Evaluating Competition of a Keyword
-
I'm curious about how others evaluate the competition of keywords when putting together an SEO program:
-
Do you place any faith in the competition listing in the Google Keyword Tool?
-
Do you find value in SEOmoz's Keyword Difficulty tool?
-
What other tactics or processes do you perform?
-
-
I know that this is an old thread, but I must say that it's EXACTLY what I was looking for!!!
I too have been puzzled by the Competitiveness scores produced by different tools (Wordtracker, MOZ etc). Many of the keywords I've researched in my particular field (refurbished laptops and computers) show Low Competition in these tools, but when I perform a regular search on Google, the first two pages are often populated by big name brands (Amazon, Bestbuy, NewEgg,Walmart, Sears, Overstock etc.)... which I assume would be difficult to rank above.
The interesting thing here is that these big brand pages don't often score high on backlinks, In-Anchor-and-Title or other Competitiveness indicators, but yet, they rank high on the SERPs.
I'm definitely a newbie at this, but this article puts the missing pieces together for me.
THANKS!
-
In order to identify true competition, I always add "allintitle" to my query to exclude 'less focused' competitors. Do you agree?
-
Hey, I agree, none of these scores are a truly reliable indicator. What I try to do is aggregate lots of different values.
- Competition from adwords to get an idea of quality
- keyword difficult from Moz tool to get some metrics on competition
- exact match search volume to get an idea of traffic
Then, the real work is built on top of this with a manual review of the results for each term. If the results are garbage - be that the content or the competition then you can read into this. If the results are dominated by big brands with well optimised pages then you are going to struggle.
If the manual review you do (loads of big brands) ties up with a high difficult from the moz keyword tool then this should scare you off!
If the moz tool comes back with 30% and the content returned is a bit ropey and you know you can do better then... you should go after it.
As I say, it's a science more than an art and you have to manually review each keyword to really know what it's worth chasing.
If your keyword was 'seo software' and you had a keyword difficult of 79% and quality sites like SEOMoz.org at the bottom of page 2 - I would leave that one well alone. :
-
I don't think that the number of sites competitng or their pagerank or keyword tool scores are 100% reliable.
Instead look at WHO is competing and the content that they have on their pages.
If you can beat their content then you have a really good chance of defeating them.... but if you are going up against the manufacturer on their branded products they will be hard to beat... but then you can put a discount price in your title tag and steal their sales.
-
This is an art rather than an exact science but there are certainly things you can do to help decide which terms to go for.
1. Google Keyword Tool is for Adwords traffic & not organic search. This is not to say that it is not useful and the competitor information here can be used to gauge the quality of the keyword. That is, if there is a lot of paid search competition for this keyword, then it must convert well so it is usually worth pursuing.
2. The keyword difficulty tool is useful as it looks at the metrics involved in ranking for the search term. There is a post on SEOMoz that explains the values returned and what is needed to do to rank for a term scoring X% - http://www.seomoz.org/blog/keyword-difficulty-tool-upgrade
3. Other tactics
I tend to do it like this:
- Set up a table with the keywords in for each page
- Get the advertiser competition as a quality score
- Get the seomoz difficulty score
- Get the exact match search volume from google adwords
Then I search for the keyword and check out the competition to look for two things
- Quality of results in terms of content & relevance
- Who ranks & how optimised are the first ten results
I am generally looking for cracks. Are there a lack of quality results? Great, it's an opportunity to make something better and get it rank - compare the organic & paid content as these guys are paying for the clicks so these pages are more likely to be finely tuned. Is there a lack of well optimised pages? Groovy, that's a crack and we can likely fight our way up the ranks.
Obviously, there is so much too this. What is the standing of the site you are looking to optimise? Can you or the client create great content to help better fill the requirements of the search terms. Are there are opportunities with little competition, poorly optimised pages, bad landing page content etc.
By building a spreadsheet of keywords like this, I then highlight them as I go. Red is no good, orange is possible or a future term, green is worth a crack.
Then... if they are difficult keywords, you can further assess the quality of the keywords and content you are planning to land them on with a brief adwords campaign & some conversion tracking in Google Analytics.
After all of that, you have some intelligence on which to base your search campaign and organic optimisation efforts.
Hope it helps!
Marcus -
I hold VERY little faith that the numbers in Google's keyword tool are accurate. I think it is a good indicator of traffic levels, especially if you compare it against other sources, like WordTracker, but I try to normalize the numbers and look at them as relative values. I dont believe the actual search volumes.
The SEOmoz tool used to be difficult to use but I find it to be much improved. It is a good snapshot of what types of site/pages are ranking for a keyword and saves me a lot of legwork.
I really like Rands post here. http://www.seomoz.org/blog/10-steps-to-advanced-keyword-research
The process is pretty labor intensive, but I think well worth it if your client is willing to pay for it.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Relevant but not-relevant keywords impact to SEO
Hello, I would like to know if the selection of individual keywords(that are not primary, secondary or tertiary) are important for SEO regardless of the relevancy to the page topic. I am wondering how much of a contribution a non-P1/P2/P3 can make in terms of SEO? For example it is a product page and I have built my content with P1,P2&P3 based only on the product and its properties itself. Do you think that a content gap for the page could be the production process of that product? So even if it is a product and its properties page, I can add 2 sentences about the production, so that I can drive more traffic by including these 2 informative sentences.? EXAMPLE:
Keyword Research | | Siir
So lets' say my topic is "hair types" (P1) and my subtopics are "Straight," "wavy," and "curly"(P2s) which I used as subtitles. But throughout the page, I am planning to add some relevant but not-directly-relevant keywords here and there since they have high metrics and volumes. For example a potential sentence I can add: "innovative hair products these days can offer amazing results for the desired hair types". It is not specifically about "hair types" but I am using the keyword "innovative hair products" (good metrics keyword) which may help for the traffic... Another potential not-so-direct sentence can be: "For all hair types, the hair damages are common: heat damage, chemical damage and mechanical damage". Would adding this extra sentence where I am not specifically talking about "hair types" (my topic) but "hair damages" and damage examples (off-topic high metric keywords) help me to drive traffic to my website? And how much of an impact would it be?0 -
Ranking a homepage for keywords
We recently found a handful of keywords we would like our homepage to rank for (for example - customer experience). On our homepage we have articles (4-5 posted daily) that feature the keywords we are targeting (one being customer experience). How do the keywords we are using in our daily articles that are posted to the homepage affect the overall keyword ranking for the homepage? In other words do the keywords used in the articles (title, first 2-3 paragraphs, meta description, etc.) all roll up/build up to the homepage's keywords or how does that work?
Keyword Research | | carlystemmer0 -
Wrong page ranking for keyword.
I have a page i'm trying to rank for certain keywords around "emergency vet clinic" the page is domain.com/emergency-vet-care but my home page is the one that is ranking better and better. How can I get the other page to rank for e.g. "emergency vet care" , "emergency animal care" and the main page to rank for just regular vet care? My on page looks pretty good. I've also taken out most references to emergency care on the main home page except for the one link to it. Thanks
Keyword Research | | swagseo0 -
How to choose a Keyword
I searched around for this answer first but got information overload. I write a photography blog and tonight I will put up a post of photography from around Jiyugaoka Train Station. I will probably call the post Around Jiyugaoka Station or Around Jiyugaoka or something like that. I like in Jiyugaoka (a part of Tokyo) so I have other posts that I have keyworded for Jiyugaoka. What is the best way to determine what is the best derivative of 'Jiyugaoka Station' to choose for the best traffic? I assume I could enter them in to manually into the Keyword Analysis but is there is easier way that would give recommendations?
Keyword Research | | ShootTokyo0 -
How do I balance conflicting keyword research tools?
We've been using Wordtracker for years to find viable long tail keyword options. Lately, we've begun to doubt the true usefulness of this tool. We have implemented good optimization efforts using relevant keywords that Wordtracker suggests as reasonably well-searched with relatively low competition. Even when we rank well for these words, we get no traffic for them. Subsequent checking of these words in Google AdWords reveal that Google has found no searches for these words at all. Suspicious, we've begun cross-checking our keywords in AdWords and the Moz Keyword Difficulty tool. But now I keep getting contradictory reports. For example, a keyword I recently checked reported thus: In Wordtracker: high competition and low search In AdWords: high competition and decent search In Moz: only moderately competitive Who do I believe? How do other people weight the opinions of the various keyword research tools?
Keyword Research | | MackenzieFogelson0 -
Best keyword research tool
Okay, what is the BEST keyword research tool? I've heard all across the board, but I'm looking for preferrably a free tool, but just want to use one that can do competitive research, as well as find me a ton of long tail.
Keyword Research | | azguy0 -
A good rule of thumb for competition and local searches when selecting keywords
I'm doing keyword research in the Google Keyword Tool and was looking and spending a lot of time looking at keyword competition and local searches. I'm trying to determine what is a good rule of thumb for what level of competition and local searches people have used when selecting the keywords they will optimize for. I've currently been trying to find ones that have less than 50% (moderate) competition and less than 1,000 monthly searches. Also, which do you put more weight on the competition or the number of searches.
Keyword Research | | EricVallee341 -
Keyword Difficulty Score Assesment
What is a good keyword difficulty score to pursue when deciding which keywords to try and rank on? I'm in a very competitive field and I am currently in the process of doing keyword research to look for the low hanging fruit.
Keyword Research | | 13375auc30