Downtrodden Adwords Quality Scores -- Really?
-
Wow! 93% of our Adword keywords in our new campaign received a Quality Score of 4 or less. That means most of the keywords aren't showing.
I received the quick answer from our Adwords advisor that, "Quality score is created from a variety of factors ... etc." Yes, I know that by reading Google's documentation.
I dug deeper into the data.
When I looked at keywords dashboard for this campaign, what vexes me is that it's all about "Keyword relevance: poor". That is repeated time and again in the keywords hover, bubble pop-up in Adwords.
"Landing page quality: no problems".
"Landing page load time: no problems".
63% of keywords have quality score = 3
29% of keywords have quality score = 4
We have thousands of keywords that are electronic part numbers. All keywords use phrase matching. We use dynamic keyword matching in the ads.
I dug deeper. I chose random keywords (and corresponding landing pages) from lower quality scores (1,2,3,4) and higher scores (5,6,7,8,9,10). What is the difference?
Examples:
- Quality score 1 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/LM2901
- 2 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/BZX84-A20
- 3 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/MAX4796
- 4 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/TMP302A
- 5 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/LTC4267-3
- 6 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/CAT1161LI-28-G
- 7 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/DS1216C
- 8 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/R10S-E1Y1-J5.0K
- 9 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/208M822-19B11 145785-000
- 10 = http://www.usbid.com/parts/TP3-PNEU-0.250 243362-000
Notice URLs with score 9 and 10 have url-encoded space (%20) -- just pointing it out.
What is the difference between these pages that have such different quality score?
And, interestingly enough, the majority of example keywords in the Urls above (LM2901, BZX84-A20, etc) have zero impressions and zero clicks thus far.
Yes, the keywords have low traffic because this is exactly what people search for an purchase when making a B2B component buy. It's all about the exact part number.
**I'd love specific suggestions of how to improve quality score of pages with a 3 or lower! ** Thanks kindly, Loren
-
Loren first off in your number crunching, I'd suggest you calculate a weighted average of your Quality Score, whereby you take into account the number of impressions for each keyword.
This is my general thought based on limited knowledge of your account:
The most tell tale factor is that you have an aged account of 2+ years with a lousy historical CTR. This is going to greatly impact the QS of any keywords you add to your account no matter how relevant (or how much better you've gotten at creating relevant campaigns). Your predicted CTR is terrible, so your QS reflects that.
There is an implied volatility, and what I haven't been able to figure out is, how much change it takes to impact your QS. I've noticed that if your future CTR is really good, and your keywords have high volume impressions and clicks, the QS can improve very quickly (sometimes within days). But if the new keywords you've added are low volume, it can take a long time before your QS improves to reflect the underlying relevance.
George Michie of RKG wrote a detailed blog (rant) post about Quality Score, and while it doesn't directly answer your question, it does educate you on what goes on in that "black box."
-
I find it hard to answer these sort of questions without seeing the account from my experiences new accounts sometimes show bad scores when you first start a campaign. But if you see it across the account i would try to make sure the ads relate to what the people are searching for as best as possible etc this post might help you as well - http://support.google.com/adwords/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=2454010&from=10215&rd=1
-
I love that you're helping me dig deeper.
I crunched quality scores (export and into Excel) for two longer-running campaigns that get an acceptable number of leads/conversions for the cost.
Older campaign 1 : average quality score = 4.8
Older campaign 2 : average quality score = 4.2
So those aren't great either (imho) yet better than the current campaign.
More questions to help you noodle on my situation or do you have gems to share on how to raise the quality score?
Cheers, Loren
-
Do your old campaigns have bad scores also?
-
Hello David,
The whole account has been running for 2+ years.
This particular campaign was started yesterday -- alongside several campaigns that have been running for months.
CTR average = 0.63% (pretty lousy)
For today's data, 187 distinct keywords had clicks.
28% had CTR >= 50%
34% had CTR 10% - 49%
37% had CTR 0.07% - 0.09%
The median is 20% so that means a lot of the CTR are at the lower end.
We are in a loooooong tail business (with lots of part numbers) so the higher CTR are for 1 impression total, 1 click total, etc.
Lots of items with impressions and no clicks.
Search results are relevant given these are manufacturer part numbers.
**Great questions. Did I answer what you sought? **
I'd love additional thoughts from you. Kindly, Loren
-
What are your ctr's? How long Has your account been running? Also check search queries to see if the phrase match is bringing in relevant searches
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
When to switch off AdWords ads in your channel mix?
My question is actually Inspired by that very good article: https://moz.com/blog/google-organic-clicks-shifting-to-paid that I read this morning. Present situation: For a specific and valuable non-branded keyword combination (2-3 words) we rank: Google Adwords: position 1 Local Pack (with maps): position 1 Organic Search: position 3-5, lately more 5-6 Question?: Is it still worth having AdWords ads or not there? How to evaluate if we could do without AdWords? Any algorithm, experiment, thought that would help find out? We know our average cost per lead for the different channels. Just to leave away AdWords ads for a certain time is not really an option nor would that statistically mean anything, i.e. if we skip AdWords and have the same number of leads after that and compare it with the months before (with AdWords) that could also be due to other reasons (seasonal aspects, etc.). Put in other words: if we skip AdWords people would still click (more) on our other two search results (local & organic). I am not sure if the additional leads coming from AdWords outweigh the cost we have for that. Would love to know your thoughts about that. Thanks a lot for your input in advance. Cheers, Cesare
Paid Search Marketing | | Cesare.Marchetti0 -
Talking about competitors on your own website to improve quality score
Hi Mozzers, I'm seeing more and more companies improving their quality score by including information about their competitors on their website, when driving traffic from competitor brand terms. For example, for 'Yahoo Mail' related terms, Zoho drive traffic via an ad to this page: https://www.zoho.com/mail/yahoo-mail-alternative.html I'm planning a new campaign targeting competitor keywords and wondered what people think about this approach, and the legalities around talking about and comparing yourself to competitors on your own website?
Paid Search Marketing | | Zoope0 -
How do YOU do an AdWords Audit?
Audits Audits Audits! I am overhauling my AdWords Audit Process and the Documentation and I was wondering if any generous souls our there mind sharing a few ideas or learnings that they have had along the way? I aim to make it as thorough but as quick and automated (think scripts) as possible. I'm also 14 pages into the documentation that I will use for some audits that include explanations, recommendations & definitions. I'd love to hear your opinions on what to Audit, how to audit and how to report on it 🙂
Paid Search Marketing | | Singularitie0 -
Have you had success using adwords to promote blog content?
From time to time I see an ad pop up in search results for blog content and have often wondered how much success these ads have had in promoting the specific post. Does anyone have experience with this? What results did you see?
Paid Search Marketing | | unikey0 -
Do only paid adwords appear in google shopping
Does anyone know if we have to have a paid addwords campain for our products to appear in google shopping. We have a feed set up for google shopping. We have addwords campaigns running for google. But our products do not seem to appear in google shopping. Any advise on how to get them there?
Paid Search Marketing | | CostumeD0 -
Do Adwords affect organic rank?
I used to rank 2 for "guitar outlet" I just dropped to under 50th. Only change I made was to pause a Adwords campaign where I was including that keyword. Oddly enough, I believe I ranked high for that keyword BEFORE I added it as a keyword, but I cant be 100% sure due to lack of timing notes. But is it common for adwords to affect organic? If not...where do I start to look for the answer as to why it dropped?
Paid Search Marketing | | Retail_Endeavors0 -
Adwords & Analytics Different Product Listing Results
Hi We have recently set up a Product Listings ad campaign via AdWords and have seen some impressive initial figures in our AdWords account. However, when viewing data from the same period in Analytics it shows completely different statistics. For example, from 1st-16th June, AdWords shows 604 clicks and 29 conversions from our Product Listings campaign but Google Analytics only shows 23 clicks and 0 conversions across the same period. Any ideas why these variations show? Is there any additional tracking code that needs to be inserted at all? Thanks
Paid Search Marketing | | instinctive0 -
Adwords: Brand ads appear bottom of SERPs
Hello, I'm running a sale promotion on a brand only Adwords campaign (I have the only account with trademark authorization) and have noticed that my ads are appearing at the bottom of the first page on Google. This happened last week so I split the campaign into three Adgroups and that fixed the problem but today I'm running brand only and there is no way to separate them. CPC has also increased dramatically. Normally it's less than 10 cents and now it's sitting at between $2-$4. Has anyone else seen this? Any ideas/advice on how to stop this happening? It's playing havoc with my CTR and conversions. Much thanks,
Paid Search Marketing | | Unity
Davinia2