Google Listings EMD Bias
-
I've been looking at 60+ location based searches for the base two months and noticed a big issue I can't explain. I know EMD was hit hard in the general SERPs but it obviously has not effected the location SERPs.
The main way I'm finding these situations is by seeing the 7 pack and it shows a site with only a quarter amount of the citations the other sites have and jumps to the top very quickly. It appears to be working because of the EMD bias in the Local SERPs algorithm.
From what I understand you are not suppose to add a TLD domain into a G+ listing and then 301 redirect it to your real domain but Google doesn't seem to mind at this point. I'm wondering if this tactic is a valid Local tactic at this time or if, from what I understand, it is a shady tactic that will end up hurting brand and have a strong chance of penalizing the real domain.
-
Ben,
If you're not already using it, 51 Blocks Local Competitive Analysis tool is a good one, and it's free:
http://www.51blocks.com/online-marketing-tools/free-local-analysis/
Might be of help to you in your research.
-
I appreciate you taking the time to explain all that. I'm looking at all the usual ranking local ranking factors and need to compile a list of what they have that doesn't "compete" with all the other.
From my initial research it appears that the only thing these listings have in common with each other is an extremely low number of citations, an EMD that redirects to a different URL and they are listed as high as #3 but usually #5 or #6. It's just strange. I haven't looked at a domain ownership timeframe or even if they did possible make a move recently but I will do that.
Thanks again for all your help Jarno and Miriam.
-
Hi Ben,
Very good question. In the Google Places Quality Guidelines, Google states:
-Do not provide phone numbers or URLs that redirect or “refer” users to landing pages or phone numbers other than those of the actual business.
So, from this guideline, we know that Google doesn't want you to list a URL that redirects to something you don't own, but in this case, apparently this business owns TheCarmelDentist.com. They are not redirecting to a domain that doesn't belong to the business.
This scenario brings up questions. Why is this business doing this? One good guess might be that they've bulit this new website at thecarmeldentist.com and have redirected the old fishers site to the new one, but have yet to update their Google+ Local Page to reflect the URL. All attempts to reach the fishers site are redirecting, so the + Local Page is simply redirecting, too. I can't think of any good reason why they wouldn't just simply list the URL, so my best guess is that they just haven't updated the + Page yet.
Looking at this specific scenario, I just doubt that the redirect is being done with an intent to spam. Because the whole old site has apparently been redirected to the new one, I think this business has simply moved to a new domain.
I would also guess that the redirect rule in the guidelines is meant to speak to the practice of either competitive hijacking of listings and redirecting the URLs to competitors' stuff, or, possibly, spammy stuff in which a snake oil marketer might convince a business owner that their URL should be redirecting to some sort of directory page instead of to the company's website. But, it doesn't look like this is what is happening in your example, unless I'm totally overlooking something.
Now, you are quite right that the EMD penalty does not seem to have hit hard in Local. Like you, I see plenty of these rankings just fine. At this point, it is still quite possible to rank well with an EMD, and if the EMD is supported by strong content, it probably won't ever be penalized.
That being said, if asked whether I would personally advise a client to switch from BobJonesDDS.com to carmeldentist.com, just in hopes of a ranking boost, my answer for 2013 would be a resounding 'no'. Every move Google has made over the past 2 years clearly supports, in my eyes, their preference for authentic presentation of brands. If Bob Jones DDS is your brand, then use it, I say. Don't go for the EMD because it doesn't truly represent your brand...it represents an attempt to rank. Google is getting impatient with anything done simply to rank.
Within the scope of Q&A, I can't do a a full competitive analysis of the situation you've highlighted, Ben, but remember, a domain is just a fraction of the local search ranking factors. Don't forget proximity to centroid, business cluster, domain age, links, citations, reviews, etc. All of these things and so much more determine rank. I don't believe an EMD can be seen as THE cause, though it could be part of the cause.
One last note. The dentist in question does have some problems going on. Their +Page is calling them The Fishers Dentist. Their website is calling them The Carmel Dentist and their address listed on their website is Indianapolis. Even if I'm not predicting a swift EMD penalty, the confusion of the signals they are sending to Google about their brand and locale is pretty serious and could lead to all kinds of problems for them. Not good.
Hope these thoughts help. Please, feel free to share more about your study, Ben.
-
Ben,
no, i did not see anyone get kicked out of Google because of something like this. It indeed is theoratical but there is an bigger chance of getting kicked.
I am really trying to imply that you should only use white hat tactics and not black hat. Just advice your client that it is a possibility but that the risks are great and that you're not liable (don't know if this is the right word).. for if the sites does get penalized.
Jarno
-
Thanks for the response Jamo. I'm asking if there is anything that this tactic directly offends in Google's eyes. The reason why I am asking is not so that I can justify it but so that I can speak from more experience than myself.
I've never seen a site get kicked out of the listing because of this so I'm not sure if it is something that I should warn clients about or not.
Have you seen anyone get penalized or is it like me, a theory?
-
Ben,
I would not go there if I were you. Why add a URL and then redirect that URL to another where your site is being set up? Why not include the right domain name then?
I would avoid this tactic. Even if it does work in the short run it could end up with a complete ban from Google. Keep it clear, keep it fair, keep it white hat. Do things you know are honest. This, in no way to my opionon, seems honest.
Regards
Jarno
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
What basics should we be looking at in Google Analytics?
We have GA set up on our site for a while now. However, we do not look at the data. We did today and it's quite overwhelming. Is there anything in specific we should start with? A top 3 items we should start to monitor each week and try to improve? Bonus Question: Is there a way to use analytics to find out who are competitors are?
Competitive Research | | IcarusSEO0 -
(Need helps here!) Can homepage and other internal pages (services) rank high together on Google?
Hi Moz community, Recently I am working on our website's SEO. Our company is a marketing agency. We provide general marketing services and also web design. Here is the content of our homepage and internal pages (specific services). Homepage (marketing agency) Internal page #1 (XXX marketing service) Internal page #2 (YYY marketing service) Internal page #3 (web design) I suggest to my supervisor that we could make some improvement and optimize different keywords for these 4 pages, respectively (homepage, internal page #1 #2 #3). However, my supervisor holds a different point of view that homepage and internal page#3 cannot rank both high for their own keywords because web design is not as related to marketing. So I did some research and look for some top-ranking marketing agency guys who also offer web design. I found their internal pages about web design service rank pretty bad for their own web-design-related keywords. Here are my thoughts and guess (please correct me if I am wrong): Google takes everything into account and deems web design to be kind of irrelevant content to the website, so the internal page for web design will not rank high. The internal page has so much lower power than the homepage so it got outranked by the guys whose homepages are all about web design and development. My question is: In above case, can homepage and other internal pages (our services) all rank high together for their own keywords? I know what I wrote is kind of confusing...But I really need help here and want to solve this problem badly. Really appreciate any help!! Thank you in advance! Best, Raymond
Competitive Research | | Raymondlee0 -
Google Keyword Tool Alternatives
Hey All, So ever since Google shut down the Keyword Tool we have used the keyword planner and a few other tools only to find they aren't quite the same, I was wondering what everyone is using now to get there keyword research and average traffic estimates ? We previous used keyword tool for phrase match and now not much offers phrase match or provides us with what seems as accurate results. We have tried Word Tracker after a numerous amount of research to find a alternative to the keyword tool, and found that the results are very different from the Google Keyword Planner, 1 noticeable result would be of "Web Design Melbourne", in Word Tracker it showed the average search of 9,900 (per month or year I'm not sure) and we compared that to the Google Keyword Planner and it showed 3,000. I have looked over a number of tools and found they weren't quite what we are looking for (Word Tracker, SEMRush, Google Keyword Planner) so I have turned to the MOZ Community. So my first question for everyone would be: A) what do you use for Keyword research and average search estimates now (any good tools with phrase match)? B) If you have used Word Tracker have you found accurate results in your keyword research? If you have found any tools that have proved beneficial and useful please let me know 🙂 (paid or free) Thank you
Competitive Research | | KBB_Digital
Jake Crone0 -
Majestic gives me a 24 situation and 24 trust flow. Seomoz just a total number of 7\. How come the difference? My ranking is still bad, so is Majestic crawling faster then google?
Hi, my total domain value number on SEOmoz is 7. In Majestic it is 24 situation and 24 trust flow. My ranking is still bad (page2) and my competitors have a lower trust/ situation flow in Majestic. But in Seomoz the're better. Is the conclusion that Majestic is more up to date then Google itself and that Seomoz is more inline with the google crawling? Because Majestic doesnt reflect my ranking. (ps I started with the domain for a month, and I only have some history in registration)
Competitive Research | | remkoallertz0 -
Why is razorservers.com the #1 result on Google for dedicated server hosting?
Why is razorservers.com the #1 result on Google for dedicated server hosting? The site also ranks well on Google for the keyword dedicated server. It outranks sites with a PageRank of 7 and 100k+ back-links. Thanks
Competitive Research | | stevenbond0 -
Trying to understand the sporadic and not relevant search results from Google?
Trying to understand the sporadic search results from Google I have been searching for answers to my situation for two
Competitive Research | | rdominey
months now with little results. I have had numerous answers and various
solutions to the issue, and I have followed through with them trying to solve
this problem but the results are the same. Beginning in late April our SERP went down drastically. I
have checked and cleaned the website of any errors and issues that I can find with
no change in the results. I have submitted a request to Google to be
reconsidered and have been told now three times that we are not being manually
penalized. The last request I asked for
any specific reason that we were seeing these very unusual SERP results and got
no answer. The best way that I can explain the issues is with a specific example. These results are similar with other pages throughout the website: www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/ If you search for a specific page Title you get some really strange results: Search for: Gallery Wrap vs Museum Wrap Photos on Canvas The results vary from day to day but for the most part remain very similar: ·** Black and White Photos on Canvas make Amazing
Wall Art** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/.../black-and-white-photos-on-can... Mar 20, 2012 – ... shots to Black and White. What a great way to display your photos on canvas. ... Gallery Wrap vs. Museum Wrap · Before & Afters
That WOW! #53 | PR: ·** Sitemap - Get Your Photos on Canvas** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/sitemap/ Use our Sitemap to help locate exactly what you are looking for and navigate directly to that ... FREE Enhancements · MORE Enhancements · Gallery Wrap vs. #54 | PR: ·** Like Get Your Photos on Canvas on Facebook** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/like-us-on-facebook/ Like Us on Facebook and keep in touch with Special Offers and information about Get Your **...**FREE Enhancements · MORE Enhancements · Gallery Wrap vs. #56 | PR: ·** [Help Get Your Photos on Canvas](http://www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/help/)** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/help/ Our Help Pages have information about Get Your Photos on Canvas, our Gift Cards, What our ... FREE Enhancements · MORE Enhancements · Gallery Wrap vs. #62 | PR: ·** Free Convert to Black and White for Your Photo on
Canvas Prints.** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/free-black-and-white-adjustments/ ... OF CHARGE. We produce the very best quality Black and White Photos on Canvas in the business. ... Wrap vs. Museum Wrap · Before & Afters That WOW! #67 | PR ·** Large Format Photographic Canvas Wall Displays - Get Your Photos ...** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/wall-displays/ Photo on Canvas Wall Displays or Wall Groupings can be produced in a wide variety of Layouts including ... Wrap vs. Museum Wrap · Before & Afters That WOW! #73 | PR The target page does not show up in the top 350 search results yet all of the above pages are listed in the top 100. It is important to note that most of these pages do not even contain the keywords allery Wrap vs Museum Wrap or any variation of those keywords. Yet, they appear in the displayed results? If you search just Gallery Wrap vs Museum Wrap our title page appears as #2 on Google? ·** Gallery Wrap vs Museum Wrap Photos on Canvas** www.getyourphotosoncanvas.com/gallery-wraps-vs-museum-wraps/ Gallery Wrap vs Museum Wrap Canvas, two options for your photo on canvas prints. Find out the difference between Gallery Wrap and Museum Wrap. #2 | PR Just as a point of interest, both keyword phrases score A in on page results. I would be grateful for any ideas or assistance on what might be causing these results and of course guidance on what I need to do to correct the problem. Thank You.0 -
How does a site get to no 3 in Google with no KW in their links?!!
Hello everyone, my first post - ahhh I'm investigating a niche and there is a site that should have no right being there in my view. It's no. 3 Google UK for 'company formation' with a small site with 65 weak links from only 7 domains and hosted in the US. But more importantly, the Open Site Explorer says there is not 1 link with that term in its anchor text. This I find crazy and makes me suspicious. But before I go back to my client saying "oh they must be black hat" I would like your expert views. I'm not sure whether to tut or congratulate them and for the first time I'm not sure what reasons to give for their amazing performance! What's your views?
Competitive Research | | GOYMedia480 -
My client has shown me a similar site, though not a competitor. He wants to know what sites they are linked from that give them such a good Google rank for certain kewords. Can SEOMoz tell me this?
When using google.com.au and searching for "travel to france", www.frenchtravel.com.au is the 3rd organic result. (the 1st two are not travel businesses, they are non profit travel guides) My client, who runs www.visituk.com.au, an Australian site that organises tours of the UK, said "so we just need to add these sort of words to the site?" I said, yes, but it doesn't end there. The real task is to have a link to your site on other sites surrounded with the words "travel" and "UK". He asked if he could see a list of the sites the french site was being referred by relevant to the search phrase. Is there an SEOmoz tool for this? Or is there another way I can generate that list? Thanks Simon
Competitive Research | | electrik0