Should I redirect a popular but irrelevant blog post to the home page?
-
Hi.
I'm trying to get my website; www.ciphr.com , to rank for keywords relevant to "HR Software" in the UK. It's a highly competitive industry and we rank ~mid to low on page one for some of our ideal keywords that are highly relevant and high volume.
Years ago we took the decision to blog about topics more loosely related to the world of work. One of our blog posts, about plants in the office https://www.ciphr.com/advice/plants-in-the-office/ is popular. It gets decent traffic and consistently builds backlinks to the post without any further effort on our part. The specific page has a PA of 46 and DA of 55 with >500 domains linking to it. This compares to our home page with a PA of 47 and 700 linking domains. It is typically the home page that ranks for our money keywords "HR Software" "HR Systems" in the UK.
Because this blog post is so loosely related to our actual business, the traffic it generates is highly unlikely to turn into a customer of ours.
I am considering redirecting the blog post to the home page to pass link juice to the home page. The concern I have is that, based on the anchor text and contextual signals from linking pages, Google might then infer that our home page is less relevant for our money keywords and more relevant for "plants".
Are my concerns unfounded? What are your thoughts? Should I redirect the blog post to the home page? Another internal page? Keep the blog post live?
Thanks
-
Happy I could be of help.
-
I agree with EGOL
Your ranking for lists of keywords and then he featured snippets. (big photo) https://imgur.com/tyle0ZZ.png
The https://www.ciphr.com/advice/plants-in-the-office/ page has 490 IPs (that's great!)
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1X21h8DOze5u9aUt1viivCllITCOIvBZag1eCxqPh0-U/edit?usp=sharing
This is a perfect example of off-topic content working very well to get backlinks as well as bring more customers on to Pingdom.com named
"Retro Delight: Gallery of Early Computers (1940s - 1960s) - Pingdom Royal"
https://royal.pingdom.com/retro-delight-gallery-of-early-computers-1940s-1960s/
<label id="url">https://www.pingdom.com/ a company now owned by SolarWinds does Website Performance and Availability Monitoring Site speed testing.</label>
I would definitely tell somebody who was creating content from the start or has a large amount of unrelated content without backlinks or any traffic to do something else but this is something relatable to human resources as well as beneficial to other people it's an excellent piece of content that I would definitely keep.
Hope this is been a help,
Tom
-
The specific page has..... >500 domains linking to it.
This is rocket fuel. Irrelevant articles help lots of websites.
Find the person who wrote that article for you and give them a really nice gift.
Ask them to write another article about plants in the office.
Ask them to come up with some great photos of plants (that you are legally able to distribute as screensavers, branded lightly with your domain) and give them to people.
Advertise the new article about plants on the popular page, advertise the screen saver on your popular page.
I don't think that you are going to kill a software giant with irrelevant articles but I believe from experience that they can be very helpful to your rankings. Plus, we make a few sales every month to people who landed on our website to consume irrelevant content - and the products that we sell are irrelevant to the content and damn few people want what is sold on that site.
-
Thanks for such a thorough and thoughtful response Tom
-
I Strongly Suggest **YOU DO NOT REDIRECT TO THE HOMEPAGE the Only Way You're Going to Keep the Backlinks From Not Being Devalued by Google is to Add HR Content With the Plant ** CONTENT OR HAVE A VERY RELEVANT ALMOST IDENTICAL PAGE TO REDIRECT TO.
Sorry for the very long post. I just found this and realized it explained everything very clearly.
"IMPORTANT
Redirecting pages to somewhere relevant is key. Google treats irrelevant 301 redirects as soft 404’s, so there’s no real advantage of redirecting unless you’re doing so to a similar and relevant page.
Google’s John Mueller explains more in this video. https://youtu.be/nIDZmac_rMI
If you don’t have a similar or relevant page, and you still have a 404 page with lots of high-quality backlinks then, honestly, it may be worth republishing the content that used to exist at that location.
Think of it like this:
If the dead page was valuable enough to attract high-quality backlinks in the first place, then it’s worth questioning why it no longer exists. I mean, it’s clearly a topic people are interested"
- John Mueller
Redirect Bad Practices
1. Redirecting All 404 Broken URLs to the Home Page
This case often happens when you are lazy to investigate all of your 404 URLs and map them to the appropriate landing page.
Cite: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/technical-seo/redirects/
"According to Google, they are still all treated as 404s.
@JohnMuReplying to @p3sn @jdevalkYeah, it's not a great practice (confuses users), and we mostly treat them as 404s anyway (they're soft-404s), so there's no upside. It's not critically broken/bad, but additional complexity for no good reason - make a better 404 page instead.
205:10 AM - Jan 8, 2019If you have too many pages like this, you should consider creating beautiful 404 pages and engage users to browse further or find something other than what they were looking for by displaying a search option."
-
It is strongly recommended by Google that redirected page content should be equivalent to the old page. Otherwise, such redirect may be considered as soft 404 and you will lose the rank of that page."
-
If you do anything do not redirect to the homepage that would be the worst possible outcome.
-
Doing that with simply create a soft for for for all your backlinks and they will be devalued by Google.
-
In order to continue to read the benefits of your 500 root domains pointing to your plant URL you should
-
Start writing about your software's User interface keeps people Relaxed. That business will grow? Spend one week with a memo in the entire office saying we will get $500 to whoever rewrites this the best way it will be done very well I promise.
-
link from it to one of the pages that you need the most boost with most needed pages**,**
-
Simply add this type of information into what you already have. I'm not going to say it's going to be the easiest thing but it will help your site. If you'd like some help I'm happy to have one of my Writers come up with something that would work
-
You should also take the rewriting/merging of two pages as an opportunity to better serve search intent and give searchers what they’re looking for. If there are a lot of top 10 lists ranking for the target keyword, make your new revamped post a top 10 list. If there are a lot of how-to guides, well… you get the idea!
-
NOTE. That has nothing to do with 301 redirects, but it’s worth doing if you want to maximize the ROI of your efforts.
-
Publish your revamped page and implement the 301 redirect(s)
-
Now it’s finally time to publish your revamped post/page.
-
If either of the old URLs is a good match for your new post, then feel free to republish at the same URL. You can then delete the other post/page and add a 301 redirect to the new post.
-
You may recall that’s what we did with our_ skyscraper technique_ post. We reused the /skyscraper-technique/ URL.
-
If neither of the old URLs is a good match for your new post/page, then it’s also perfectly fine to 301 redirect both pages to a totally new URL.
-
**I would concentrate on HR's role in keeping people happy and barely breathe clean. You have so much ammunition use it **About how you're trying to actually help people's mental state.
-
Human resources provide care for workers and make sure that they are healthy and have a good mental state. You do everything you can to try to keep people from getting sick and making sure that they are happy plants are doing the same thing this is a slam dunk you can make this very very HR with plants. Do you want to get a real lot of attention do you your own COVID-19 and plants in your home office or workplace study****
-
Information that is positive about plants and working.
-
You Have so much good stuff that you can mix.
-
https://www.thebalancecareers.com/how-hr-provides-career-help-4125267
- https://www.thebalancesmb.com/best-indoor-plants-for-your-home-office-4160064
- https://pittnews.com/article/157206/opinions/opinion-plants-are-more-important-than-ever-in-the-time-of-covid-19/
- https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/07/climate/air-pollution-coronavirus-covid.html
- https://www.nbcnews.com/better/health/indoor-plants-can-instantly-boost-your-health-happiness-ncna781806
- https://www.thebalancecareers.com/how-hr-provides-career-help-4125267
- https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2014-30837-001
- https://www.thesill.com/blogs/care-miscellaneous/why-you-need-plants-in-your-life
- https://www.vogue.com/article/caring-for-indoor-houseplants
- https://www.marketwatch.com/story/this-earth-day-especially-remember-plants-are-non-judgmental-what-its-like-to-start-gardening-during-a-pandemic-2020-04-22
Work Environment
**Example: **While performing the responsibilities of the job, these work environment characteristics are representative of the environment the job holder will encounter. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable people with disabilities to perform the essential functions of the job.
While performing the duties of this job, the employee is occasionally exposed to moving mechanical parts and vehicles. The noise level in the work environment is usually quiet to moderate. The passage of employees through the work area is average and normal.
Benefits of Plants in the Home Office
Research shows that plants improve air quality, health, mood, and productivity. Here’s how:
- Air Filter: Research from NASA shows that plants can remove toxins from the air. Don’t think you have harmful chemicals in your office? Think again. Chemicals are found in furniture, carpets, pen and printer ink and more.
- **Improved Health: **Research from Norway (PDF) indicates that plants can reduce illness rates, including ailments such as a headaches, dry eyes, cough, and more. Plants are also natural humidifiers, which can reduce incidents of dry skin, sore throat, and dry coughs.
- **Mood Enhancer: **Office plants can reduce stress, boost mood, and improve perceptions of the workspace (make it a more appealing place to be).
- Increased Productivity: It goes without saying that good health and attitude leads to good productivity. Research suggests that plants also increase alertness and attentiveness, which is important to getting things done, as well. A Texas A&M study showed plants can improve creativity, another important factor in productivity.
in addition, you should probably look at some of the research and consider what HR does and you are providing a beneficial service for people in offices as well as for her people working at home during a pandemic. Make sure you use COVID-19Update the content to reflect the home office and then add a bit of your software into the content in a very clean and easily made relevant method.
Talk about how your company cares about workers this is in fact advice and it is actually beneficial to them at this time. This is not taking away from your site and overpowering your other pages.
THIS IS JUST ANOTHER OPPORTUNITY TO MIX ONE AND TWO TOGETHER.
- https://pittnews.com/article/157206/opinions/opinion-plants-are-more-important-than-ever-in-the-time-of-covid-19/
- https://www.ciphr.com/advice/8-easy-ways-to-create-and-maintain-a-healthy-workplace/
- https://i.imgur.com/CKCvMvZ.png
I know I added a lot of content here and I'm sorry that I did that. But I want you to understand that you can combine these two things because human resources and healthy workplaces go hand-in-hand and so dose the prevention of Covid-19 and plants clean the air
Do not We direct the plant page to the homepage. Combined the plant URL Content with something HR and publish it.
I hope this was of help
Tom
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Redirect question
Hi Everyone I've tried searching elsewhere in these forums for an answer to this but not having much luck - hope I'm not duplicating content! I get this message in Moz: "We have detected that the domain NappyValleyNet.com redirects to www.nappyvalleynet.com. We do not recommend tracking a redirect URL. Would you like to track www.nappyvalleynet.com for this campaign instead?" Is this a set-up issue on my side? I'm not sure what this means? Thank you!
On-Page Optimization | | NappyValleyNet0 -
Understanding why our new page doesn't rank. Internal link structure to blame? + understand canonical pages more.
Hi guys. Sorry it's an essay...BUT, i think a lot of you will find this an interesting question. This question is in 2 (related) parts, and I imagine it would be an 'advanced' SEO question. Hoping you guys can help bring some real insight 🙂 Always amazed at the quality for this forum/ community. **Context... ** We had a duplicate content issue caused by this page and it's product permutations, so we placed canonical tags on all the product permutations to solve it. Worked a treat. However, we now have more **product ranges. **We now sell Diaries, Notebooks & Music books, which are clearly different from one another. So...we've placed canonical tags on all the product permutations leading back to the 'parent' theme. In other words, all the diary permutations 'lead back' to the diary page. All the notebooks permutations 'lead back' to the main notebook page. So on and so forth. Make sense so far? Context end..... Issue. Amazingly our Diary page outranks our notebook pagefor the search term 'Design your own Notebook'. The notebook page is well optimised for this search term, and the diary page avoids the word 'notebook' altogether (so no keyword cannibalisation going on). Possible reason? Our Diary page has a vast amount of internal links to it throughout our site. The notebook page has only a few. Could this be the issue? If so, what reading/ blogs/ content/ tools would you recommend to help understand and solve this problem? i.e) Better understanding internal link structure for SEO. 2nd part of the question (in the context of internal linking for SEO). When there are internal links to a page with a conical tag does that 'count' towards the 'parent page', or simply towards that specific page? I really hope that makes sense. If it's clear as mud just shout. Isaac. EDIT: All pages in question have been indexed since we added these changes to the site.
On-Page Optimization | | isaac6630 -
Page Speed
Google recommends a page load speed of 1.4 seconds, is it recommended to have that page speed for every page on the site, or just the landing pages. Is there a tool that will check the load speed of every page on a site and report the slow pages? The free online tools only check one page at a time.
On-Page Optimization | | Bryan_Loconto0 -
Post url not matching with post title ( wordpress)
I have this site called searchoflife.com on which I have noticed the post urls are not matching with the post title. For Example:Post Title - A Dialogue With NaturePost URL - http://searchoflife.com/dialogue-nature-2013-09-12 Words like 'A' and 'with' are not present in the post URL. This has been the trend since a few days. After investigating I found out that it was due to my plugin SEO ultimate which is actually creating post slugs automatically for the post urls. So my question is whether it is advisable to use post slugs instead of the full post url. Does it affect the SERPS for my site?
On-Page Optimization | | toxicpls0 -
Can you 301 redirect to a page that has other pages 301 to it?
Two years ago updated url page to include better keywords and used a 301 redirect from the old page to the new. so www.example.com/keyword-1st-generation.html now points to ... www.example.com/keyword-2nd-generation.html That moved the pages up in ranking, but now have better kw for the url, so is it okay to redirect the /keyword-2nd-geration-html to www.example.com/keyword-3rd-generation.html And what is a good length of time before removing the 1st-generation url? It's been 3 years and there is no chance of using it again. Plus, no sign of it in analytics.
On-Page Optimization | | AllIsWell0 -
Page Title
Hi All, I am wondering if you could help me please. I am getting the following result after I run my On-Page Analysis Avoid Multiple Page Title Elements _Easy fix _ <dl style="font-style: normal;"> <dt>Page titles</dt> <dd>"Aquashowers-Shower Repairs Dublin -" and "Aquashowers - Shower Repairs Dublin"</dd> <dt>Explanation</dt> <dd>Web pages are meant to have a single title, and for both accessibility and search engine optimization reasons, we strongly recommend following this practice.</dd> <dt>Recommendation</dt> <dd>Remove all but a single page title element.</dd> </dl> Does this mean that i have 2 pages that are nearly identical or i should only name a page with one word? The reason i ask is because i have 1 page called "Aquashowers-Shower Repairs Dublin" and another called "Aquashowers-Dublin Shower Repair" I don't have a page called "Aquashowers - Shower Repairs Dublin" (with the space inbetween the words and the hyphen) Any help would be great. Thanks again Aidan
On-Page Optimization | | aidanlawlor0 -
Should I fix 302 redirects?
I have a Magento ecommerce site that allows customers to compare products. When SEOmoz crawled the site, it came back with over 6,000 302 redirect errors related to the compare products feature. Is this harming our rankings? And any suggestions on the best way to fix it?
On-Page Optimization | | AmazingPlans0 -
Home Page is Not Ranking Anymore on this ecommerce site
Hi Everyone, I work regularly on this site www.cheapsnapframes.co.uk which is a cubecart based site and upto a few months ago the home page used to rank on poster frames we were on page 1 of google now we are on page 2 but it has dropped the home page and favours a category page. I have been looking at this to try and figure out why and I have today realised I had some external links on the home page pointing to the .com which the site used to run from but has been setup as a 301 redirect so I have changed these to internal links. I have used the on page tool and get an A but its been showing an A for a long time. Is there any other reason why we have lost out on this keyword term? Thank you in advance Tracy
On-Page Optimization | | dashesndots0