Did Google Search Just Get Crazy Local?
-
Hey All,
I think it's a known fact at this point that when signed into a personal Google account while doing a search, the results are very oriented around keywords and phrases you have already searched for, as well as your account's perceived location; for instance when I wanted to check one of my own web properties in SE listings I would sign out or it would likely appear first as a false reading.
Today I noticed something very interesting: even when not signed in, Google's listings were giving precedence to locality. It was to a very extreme degree, as in when searching for "web design," a firm a mile away ranked higher than one 1.5 miles away and such.
It would seem that the algos having this high a level of location sensitivity and preference would actually be a boon for the little guys, which is, I assume why it was implemented. However, it brings up a couple of interesting questions for me.
1. How is this going to affect Moz (or any SE ranking platform, for that matter) reports? I assume that Google pulls locations from IP Addresses, therefore would it not simply pull the local results most relevant for the Moz server(s) IP?
2. What can one do to rise above this aggressive level of location based search? I mean, my site (which has a DA of 37 and a PA of 48) appears above sites like webdesign.org (DA of 82, PA of 85). Not that I'm complaining at the moment, but I could see this being a fairly big deal for larger firms looking to rank on a national level.
What gives? I'd love to get some opinions from the community here if anyone else has noticed this...
-
Thanks David. Very helpful info.
-
Hi David,
To answer your first question what you are seeing does not affect Moz at all as we use multiple IPs to avoid bias. In OpenSiteExplorer links are not affected by locality.
Check out the FAQ we have for Universal Rankings at the bottom of this link: http://moz.com/help/pro/rankings
Hope that helps!
-
Thanks, Miriam!
-
Great discussion going on here! David, I will ask our help staff to look at your question #1.
-
I'm on PC but only shows for me on FF not Chrome yet.
-
I was just looking at it on Chrome for the sample term "italian restaurant". It also works in Firefox for me. Are you running a Mac? I'm on one of our office PCs right now.
-
Just announced this AM. If you read my post previously, read again. I just added a Q & A from Googler Jade.
I just got the carousel to come up myself now. Does not work for me on Chrome but does on FF oddly. So I'm off to explore and see what I can figure out.
-
Local Carousel is pretty cool, Linda. I did not know it had launched yet!
I assume they finally switched over a proprietary rating system and it's not Zagat based any more (I can only get the carousel to come up for restaurants)?
-
David, assumed you were talking organic but then you said: "Google's listings were giving precedence to locality. It was to a very extreme degree, as in when searching for "web design," a firm a mile away ranked higher than one 1.5 miles away and such."
Since you mentioned distance thought then that maybe you were looking at a map result, so I wanted to clarify and make sure you were not seeing something new. But I guess since you know the area you just know where others in your market are located.
BTW on a semi related note, I just announced the new Local Carousel display was officially launched. Pretty exciting! (Related talking about Google Local algo and display changes at least.)
-
Well said, Marcus.
-
Hey, I don't think that has changed much really. Just now you will be competing not only against other national players but against local companies as well.
Open your Yellow Pages book (yeah, we have one, it's kind of thin nowadays though) and you see adverts for brands in the local search and local companies - search seems to be edging ever closer to this.
Oh, and there is always PPC - I don't see Google dropping that any time soon.
I think we are entering a time where a well rounded out digital marketing plan includes local, national, social, content and paid search adverts in search and across display networks. We also have all the other aspects here including lead generation, re-targeting and the like that really help round things out.
It's good that someone can't just buy links and rely on Google - people have to market properly and that is why this industry is just so much fun.
-
With regards to question number one in my initial post, I can only assume that Moz and other ranking platforms will in fact broaden the local search radius to a national level by default.
That again raises the question of what to do if you or an entity you represent wish to rank internationally...
-
Marcus,
I totally agree that this is a good thing and can't deny it's pretty helpful for us. I think in general it's pretty cool to see a tech giant taking major strides toward helping small businesses compete and building local community networks up. Kind of refreshing actually...
If you take a look at the following, it actually appears that you cannot turn location based search off now; just widen the geographical area.
-
Hey David
We don't tend to see a 7 pack for web design companies in the UK but we are seeing more and more localisation even in the standard organic results. A search for 'web design' shows local companies and is not a million miles away from a search for 'web design Birmingham' which is where I am based.
Same as my initial response though, I see this being primarily a good thing and most people searching for 'web design' or even one of the more traditional business categories will likely be looking for a local company and Google would want to best match the results to the intent of the search query and in this case, I think they are doing a pretty good job.
So, whether that is more localised organic results or more blending of 1 packs, 3 packs and 7 packs in amongst organic results (which are themselves seemingly more localised) this is a good thing that helps users and levels the playing field.
Hope that helps
Marcus
-
To clarify; I am talking about pure organic results, not a 7-pack (formerly 10-pack?). Take a look at the attached image to verify if you'd like.
As I said, you can change the target location using the Search Tools function, however I can't see that many people knowing to do this and the query automatically detects your location by default.
-
Hey David, sounds like you are seeing a shift that's different than what you normally see? I'm curious if you are seeing an algo change and would like to explore further.
Google does not normally show local 'pinned' results that show in a 7 pack for web design type keywords. Yet you are talking how close one listing is over another so it sounds like maybe you are seeing a pack?
Could you share the exact search term you are using and whether you are seeing and talking about pure organic or 7 pack?
-
Hey David
I am seeing similar things in the UK and in most industries localisation has really been turned up in the last 12 months (and seemingly even more since penguin 2.0 / 4.0).
In most cases it seems this is a good thing and searching for the kind of business that would generally have a local intent returns local results. We also now see a 7 pack of local results directly after the PPC for a wide range of queries and business categories.
Now, if we search for the obvious ones: accountant, lawyer, builder etc it is almost always localised. No need for a city or town either as it uses the assumed location.
I think this is interesting in a number of ways
- click to call from mobile meaning folks don't even need to visit the website
- organic #1 is now really #11 at best for many highly commercial terms
- even organic listings seem much more influenced by localisation
I tend to think that this will train people to search like this more and more and for many commercial terms traditional SEO will lose a lot of value. Obviously, search still has tons of opportunities for organic and content marketing but if this helps small local businesses get found more easily and further halts the tiresome tactics that have tainted this industry then it's all good in my mind.
We are having some great success with small companies with Local SEO, localised organic and region specific PPC campaigns and it's always nice to help the little man get found over the big national brand.
Marcus
-
You can of course change your location from the auto detected one to whatever you wish using search tools, but I doubt most would do that.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
What Google Analytics Data to Share with Potential Website Buyer
Hi Mozzers,
Industry News | | emerald
We have contacted our competitors to let them know we would like to sell our website (domain and all content). One of them has asked for Google Analytics data. Which parts of this and how is this data best shared in such a case? As this is the opening of offers, I'm assuming some kind of PDF export with a summary of some Analytics data is sufficient to see who is serious. Then for those who are serious more data could be shared. Or is it ever ok to share your full Analytics with a competitor? Would love to hear what data and best practises are used to share this kind of information. Thank you.0 -
Google Site Warnings via Phone?
I received a voicemail earlier stating that "there are two issues with your company's current Google listing that we need to discuss with the business owner. it is very important that we talk as soon as possible. press 1 to speak with an agent immediately. press 8 if you have already verified your account information or if you are no longer in business and want to be removed from this list. thank you" that's it. no contact number, no reference to what listing or what type of listing (organic, places, etc.) Checked GWT, GA, and the Gmail - there are no warnings or messages in any of those accounts. Has anyone else experienced this?
Industry News | | EmpireToday0 -
Google Analytics (Not Provided) Count will Increase 100% by Oct 2014 ? - Your Advice ?
What will you Do if you cannnot find your Top Keyword in Google Analytics "not provided"
Industry News | | Esaky
Check here for more details: http://www.notprovidedcount.com/0 -
Google Analytics Tracking Miscount - Originating Around 5/24
Is anyone else experiencing an issue where it seems GA failed to track many of their visitors? This is why I think it's something on GA's end and not mine (and not natural): 1. No changes were made, site wasn't down, tracking code is correct and is "receiving data" 2. Referral, Direct and Organic traffic all dropped at about the same decline over the same period *3. Pinterest Analytics shows me being sent over 10 times more traffic every day than GA shows me actually receiving. In the screenshot, Pinterest shows 584 uniques while GA shows 43 for Sunday. I figure if something was broken, I wouldn't be showing ANY traffic and if it was natural, it wouldn't have happened on the same decline across all traffic mediums and Pinterest Analytics wouldn't be so far off. I saw a few people mentioning similar things on Google's forums and wanted to ask you guys if anyone noticed any issues? y8XAvwz.png pRsRAmK.png
Industry News | | zDucketz0 -
URL Search removal tool.
Hi All! I have tried to request a URL removal from Google search for an old testing site they still have listed. Ive tried requesting removal of the domain and of individual pages, all requests are getting rejected. Any help would be gratefully appreciated 😄 Many Thanks Anthony
Industry News | | Anthonykal-group0 -
Paste 'do a barrel roll' into Google - See what happens!!
Hi, Paste the words 'do a barrel roll' in Google and see what happens!
Industry News | | activitysuper0 -
What is the best method for getting pure Javascript/Ajax pages Indeded by Google for SEO?
I am in the process of researching this further, and wanted to share some of what I have found below. Anyone who can confirm or deny these assumptions or add some insight would be appreciated. Option: 1 If you're starting from scratch, a good approach is to build your site's structure and navigation using only HTML. Then, once you have the site's pages, links, and content in place, you can spice up the appearance and interface with AJAX. Googlebot will be happy looking at the HTML, while users with modern browsers can enjoy your AJAX bonuses. You can use Hijax to help ajax and html links coexist. You can use Meta NoFollow tags etc to prevent the crawlers from accessing the javascript versions of the page. Currently, webmasters create a "parallel universe" of content. Users of JavaScript-enabled browsers will see content that is created dynamically, whereas users of non-JavaScript-enabled browsers as well as crawlers will see content that is static and created offline. In current practice, "progressive enhancement" in the form of Hijax-links are often used. Option: 2
Industry News | | webbroi
In order to make your AJAX application crawlable, your site needs to abide by a new agreement. This agreement rests on the following: The site adopts the AJAX crawling scheme. For each URL that has dynamically produced content, your server provides an HTML snapshot, which is the content a user (with a browser) sees. Often, such URLs will be AJAX URLs, that is, URLs containing a hash fragment, for example www.example.com/index.html#key=value, where #key=value is the hash fragment. An HTML snapshot is all the content that appears on the page after the JavaScript has been executed. The search engine indexes the HTML snapshot and serves your original AJAX URLs in search results. In order to make this work, the application must use a specific syntax in the AJAX URLs (let's call them "pretty URLs;" you'll see why in the following sections). The search engine crawler will temporarily modify these "pretty URLs" into "ugly URLs" and request those from your server. This request of an "ugly URL" indicates to the server that it should not return the regular web page it would give to a browser, but instead an HTML snapshot. When the crawler has obtained the content for the modified ugly URL, it indexes its content, then displays the original pretty URL in the search results. In other words, end users will always see the pretty URL containing a hash fragment. The following diagram summarizes the agreement:
See more in the....... Getting Started Guide. Make sure you avoid this:
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=66355
Here is a few example Pages that have mostly Javascrip/AJAX : http://catchfree.com/listen-to-music#&tab=top-free-apps-tab https://www.pivotaltracker.com/public_projects This is what the spiders see: view-source:http://catchfree.com/listen-to-music#&tab=top-free-apps-tab This is the best resources I have found regarding Google and Javascript http://code.google.com/web/ajaxcrawling/ - This is step by step instructions.
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=81766
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/how-to-allow-google-to-crawl-ajax-content
Some additional Resources: http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2009/10/proposal-for-making-ajax-crawlable.html
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/how-to-allow-google-to-crawl-ajax-content
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?answer=357690 -
How to remove a Google algorithmic penalty
My site has a Google penalty. I seem to be stuck in the 64th position for a Google search for my sites name. All my keywords that I used to rank well for are now well above the 60th search place in Google. I have resolved the issue I recieved the penalty for and I have asked Google for reconsideration. That has been about 3 months ago. The penalty is still firmly in place. I was wondering if anyone else has had a Google algorithmic penalty removed and if so how did they accomplish this?
Industry News | | tadden0