Google penalty
-
Anyone have any success stories on what they did to get out of Google penalty?
-
I have been directly involved in assisting sites recover from manual and algorithmic penalties. I believe most providers of SEO services have this experience as well. Penalties are a common driver or business for our industry.
I did not intend to upset you in any way. My only thoughts regarding your reply were:
-
if you have knowledge about an SEO topic, please share it. If you feel you have discovered a solution, it would be helpful to let others know about it in the Q&A section. You can even write a YouMoz article if you desire which can yield positive credit and attention.
-
generally speaking, taking months to recover from a penalty would be crippling to most businesses. I always strive to work with clients to balance their traffic, but when I first receive clients they often show 85%+ of their traffic comes from Google. If they were to lose that traffic for 60+ days many would go out of business.
I am glad to hear you were able to resolve the issues on your site.
Best Regards,
-Ryan
-
-
Wow that is a horrible analogy. You really think fixing a computer and getting a website out of a Google penalty is the same thing or even close to being similar?
You act like I am trying to sell a service here or something. I am just providing information on the fact that I was actually successful.
It took a while for me to make the changes on the site because I had no idea what to change. We bought this site and it had a Google penalty... so I had to go through the site to figure out what could be wrong. Then went through it and tried to clean it up.
I came on here to find out if anyone has gone through the process of actually getting a site out of a Google penalty, but no one said they did. I do realize in Internet marketing, many people like to talk about how to do stuff, but very few actually do it.
Feel free to tell me that I am doing something wrong or my claims are false... but I am just telling the facts of what happen in my case... whether you feel its "troubling" is your problem.
Bottom line is after I finished making changes on the site sometime in July, 2 months later Google rankings have skyrocketed. I dont know what is so troubling about that.
-
I find your reply quite troubling. It should not take 2-3 months to remove a penalty. It should not require dozens of changes either. Not for a "good" site which has went astray.
If you have a pc that doesn't work and a tech says "hey, I spent a couple weeks working on it, replaced the motherboard, video card, sound card, memory, hard drive, and some other parts, and now it works" is that really an approach you wish to duplicate?
In my case after I made all the changes it took about 2-3 months for Google to make the changes on their end. So dont expect things to happen overnight.
If a site has been penalized, the first thing which needs to be determined is whether it is an algorithmic penalty or a manual penalty. The overwhelming majority of penalties are algorithmic in nature, and those can be fixed overnight. It could take weeks depending on the site, but it should not take months.
-
Figured I would update this... I made a lot of changes to the site before I placed this post on seomoz. Basically gave up on the site at the time I wrote this.
Spent about 2 months making changes trying to figure out what Google didnt like.
About a week ago I guess all the changes finally kicked in and traffic from Google has increased over 900%.
My original reason for posting this was to find someone who actually got a site out of the Google penalty. So if someone is reading this with a Google penalty, contact me and I will try to help.
In my case after I made all the changes it took about 2-3 months for Google to make the changes on their end. So dont expect things to happen overnight.
-
Google has some good information about what it looks for in quality sites at http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2011/05/more-guidance-on-building-high-quality.html.
Of particular interest to ads is the statement "Does this article have an excessive amount of ads that distract from or interfere with the main content?"
-
There are times when Google notifies you in the messages area regarding things that it has noticed that are not in their guidelines (as an example, see this post on Search Engine Roundtable at http://www.seroundtable.com/google-link-spam-notifications-13652.html).
Can you share any information you have about knowing you have a penalty as opposed to the algorithm having changed?
-
We run other sites with 5+ ad units that dominate the search engines for their theme... and Google actually sends emails to add more ad units.
I will try this though and see what happens.
-
Where in webmaster tools does it provide info on a penalty? Never seen that.
-
Ironically enough your site has a page on how to unblock websites: http://monsterguide.net/how-to-unblock-websites
(That page is actually related to individual users, but I noticed it and couldn't help but mention it).
You need to remove all ads from the site. Your not only offer ads, but they are at the top of your left sidebar, right side bar, main content and in the header. Users are blasted with 4 ad blocks the moment they land on a page. They would be the first thing any Google employee or human will notice when reviewing your site, and they offer a most unpleasant user experience.
I am not an expert on AdSense but it seems your page violates Google's AdSense rules. That would explain if your AdSense account was banned, but the Spam team could take action by pulling your site from Google's index, and then notify (or not) the AdSense team. https://www.google.com/adsense/support/bin/answer.py?answer=48182&sourceid=aso&subid=ww-ww-et-asui&medium=link&hl=en_US
"AdSense for content: Up to three ad units and three link units may be placed on each page."
Once your penalty has been removed you can replace some ads, but it is not reasonable to have that many ads. I am quite sure Google does not wish their ads to be displayed in such a manner.
Another concern is your site offers many followed links to other sites. If you link to another site which violates Google's terms and they receive a penalty, your site can be affected.
You really need to step back and look at your site's pages. Does the pages in their present condition offer any value to the internet? Would any user say "I am glad to have found this site"? Or are they more likely to run from the site never to return?
-
Hi Phatride,
Have you verified the site in Google Webmaster Tools and in Bing's Webmaster Tools? The webmaster tools will often give you information about any penalty, and let you submit a reconsideration request.
I'm seeing many pages indexed, which is a good sign. A not-so-good sign is that the article on How to Pluck a Chicken was categorized under Games, and has at least five separate ad blocks on it, some with multiple ads. The sheer number of ads may be an issue.
How do you know that you are still penalized?
-
We bought some websites and we knew one of them had a penalty on it. Went through and took out all duplicate content and still nothing. It is on Wordpress.
The penalty started last summer. The other company has no clue what happened. They didnt do much in terms of SEO.
The site is monsterguide . net
If anyone has any ideas that would be great.
Things we have done were... got rid of all language pages, blocked search results, blocked basic wordpress folders, they had image galleries setup so each image was being indexed as its own page, that is now fixed, put canonical links on all pages.
Really appreciate any help.
-
We had a client that picked up a penalty just after Panda and it ended up being for duplicate content. Funny thing was, they had been around for about 8 years and the content itself was also about 3 years old and had been scraped, copied, stolen and reproduced on several other sites in and out of the UK.
We contacted all of these people but also just rewrote the content and then, like magic, they were back again.
Point being - there are so many things that can cause a penalty. A hacked site, ripped off content, dodgy practices or SEO that for us to advise, is pretty much impossible without a link.
Hope it helps and fire over a link for some more targeted feedback.
Cheers
Marcus -
Dejan SEO website was done about a year ago.
It took us weeks to detect the problem and it was finally discovered once Google Webmaster Tools updated. It suggested that most of our content contained words "serial number, adobe, crack...etc". Upon inspection we found that we were hacked and a cloaking script was installed showing pirated software to Google and clean site to users. The links were visible in the source of the cached page.
We cleaned up the site and did 301 from dejan.com.au to dejanseo.com.au
(this was not needed, but I wanted to do it for branding anyway)Back in the results within a week.
-
Marcus is dead on. If you earned a penalty, figure out what you did wrong and fix it. It really is that simple.
-
Hey, some more info would help us put a solution together that best suits your requirements but... in a nutshell - remove all the things you did wrong.
- Built lots of bad, bad, links? - remove them
- got loads of duplicate or weak content - improve it
Anything you have done that earnt the penalty needs to be fixed and you will be okay (eventually, hopefully).
Hope it helps.
Marcus
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Favicon not showing in google serps
Hi, I have a website where the favicon is not showing in the google mobile serps. It's appearing the default icon instead (world icon). This is the tag I have place in the head section of the website: <link rel="shortcut icon" href="/favicon.ico" /> The size of the favicon is 48x48 and it's appearing correctly in the browser tag. I've checked that the google robot can crawl it and in the server logs I can see requests from the "Google Favicon" user-agent. Has anyone had this same problem? Any advice?
Technical SEO | | dMaLasp0 -
Google Search Console Not Sending Messages
One of our sites received a Manual Penalty for unnatural links by Google. However, we never received a message in Google Search Console or an email about the manual action. The only reason we knew about the penalty is by the obvious drop in rankings, then signing into search console to look for any manual actions, which we found. Since then, we have submitted a disavow file and a reconsideration request. However, once again we did not receive an email or message in search console that shows confirmation of the disavow or that they received the reconsideration request. The disavow file does show up after I upload it, and it says it was successfully uploaded... but no messages or emails. After many hours of investigating the various canonical versions of our website on Search Console, we found out that there were several “owners” of the various canonical versions of our site that had “could not find the email address” as a site owner. We found out that these were previous employees who no longer worked with the company and their email address was deleted. After unverifying these site owners, (all the ones that had “could not find the email address” as the site owner), the notifications, emails and messages in Search Console started to appear. However, the only place they did not appear, is the main canonical version of our site. Of course, the main canonical version of our site (https://www) is the version that we uploaded the disavow and reconsideration request. This is the canonical version of the site that we need to receive these messages to know if our reconsideration request was granted! We’ve just reuploaded the disavow file and reconsideration request to all of the other canonical versions (2 of the 3 received the message about the penalty)…. and we are currently awaiting a response. Has anybody else had problems with not receiving notifications in search console due to deleted email addresses?
Technical SEO | | Fiyyazp0 -
Google serp pagination issue
We are a local real estate company and have landing pages for different communities and cities around our area that display the most recent listings. For example: www.mysite.com/wa/tumwater is our landing page for the city of Tumwater homes for sale. Google has indexed most of our landing pages, but for whatever reason they are displaying either page 2, 3, 4 etc... instead of page 1. Our Roy, WA landing page is another example. www.mysite.com/wa/roy has recently been showing up on page 1 of Google for "Roy WA homes for sale", but now we are much further down and www.mysite.com/wa/roy?start=80 (page 5) is the only page in the serps. (coincidentally we no longer have 5 pages worth of listings for this city, so this link now redirects to www.mysite.com/wa/roy.) We haven't made any major recent changes to the site. Any help would be much appreciated! *You can see what my site is in the attached image... I just don't want this post to show up when someone google's the actual name of the business 🙂 nTTrSMx.jpg C4mhfgh.jpg
Technical SEO | | summithomes0 -
Google is indexing my directories
I'm sure this has been asked before, but I was looking at all of Google's results for my site and I found dozens of results for directories such as: Index of /scouting/blog/wp-includes/js/swfupload/plugins Obviously I don't want those indexed. How do I prevent Google from indexing those? Also, it only seems to be doing it with Wordpress, not any of the directories on my main site. (We have a wordpress blog, which is only a portion of the site)
Technical SEO | | UnderRugSwept0 -
Do Google Always Tell You About Penalties?
Hi One of my clients has recently suffered a big decline in rankings on some of their keywords, going from positions in the top 10 to sub 50 for some of their keywords, but not all. Their website is still indexed and there is no link warning from Google. Some of their links from a previous link builder are dodgy and we have already tried to contact the other company for removal but to no avail. Any ideas where I start? So far I planning to increase the branded anchor link and add some content as the site is fairly light on content. Is it worth doing a reconsideration request and mention the bad links incase this is the problem. Has anyone seen any particular good resources on what to do when it appears you have a penalty. None of my other clients have been effected by Panda or Penguin and although I have done some general reading I need to know what action to take and get up to speed FAST! Thanks in advance. Kind regards Karen
Technical SEO | | Karen_Dauncey0 -
Google Search memory
Hi we have had the following statement from a member of our Japan office with regards google displaying search results, would anyone be able to give us a definitive answer on this. Google remembers previous non-mobile related searches For example, we already know that we come up on the first page if you select “kaigai keitai” (mobile phone for use abroad) and “UK” where as we don’t for searches where you replace the UK with the US or other countries. This means that if a customer, for example, does a search just on the UK e.g. using words like UK travel, London, millennium dome, etc. and then does a separate search just using the words “kaigai keitai” that google could show us as a link on the first page. However, if an individual did a search on Paris, France, Eiffel Tower, and then did a search for “kaigai keitai”, our link might not appear on the page. I don’t know if we have tested this already, but Google seems to have a very long “memory” and I could see this kind of aspect of Google resulting in us missing significant business from people going to the US, France, Italy, etc. Any thoughts?
Technical SEO | | -Al-0 -
Is the number at the top of google wrong
If I search a term, any term, Google states at the top 922,000 results (as an example). However, if you click the "O" in google at the bottom you can get the 2nd and 3rd and 4th page of results. Those numbers don't match. The result of my searches would show anywhere from 120-140 results, but the number at the top is in the tens of thousands if not millions. Am I missing something here? Shouldn't these numbers be the same?
Technical SEO | | StreetwiseReports0 -
Google & Separators
This is not a question but something to share. If you click on all of these links and compare the results you will see why _ is not a good thing to have in your URLs. http://www.google.com/search?q=blue http://www.google.com/search?q=b.l.u.e http://www.google.com/search?q=b-l-u-e http://www.google.com/search?q=b_l_u_e http://www.google.com/search?q=b%20l%20u%20e If you have any other examples of working separators please comment.
Technical SEO | | Dan-Petrovic3