Negative Keyword Help
-
I am working on compiling a list of both broad and phrase-matched negative keywords for my AdWords campaigns, but I feel like I am encountering a problem.
We offer payment gateway services and business owners often search terms including online payment gateway, Internet payment gateway, credit card payment gateway, etc to see our ads. However, we have been getting bad leads from consumers searching for terms such as online payment, online payments, online bill pay, and various other phrases regarding consumers paying their bills online. We work specifically with business owners who want to accept payments and NOT consumers who want to make payments.
Here is my dilemma: If I have "online payment gateway" or [online payment gateway] as keywords as well as "online payment" or "online payments" as negative keywords, then I will be blocking business owners from seeing my ads when they search the term online payment gateway. Correct?
Is there any way to get around this? Am I wrong?
-
I am in the middle of re-vamping my PPC marketing campaigns. Once I have more data on the results of my changes, I may take you up on that offer for a free review. Thank you for all of your help!
Regards,
Meghan -
Hi Meghan,
Broad modified keywords are a new variation of broad match. They are a hybrid between broad and phrase match types. Broad modified keywords must use all the keywords.(like phrase) but they allow the keywords to be in any order. Broad modified keywords main benefit is they will not be triggered by synonyms or keywords the Google/Bing believe are 'relevant". Synonyms and 'relevant' keywords are what cause trouble for broad match...sometimes they are relevant, but often they are not relevant...broad modified does not have this issue.
To create broad modified keywords you just need to put a "+" in front of each word, and have a match type of broad. While this can be time consuming to create manually, here is an awesome broad match generator. http://www.acquisio.com/ppc/google-adwords-modified-broad-match-keyword-tool/
Use Editor... just export to excel ...all of your keywords, campaign, group, match type & dest url. Make sure your keyword column in Excel is set to "text"...if its set to 'general' it will create problems when you paste '+keyword" back later. Copy your keyword column, paste into the above Acquisio page, click the 'generate broad match button" , copy the new broad modified keywords and paste them back onto your spreadsheet. Make sure all keywords have broad match type. Save excel file and import back into AdWords editor. You now have all keywords with a broad modified match type. Should only take 5 minutes. I would then recommend pausing broad match types...you will begin receiving much more targeted traffic, and will not need to micro manage your negative keywords.
By the way, I offer a free PPC marketing review. Do you have 30 minutes to chat with me? I can really help your PPC campaigns. Private message me if you are interested.
Branden
-
Thanks, Branden!
I did know know that I could sort through my keywords in this way. It does seem like a lot of work, but I am willing to do it if it provides me with better results. That is the goal, after all.
I am unfamiliar with broad modified keywords. Could you explain this a little more?
Regards,
Meghan -
The best way I have found to create negative keywords is by going through the search queries. I do this every month for my clients. It takes some time to do this, especially at the beginning, when you don't have a large negative keyword list. But as time goes by you will have developed an extensive negative keyword list.
Set a broad date range, go into an ad group >>> keyword tab>> Details drop down >> select Search terms All. This will show you every search term that triggered your keyword. Sort by impressions and start with the most impressions. If this is a term that you don't want to show your ad for, just check the box and click "add as negative". This will add this term as a negative exact match for this ad group. It takes a while to go through all of the search terms, but it will pay off in the long run. This is also a good way to add keywords.
Another thing that will help you is to stop using broad match for your keywords, ..broad modified, phrase & exact match are the only match types I use for keywords. This will give you much more targeted search queries.
-
Trenton,
The keyword airaisia payment online by debit does not sell. That is a keyword consumers used to find our ads--but I do not work with consumers. I work with business owners, which means any clicks or conversions are a waste of money from this term. However, I do understand what you are saying.
Also, I must add how much I love Excel's concatenate function. It saves massive amounts of time!
Thanks again for your help!
-
I think you mistook my post, I would recommend using exact for BOTH the positive and negative keywords.
In your case, I believe, the positive keywords being exact would solve all your problems. One, make sure these signups are coming from PPC, then for example, why not add [airasia payment online by debit] to your keyword list. You've already told me it sells and you would be able to track the metrics for this keyword exactly. Then, take the list that goes on and on, and export it to an excel sheet, add those keywords to your PPC campaigns. Make sure you put the [] around each though. Excel can help you do this very quickly if you are familiar with excel functions. Just my $.02. Hope it helps.
Trenton
-
Thank you, Kerri.
I have been analyzing the Search Terms in Dimensions to see what phrases people are searching to find our site. I have been building a list of negative keywords since my last post. Some of the negative keywords include:
- "abdomen" (yes, we have even gotten clicks for this term!)
- "belks"
- "car payment"
- "electricity payment"
- "make bill payment online"
- pay cell bill
- gas bill
I am hoping this helps solve my problem!
-
One other thing to consider is finding a list of online payments people may be looking for, and add those as negatives. I searched for 'online bill pay directory' and found that Chase has a list of people that they will do a bill pay for at http://chasepayeedirectory.com/chasebiller/home.html. It's in flash and not easily grabbed in text format, but it's a start.
I wrote a post about finding these types of lists and other negative keyword brainstorming ideas at http://moz.com/blog/negative-keywords-for-positive-roi. It may be of help in finding lists of terms to exclude.
-
I feel like I should not use exact match negative keywords in this situation. Consumers are not searching for exact match phrases. For instance, one of the search phrases a consumer used to sign up on our website through an ad was: airasia payment online by debit.
If I list -[online payment] as an exact negative keyword, this consumer would still see my ad. Even adding the phrase -"online payment" as a negative keyword would allow this consumer to see my ads since the exact phrase within the entire keyword is payment online and not online payment.
Other keywords consumers search and see my ads are:
- aircell online bill payment
- airtel landline online payment through credit card
- allen online payment
- at&t pay bill online
- best buy online bill payment
- boost mobile online payment
The list goes on and on . . .
I just do not know what to do. I feel like I need to either choose between blocking legitimate clients or allowing bad conversions.
-
around your keyword for exampleonline payment gateway should be [online payment gateway]. This will make it so only the exact search will return the results. I would also suggest making your negative keywords exact when possible as well.This is what we used to solve this problem and has been extremely effective.
Trenton
-
A negative exact match should not exclude your search term. For example:
**-[online payment] **will allow online payment gateway to show.
Check this post by Google and look at the chart of possible combinations - http://adwords.blogspot.co.uk/2007/11/adwords-optimization-tips-more-on.html
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Keyword & negative keyword overlap
So I just read your blog on quality score and after reading the negative keyword section I'm a little confused and I need clarification. In that paragraph you mentioned about not overlapping your negative keywords with your active keywords and you used an example of dog food and dog bed. So my question is, if you put the word dog bed into the negative keyword list isn't the word dog the over lap word? Would you ad not show because the word dog is in the active keyword list?
Paid Search Marketing | | Vallerinspects0 -
Adwords Duplicate Keywords with Different Match Types - Good or Bad?
If you have the following keywords in an Ad Group advertising for a product, let's for example call it "target" product [target product] "target product" +target +product I've found that the exact match keyword has the highest conversion rate in almost all circumstances. So it would make sense to have a higher max bid on the exact match then phrase or broad batch. Even with lots of negative search terms to maximize conversion on the broader matches, if the bid is the same as exact match, the cost per conversion will be much higher (too high.) However in chatting with an Adwords Support Rep (on a different matter) they stated after looking through my account at the end of the chat: " duplicate keywords will impact on quality score. your all keywords will compete with each other" However many of the ad groups in question these duplicate keywords have quality score of 9 and 10. So obviously if there is an effect it seems it may be minimal. I thought it was pretty common for people to bid higher on more exact match and lower on more broad match. What's the real story here? Was this support rep not seeing the big picture?
Paid Search Marketing | | JCCMoz1 -
Adwords negative keywords / keyword lists conflicting?
Does any of you had any experience on large 5k+ shared negative keyword lists impacting normal campaign negative keywords in Adwords even if they are not selected on these campaigns? And a second question; does anyone know how selected negative keyword lists can be removed from a campaign? I seem to be able to add them but not to remove them... Cheers!
Paid Search Marketing | | hellemans0 -
Adwords Keyword Quality Score changes when keyword is paused
Today I was pausing a bunch of low quality score keywords for a client, the thing is, once I paused the keywords, the quality score would immediately change. For example, a number of keywords that had a QS of 3 while they were running, immediately changed to 1 once paused. Out of curiosity I un-paused one of them and it remained at 1. Has anyone else experienced this and/or have an explanation? Cheers
Paid Search Marketing | | David_ODonnell0 -
Adwords Dynamic Keyword Insertion for Location keywords
Hi Guys, I'm managing a campaign targeting multiple cities across the country. The campaign is using DKI to display locations in ad titles. Is the following example the best way to handle it (example data only): Ad headline: {KeyWord: Local Chocolate Delivery} Keywords: chocolate delivery chocolate delivery Dallas chocolate delivery Austin Etc etc?
Paid Search Marketing | | David_ODonnell1 -
Exact url dynamic keyword insertion
A competitor of ours is using dynamic keyword insertion for exact urls in our field. I'm not 100% clear on this, but isn't that not allowed in adwords? I am not one that usually turns in a competitor for shady doings, but I'm not sure what to do. Any advice?
Paid Search Marketing | | ClaytonKendall0 -
My client's resort, ME Cancun would like to rank for the keyword “Complete ME” and related modifiers. So any advice or ideas you have to improve our performance on this keyword is appreciated.
ME Cancun went all-inclusive, and their all-inclusive package is called
Paid Search Marketing | | Melia
“Complete ME.” Here is their website: www.me-cancun.com. They are concerned because although we are buying keyword “Complete ME” in
Google, but they are not showing up very high for this keyword in organic
search results. So any advice or ideas you have to improve our performance on this
keyword is much appreciated.0 -
How accurate is the Google´s keyword tool regarding monthly searches?
How correct is Google´s keyword tool regarding the estimated number of Global Monthly Searches? Judging from my adwords campaigns the real number of impressions is 1/3 compared to the estimated number for an exact match. What is your experience?
Paid Search Marketing | | europeandomaincentre0