicate Content & Tags
I've recently added tags to my blog posts so that related blog posts are suggested to visitors. My understanding was that my robot.txt was handling duplicate content so thought it wouldn't be an issue but after Moz crawled by site this week is reported 56 issues of duplicate content in my blog. I'm using Shopify, so I can edit the robot.txt file but is my understanding correct that if there are 2 or more tags then they will be ignored? I've searched the Shopify documents and forum and can't find a straight answer. My understanding of SEO is fairly limited. Disallow: /blogs/+
Content Development | | Tangled
Disallow: /blogs/%2B
Disallow: /blogs/%2b0 -
Knowledge base for seo, announcing new articles on blog (dupe content)
Hi all, Im thinking of creating a knowledge base with all many asked questions in my company. This could be a great Link-bait source but also nice ranking opportunities i think. But sometimes some new articles are so actual that i also want to blog them.
Content Development | | mdkay
Can i for example double post them (or post a big excerpt) on the blog and canonicalise it to the KB article?
Will links to the blog have equal value to KB links? And will this work?0 -
Same content on site blog as a separate blog. Will unpublishing on one blog evade duplicate content issues?
I just discovered my client was posting the same content as the site I'm working on for him on a separate blog. I don't want to run into duplicate content issues. Both are Wordpress sites. Will it suffice to simply unpublish duplicate entries on the other blog and leave the posts as drafts?
Content Development | | locallyrank0 -
Using testimonials to build quality content
I don't see a lot of talk on here about using testimonials to build good content. From what I have seen, the search engines love client testimonials. I haven't found a good service provider for this yet. I'm thinking something combined with Twitter or FB that also allows you to show the content on your site would be great. Can anyone recommend a service like this? I'm checking out a service called, "Quick Vouch" but I haven't tested it yet.
Content Development | | BradBorst0 -
For a consumer facing blog, how often do you recommend updating content to develop good rankings? I understand that it's really dependent upon the niche/competition, but what are some best practices? Content is expensive. Thanks
For a consumer facing blog, how often do you recommend updating content to develop good rankings? I understand that it's really dependent upon the niche/competition, but what are some best practices? Content is expensive. Thanks
Content Development | | CSOD19990