Title Tag: Phrases vs. Keywords Separated by "|"
-
Hello,
One of my client's old sites has all category titles of the form (for example)
running shoes | running shoe | walking shoes | walking shoe
including many that perform well with over 60 characters.
I'm in the process of rewriting the titles into something like
Running and Walking Shoes, A quality shoe at OurShoes.com
The reason I'm rewriting them is for future google penalties, and to look better to possible guest post opportunities. Also to look better in the SERPS
But the old style is performing very well.
What are the real pros and cons of each?
Thanks.
-
Thanks Ryan, very clear. I learned to look at the page and the goals of the page, and with a new site to start with one keyword, etc. Wow. very nice thank you
-
Approaches vary widely based on the client, site and SEO involved. I agree with the logic Martin applies, although there are other ideas as well. Of course, that response is likely not helpful so I will share the approach I prefer.
When working with a new site, I first determine what is the goal of the page. While you wish to attract search engine traffic, you also wish to present your brand in a specific manner as well. For example, Wikipedia style writing is very effective, but it is also mechanical and does not necessarily scale to ecommerce sites.
The typical approach I prefer is to take an all out "I want tot rank #1 for this keyword" stance. The title I would choose is "Running Shoes" and I fully optimize the page. I would ensure internal linking is solid, work to earn external links, and watch the SERPs for 30 days. Next, I may make some tweaks to the page and watch SERPs for another 30 days. At this point, the rankings are likely as good as they will get without earning more links to the page.
Now you can ask yourself, how can I make changes to improve CTR or branding without losing any ranking positions. Here is when you can try adding the pipe and your brand, or an alternate keyword, etc. I still would not create a single page for Running Shoes and Walking Shoes. Running is higher impact and a different audience.
-
Ryan, do you agree with the "piping" that MartinEvolveRetail recommended below? You're one of the best SEOs I know of, you would know.
-
I'm a fan of piping, from personal experience CTR have been higher from dashes or commas. Which one is best, well according to Matt Cutts it's neither:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2_7PTio3Qc
As he suggest, it's trial and error. See what works best for you.
In terms of keywords, i'd try and keep it to two keyword phrases, use Wordtracker or Google's keyword tool to see what is getting the most traffic and split between.
Remember the value of each keyword is diluted the longer the meta title gets, as Ryan Kent suggest, focus on one or two, depending on if you want branding in the Meta title.
My rule of thumb is:
Just keywords:
"Keyword phrase 1" | "Keyword Phrase 2"
Keywords and Brand:
"Keyword phrase 1" | "Brand Name"
Hope this helps
-
Hi Bob,
If you are new and trying to build the brand online, you can include the brand at the beginning of the title along with doing some value based link building with branded anchors. So this would be your brand building phase and then comes your ranking phase for certain keywords/ phrases. This is when you push your brand name to the end of the title and this can be beyond the 65 character limit. Google strips the text after this limit in the SERPs but this does not mean that Google cannot read or will not consider text beyond this limit for ranking. So, I always say, try to include the essence or vital SEO info in the first 65 characters but come up with good titles that read natural and at the same time very enticing.
Best regards,
Devanur Rafi.
-
Both responses bring up another good discussion point. When is it best to incorporate branding into the title if it is already performing well?
Also, it seems that titles a little longer than 60 characters work well sometimes in the SERPs even if the term is partially cut off. Is it just that that last term is diluted with the long title?
-
Hi Bob,
All of us SEOs run into situations like this very often where a client's website though not up to Google's guidelines performs well in the search engines and we as SEOs tend to correct these so called, 'not so Google compliant' elements despite apprehensions from both the client's side and our side about these changes being made.
Personally, I always stick to what's going to be a winner in the long run and go ahead and implement it. At times, we might need to educate our clients about the purpose behind these changes. We have to make it very clear that, just because something is working out really well does not mean it will do so forever and it takes just another update from Google with some black and white animal name to make the website vanish overnight from the SERPs.
Believe me my friend, I did a lot of practical research with live domains that I maintain which are dedicated just for the search engine tolerance level tests and learned the above. Whenever I train someone in SEO, I always urge them to stick to the best practices and they can reap the fruits from search engines. Going or taking the other route might give you or your client some temporary gains but in the long run, this will not only destroy the rankings of your website but also leave a big dent to your reputation.
Always remember, a happy customer might fetch you one or two new customers but an unhappy customer can sometimes cause irreparable damage.
Let me cut the crap and conclude by saying, please have those titles re-written in a descriptive way and so enticing that they literally force the visitors click through the listing in the SERPs. If possible, include a call to action in the description. And always remember to push the brand towards the end of the title and let the primary keyword /phrase be at the beginning. Also never include multiple keywords/ phrases in the title tag as this will leave the search engines confused. Ideally wherever or whenever possible, optimize a page for only one keyword/ phrase
The above is based on my experience and please do consider the other valuable suggestions that our friends write in here.
Good luck my friend.
Best regards,
Devanur Rafi.
-
There are a lot of variables to consider Bob. A few are:
-
the page's content
-
the site's internal links to the page
-
the site's external links to the page
-
the site's ranking and traffic for each term
All things being equal, if you had a title tag of "running shoes" you will likely perform noticeably better for the term "running shoes" then with the current title tag, but not as well for the other terms. By targeting 4 keywords the page is not focusing on any one term leaving the page vulnerable to competitors with an optimized page.
If I were in your situation, I would recommend tracking your rankings and traffic on each term, then changing a couple pages, then review the results in both SERPs and analytics. At that point, you can test further tweaks or choose to roll out the change site wide.
I would expect a site named OurShoes.com to have a separate category page for Running Shoes and Walking Shoes.
-
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
When using long-tail keywords, should you exactly match for the url or delete "in" "to" etc.?
long-tail keyword - "seizures in adults with no history" Should you include "in and with" in the url?
On-Page Optimization | | Moleculera0 -
Adding Location to Title Tags has dropped SEO Rankings
After adding the suburb of my business to each title tag on my website, I've noticed their rankings have dropped from page one to page four in a lot of cases. Should I wait it out and expect to see them improve in the future? Should I revert them back to their old title tags? I'm a little concerned!
On-Page Optimization | | thomaslutrov0 -
Hi - How do you get rid of duplicate content that was accidentally created on a tag url? For example, when I published a new article, the content was duplicated on: /posts/tag/lead-generation/
the original article was created with: /posts/shippers-looking-for-freight-brokers/ How can I fix this so a new URL is not created every time I add a tag to a new posting?
On-Page Optimization | | treetopgrowthstrategy0 -
IMG ALT tags - should they be the same or the product title?
I have about 300 products. Should I make all my IMG ALT tags with my keywords, such as sea glass jewelry, sea glass necklace, sea glass bracelets? Or, should I make them what their title is, some of which do not pertain to the keyword, such as By the Sea. Some of my products do have keywords in them, but not all. I am hesitant on changing all the titles, as almost all URLs are indexed.
On-Page Optimization | | tiffany11030 -
Keyword Saturation
Hi guys, A run a niche price comparison website and the keywords I'm targeting are the product names themselves. I recall Moz recommended that using the keyword too many times on site was not a good thing. Typically, I would have a unique description for the products and the list of merchants, prices, links to thier site and thier product names. This resulted in my keyword appearing many times on site, in slightly different forms (the product names were taken from the merchants feed) I no longer see this warning in the recomended and I believe it is more transparent for my visitors if they see the merchants website name on my site. Is it safe to put them back on my site? Mark
On-Page Optimization | | MrPenguin0 -
Shortening Titles
Have a ecommerce site using woocommerce. Most product titles contain the information needed for the product. I have shorten the title as much as possible but; Most of the titles are about 18-19 characters over 70 characters the recommended max. I have removed all possible characters from the title but I could remove the site name - this would get it down by about 18 characters - meaning most titles would then be just under the 70 characters recommended. Would removing the site name from the title of all the products be a bigger problem than good?
On-Page Optimization | | royRR0 -
Different Title and Meta Title Tag
Do the search engines rank based on the meta title tag or the title tag? What if you have a different meta title tag from the title tag? Edited: I have edited to clarify my issue. Having a different meta title tag from the title tag. Thank you for those who have answered the question so far.
On-Page Optimization | | rching0 -
Title tags in duplicate pages
hi there, we have a new ecommerce platform which has just been deployed, and I've been asked to tidy up the onpage SEO. we have employed canonicals across the category and product pages and we now have a nice set of unique product pages my question is - do we need to create the title tags in all of the duplicate non-canonical pages eg www.mysite.com/niceproduct.html (canonical) www.mysite.com/acategory/niceproduct.html (duplicate) Can we leave the duplicate title tag empty and not worry about it, or should we put in a duplicate of the canonical title tag hope the question makes sense! thanks in advance for all help
On-Page Optimization | | k3nn3dy30