Does google places mind listing cities on the home page
-
Hello,
A site in our industry is listing a bunch of cities on their home page and ranking for them. Like
"Our dog training facility provides services to dogs in city1,city2,city3,city4,city5,city6 state"
where the cities and states are relatively in their area.
It's working organically, will this confuse google places?
Thanks!
-
My pleasure, Bob!
-
Awesome Miriam, thank you!
-
Hi Bob,
This is an interesting question, in light of a recent update to the Google Webmaster Guidelines. Here is a link: http://support.google.com/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=66358.
And here is the text of the update: ------------------------------------
Keyword stuffing
"Keyword stuffing" refers to the practice of loading a webpage with keywords or numbers in an attempt to manipulate a site's ranking in Google search results. Often these keywords appear in a list or group, or out of context (not as natural prose). Filling pages with keywords or numbers results in a negative user experience, and can harm your site's ranking. Focus on creating useful, information-rich content that uses keywords appropriately and in context. Examples of keyword stuffing include:
Lists of phone numbers without substantial added value
Blocks of text listing cities and states a webpage is trying to rank for
Repeating the same words or phrases so often that it sounds unnatural, for example: We sell custom cigar humidors. Our custom cigar humidors are handmade. If you’re thinking of buying a custom cigar humidor, please contact our custom cigar humidor specialists at custom.cigar.humidors@example.com.
Note the second point on that list. Now, in my opinion, what Google is going after with that guideline is a practice I encounter on many local sites wherein someone posts a lists of cities (often in the footer) like this:
Auburn, Audubon, Arrington, Burnside, Camden, Cordell, Craton, Douglas, Douglas Pines, Farmington, Golden, Graham, Hyden, Isleton, Jonesy, Killey, Landow, Mongtomery, Noel Hill, etc.
You see this all the time. Sometimes the city names link to thin content, duplicate pages, and sometimes they don't link anywhere at all. It appears, from the guidelines, that Google does not like this practice.
However, my gut feeling is that Google will view this example differently:
Our dog trainers will come to your home in San Francisco, Berkeley, San Jose, Oakland and San Rafael for gentle canine behavioral training. We schedule appointments that are convenient for you, as you need to be present during each training session.
The difference here is that a short list of a few target cities has been incorporated into a paragraph of text in a natural manner. If, however, the business serves a huge list of cities, like the sample cited above, I would not list that in a block anywhere on the site. Rather, I would encourage the client to begin developing unique, strong pages of content, one by one, for each city, perhaps documenting a training session of a cute dog in a given city on each page. I would then work these into a menu tab called, "Where We Serve," or something along those lines. It's very important to avoid letting this approach turn into a weak effort resulting in duplicate content pages that mimic one another, only swapping out city names. This is a task that should be seen as an opportunity to produce some of the best copy on the website.
Now, all this being said, there are still tons of sites out there with blocks of city names linking to thin, duplicate content that are managing to pull consistent high organic rankings. For clients, this can be a temptation to imitate what a competitor like this is doing. This is where you can help by letting the client know that making a better effort than their competitor has may provide protection from future penalties, should a Google update target certain practices, or should Google turn an eye of heightened scrutiny on the client's industry. With Google, an ounce of prevention is always worth a pound of cure!
Hope this helps, Bob!
-
if it is a legitimate reason that you have to list more than one city. For instance they're not cities but actually just towns? That is fine you can get away with that just fine in fact you can tell them you walk dogs and every city that you legitimately do make sure that you sign up with Google places and link it to that account it will help legitimize any doubts Google may have.
Respectfully,
Thomas
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Ranking App Store page in Google
Hey - has anyone had any experience in getting their App Store listing page to rank highly in Google for one of their primary keywords? If so, have you been successful and have you any pointers?
Image & Video Optimization | | GrowTraffic0 -
Places page help
Hi I was hoping somebody could provide me with some help regarding places pages. If I search 'recruitment agencies Chester' I get this result https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=recruitment+agencies+chester&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&client=firefox-a&gws_rd=cr&ei=LsBTUr6rJ8Sw0wXt74CQAg I am confused as to why certain sites are ranking higher than others for example: The site with the a) ranking has no reviews and the place page doesn't seem particularly optimised. The site ranked at c) has 2 bad reviews The site ranked at g) seems to have a much more optimised places page yet ranks below the other sites. Is this just a strange batch of results or can somebody provide me with more information/ help? I don't understand the ranking system at the moment. Thanks for any help you might be able to offer!
Image & Video Optimization | | onlinechester0 -
LOCAL SEO: Franchise --> One storefront. Multiple territory. Multiple listings?
An interesting problem came our way, and I'd love your help in solving it. An individual I'm chatting with owns and manages a number of territories of a service-based Franchise business around Eastern Iowa.**His territory covers multiple cities and zips. He services all of those places, but does not have a physical presence in all. There is one company office. But he has local numbers for each territory.**The corporate franchise's website is dynamic. It shows the 'local' number and information based on the visitor's location. Basically, little microsites for each franchise territory.Three years ago he set up individual Google Places pages for each territory, using a PO box address and the local phone numbers. The Google listings are set up not to display an address. The kick is -- those addresses are now expired. Those Google Local listings still exist, and drive considerable traffic in each target city. As you can imagine, this also causes havoc on his other citations. There are scattered (YP, Yahoo, Yelp, etc) listings for each address. Their name in GetListed brings up all five different addresses, each with a number of web properties already claimed.Now that I've offered to help, I need to determine the best way to move forward. Suspend the verified listings with hidden addresses and move to a single listing for the office location? We could add all of the zips in manually, but it would cover a very wide range, and could lose its rank in local SERPs. Even with a well-optimized description. And the local numbers would likely not show up. Keep the listings. Don't touch them at all. The owner is looking to maintain the look and feel of a local business in each of his territories. That is difficult to do with a single listing. Assuming we decide not to touch the active listings (option 2), what will we do for other listings? Do we claim a local Yahoo listing for each location? Just for the corporate office? Would love to hear how others have attacked the multi-territory franchise problem, or would in this case.Thanks!
Image & Video Optimization | | SocialJosh0 -
Why do seomoz rankings not match mine in google for the same keyword?
SEO moz lists my site http://holmesbailbonding.com as listing 2nd for raleigh bail bonds but when I search I am getting different results even with a cleared cache. Just wondering what factors contribute to this and what I need to be doing more of to get my site to rank for Raleigh Bail Bonds in raleigh, nc. Thanks,
Image & Video Optimization | | MaddDogg0 -
Google Places - second listing, same name
We will open a new office at a new location and I would like to add it to our Google places. How do I do this? Per Google guidelines: "Do not create more than one listing for each business location, either in a single account or multiple accounts." - Website & Phone: Provide a phone number that connects to your individual business location as directly as possible, and provide one website that represents your individual business location_._ Do I have to another contact page on my website for that location too? I will end up having to business listing with the same name but different locations. I want people to know that we have 2 separate offices because they serve different clients. I want to show up in Google places for the second location as well. Any thoughts?
Image & Video Optimization | | echo10 -
Local SEO: What is the largest Google Places bulk upload you have ever done?
Hi All, One of my clients recently requested my team at our agency to do a bulk up load of business locations. We did the bulk upload and it came to around 652 or so locations in the form. I have done some serious bulk uploads in the past around 500 locations but never this high. My question is to SEO moz what is the largest bulk upload or single upload you have done on Google Places?
Image & Video Optimization | | JamesNorquay0 -
How to get my forum to be listed on Google in the Discussions section?
I'm running several community sites with forums (for example http:// www.finalstitch.co.uk). All of those sites have a forum section like http://http://www.finalstitch.co.uk/forum/ So far Google didn't recognize the forum. When I search for the site and click the Discussions filter on the left, no forum topics from my site show up. What should I do to change that? Thank you. 20110616-gu1beph7p673x1jkgahy1q63r.jpg
Image & Video Optimization | | asmirasro0 -
Ranking Penalty in Google Places for Primary Cell Phone Number?
Say a business runs out of a home (so, technically, the address of the business has a land line). But the business owner works outdoors all day long and so really runs his business off his cell phone. Is it OK in Google Places to list the mobile phone as the primary contant number, and list the home phone as a secondary number? Or will Google penalize the business's ranking in local search results for using a cell number as the main number?
Image & Video Optimization | | keethgee0