Categories in Places Vs Local
-
Say you are listed with both Google places and Google Local. Places still allows custom categories, while Local limits you to preset categories. Which is the better strategy: to build service pages following custom services available in Places, or build out service pages following the (allowed) preset categories in Local.
-
Hi Miriam,
I think budget issues are always a consideration. I'm with you: if the owner doesn't get that this is a long term effort to increase their business, then I tell them I can't help them.
I tell them that my job is to increase their business and that I need a commitment of time and money to do so. I generally try to get them to commit for a one year period and a budget large enough to actually accomplish something.
These kinds of customers are harder to find, but, once I do, because I have the time and money to get a result, they tend to become more or less permanent customers.
My biggest challenge is explaining what I'm going to do and how this will result in more business.
-
Hi Wayne,
So glad to help! Thanks for suggesting a post on this topic - I'll think this over!
What I have experienced with customer resistance has typically revolved around budget. I've worked with a lot of very small local businesses over the years and they are concerned about being able to afford content development (particularly when they don't have the skills/resources to create it themselves). Sometimes, I have been able to offer an austerity plan to a local business owner - something like just one new page per month once the basic website has been built. Typically they can afford this. In a year, they've added 12 new pages.
This is nothing like some of the Local SEO projects going on out there where people are building hundreds of pages, of course, but it is at least some progress. The hope is that if the company starts getting more business from even a small web presence, they will eventually be able to afford to invest more in things like content development. But I do think there is a threshold for every business. If the owner can't make even a modest investment, he's not going to be able to utilize the web to promote his company. I've had to turn business owners away who just don't get this.
How about you, Wayne? Do you have clients with budget issues or does resistance to growth stem from something else?
-
Hi Miriam,
Great answer. I especially like your differentiation on "is" and "does" and agree 100% about the importance of mapping content to research and trying to cover as many bases as you can.
I've long been involved with national campaigns, but this is my first local job. I knew the categories would be crucial, but wasn't sure about the best approach. With your roadmap, I know exactly what to do.
You should consider a post on this issue. This is a crucial issue for local, and I bet a lot of people aren't getting this.
How do you deal with customer resistance to expanded/ongoing content?
-
Hi Wayne,
That's what I thought. Here's my take on this. There are two distinct types of keywords you can optimize a local business website for. I think of these as 'is' and 'does'.
Examples of 'Is' Keywords:
Plumber
Arborist
Dog Walker
Examples of 'Does' Keywords
Plumbing
Tree Trimming
Dog Walking
In other words, one set says what a business 'is', the other set says what a business 'does'. Google has always wanted categories, whether custom created or chosen from their pre-set taxonomy, to reflect what a business is - never what it does. In optimizing a local business' website, it is certainly important to include these kinds of 'is' keywords in your work, but you shouldn't limit yourself to this. You'll want to include relevant 'does' keywords, too, because people certainly search both ways.
Keyword research will, of course, be vital to determining which kinds of 'is' keywords are being searched for most for a given business. I consider that Google's pre-set category taxonomy (the only one that will be available to any business once all listings have transitioned to the new Places for Business dashboard) gives us certain clues about how Google understands and organizes types of business. Since we care so much about Google rankings, we need to pay attention to what Google is signalling to us and incorporate these very big hints into our optimization. But we need to build additional content that reflects all the other findings of our kw research, there will typically be lots of 'does' terms in there.
This line of reasoning is why I have to be very frank with low-budget clients who come to me saying that they only want a one-page website, or a five-page website. There are so many keywords we should ideally be optimizing for, and there's no way to cram them all into a tiny site. Pretty much every local business, even if they have to start small, should have a plan for content development that will grow the size of their website to eventually include lots of different keywords. When you start small, though, Google's pre-set categories definitely need to be given consideration, in addition to the most searched terms discovered in your keyword research.
Long answer! But, you've asked a very good question, Wayne, and I wanted to give you a big-picture view of this, based on what I've experienced. Hope this helps!
-
Linda, I thought your answer did a good job of explaining certain facets of the two dashes, even if it wasn't quite what Wayne was asking about
-
Hi Miriam,
That's exactly what I'm asking: should I build out my website service pages as per the custom categories available in Places or per preset categories available in + Local?
-
So sorry I was rushing to prep for a webinar. Think I totally misread the question, so please ignore my answer.
Somebody give me a big thumbs down. ;-(
-
Hi Wayne,
You've received some thoughtful replies here, but I'm not sure your question has been answered you. You write:
"Which is the better strategy: to build service pages following custom services available in Places, or build out service pages following the (allowed) preset categories in Local."
I believe you may be talking about building out service pages on a website, not about altering a Google+ Local page. Is this correct? Are you asking whether your website-based service landing pages should be optimized to reflect the old custom category system or the new Google+ Local pre-set category taxonomy? Could you please clarify. I want to be certain you receive a helpful answer.
-
If by local you mean you've merged with G+, then FYI after you merge with G+ you are not supposed to edit anything in the old Places dash any more at all anyway, so there is really no "which is better" strategy. You are limited by which dash you are in and whether you have merged or not (which if you have not do not BTW.)
Plus custom cats are going away soon. Google is upgrading everyone to the new Places dash, which like Google+ does not allow custom cats. THEN they are auto-upgrading everyone to G+ so everyone will have a merged page, which again does not allow custom cats.
So both the old dash and custom cats will be gone soon. Sad...
-
I notice that competitors who set up places accounts before Local (which I did not have the opportunity to do) do better in search for subcategories of specialties that aren't listed in the preset categories. I'm sure Google will eventually deal with this, but I would say if you have the opportunity to include categories that aren't on the preset list, it may give you a leg up.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
What can be the cause for difference in local rankings between mobile and desktop?
I have a site that ranks differently for the same search term on mobile and desktop computer. I'm based in Glasgow, and the search term is (I've replaced the term with X's) XXXXXX XXXXX Glasgow Searching from a location in Glasgow: Desktop: Snackpack : 2, Organic : 6
Technical SEO | | johanisk
Mobile: Snackpack: 1, Organic : 10 I'm keen to improve on the Organic positions as this term is a lead generating one for me. My site is mobile friendly and scores 69/100 on the speed test. Do you think bumping the pagespeed well "into the green" would help improve it's position? Is there anything else I should look at?0 -
URL Structure On Site - Currently it's domain/product-name NOT domain/category/product name is this bad?
I have a eCommerce site and the site structure is domain/product-name rather than domain/product-category/product-name Do you think this will have a negative impact SEO Wise? I have seen that some of my individual product pages do get better rankings than my categories.
Technical SEO | | the-gate-films0 -
Use of multiple keywords that are similar for one local site
Hi I thought that if I wanted to rank a local site for the core Keyword, 'Landscaping Location' that variations of this keyword should be used on the same page. But I recently read that if I wanted to rank for: Landscaping Location
Technical SEO | | CamperConnect14
Landscaping in Location
Landscaping Services in Location that I should use separate page for each term. Is this correct? A small local website will probably only have a few pages and so making up pages solely to go after Keywords can't be right. But then would opportunities be missed? Thanks for your help with this!!0 -
Google how deal with licensed content when this placed on vendor & client's website too. Will Google penalize the client's site for this ?
One of my client bought licensed content from top vendor of Health Industry. This same content is on the vendor's website & my client's site also but on my site there is a link back to vendor is placed which clearly tells to anyone that this is a licensed content & we bought from this vendor. My client bought paid top quality content for best source of industry but at this same this is placed on vendor's website also. Will Google penalize my client's website for this ? Niche is HEALTH
Technical SEO | | sourabhrana1 -
Tags, Categories, & Duplicate Content
Looking for some advice on a duplicate content issue that we're having that definitely isn't unique to us. See, we are allowing all our tag and category pages, as well as our blog pagination be indexed and followed, but Moz is detecting that all as duplicate content, which is obvious since it is the same content that is on our blog posts. We've decided in the past to keep these pages the way they are as it hasn't seemed to hurt us specifically and we hoped it would help our overall ranking. We haven't seen positive or negative signals either way, just the warnings from Moz. We are wondering if we should noindex these pages and if that could cause a positive change, but we're worried it might cause a big negative change as well. Have you confronted this issue? What did you decide and what were the results? Thanks in advance!
Technical SEO | | bradhodson0 -
A/B testing entire website VS Seo issues
I'm familar with A/B testing variations of a page but I'd like to A/B test a new designs version of a e-commerce site. I´m wondering about the best way to test with SEO concerns... this is what I´ve in mind right now, any suggestion? Use parameters to make version B different from A version. Redirect 50% of the users with 302 ( or javascript would be a better way?) Use noindex in the B pages. Use rel=canonical in the B pages pointing to A version. In the end use 301 redirect to all B pages to A urls. PS: We can´t use subdomain and i don´t wanna use robots.txt file to protect the new design from competitors. I´d love any suggestions and tips about it - thanks folks 🙂
Technical SEO | | SeoMartin10 -
Updating inbound links vs. 301 redirecting the page they link to
Hi everyone, I'm preparing myself for a website redesign and finding conflicting information about inbound links and 301 redirects. If I have a URL (we'll say website.com/website) that is linked to by outside sources, should I get those outside sources to update their links when I change the URL to website.com/webpage? Or is it just as effective from a link juice perspective to simply 301 redirect the old page to the new page? Are there any other implications to this choice that I may want to consider? Thanks!
Technical SEO | | Liggins0 -
Duplicate Title tags vs. View All for search results
I run a directory and some search queries give almost 1000 unique results. My moz campaign tells me that I have around 1,300 duplicate title tags etc. I read online about canonical, rel=next/prev, also about having a 'view all' page just for google (page links, not search queries), but if I do this, wouldn't the slowness mean google won't index it? So the question is what is the best thing to do?
Technical SEO | | tguide0