Meta Descriptions - Does Cutt's comment still hold true?
-
When looking through my old research on Meta's came across this article on Search Engine Land where Matt Cutt's stated...
"In fact, Matt said for his own blog, he doesn’t bother to make meta descriptions for his own site. In short, it is better to let Google auto-create snippets for your pages versus having duplicate meta descriptions."(http://searchengineland.com/googles-matt-cutts-dont-duplicate-your-meta-descriptions-177706)
Recently, I have seen Google continuously play around with my metas, pulling from some really weird places on the page, discrediting the meta that I have there..and more-or-less really f them up..
Does the community think that maybe what Matt said in 2013 still holds weight and we are just wasting time with metas since Google does what they want in that space anyways?
-
I write all of my own meta descriptions and spend good time on them. Much of the time, my meta description is grabbed and shown verbatim in the SERPs. In that meta description I can give a nice list of topics covered in my article or features of a product or value proposition on shipping. I read lots of meta descriptions and use them to decide if the page is worth a click. I don't think that I am the only person who does this,
Why would I spend three days writing an article and then not write a nice meta description? Or, not write a description with clever marketing for a product that I sell hundreds of per year. Why would I not shoot finely-crafted arrows when I can?
Keep in mind that Google has a mentality to do everything with an algo.
And that can be a huge problem.
How many people have their adsense accounts banned unjustly with no possible appeal? How much adwords advice is given poorly? How many times does google email me that my traffic has fallen off a cliff the day after Thanksgiving? How many times does their program send adsense policy violations in error? How many times do they give the wrong person credit for images in image search? How many times does their parameter management in WMT not work and you fix it yourself using htaccess? Google is even know to list wrong numbers for police stations in knowledge boxes! (Stopping here, I could keep going but you get the idea.).
Google has a philosophy that "we would rather do stuff half-ass at scale, than have a human tool do it right most of the time". Doing stuff with algos at scale is OK much of the time and Google is quite good at it..... but my advice is do not allow google to do anything important for you that you can do for yourself.
I am going to bet on me, and if you think that you are a reasonably smart person, then maybe you should bet on you.
-
I think Matt's point was that he'd prefer to let Google generate meta descriptions - in the hope they'd be unique - rather than using the same one repeatedly.
My view? You should be writing unique meta descriptions for all of your key landing and sales pages.
Not for SEO - far from it. But because it's the shop window that people will see before they reach your site via organic search. You have a great opportunity to make it compelling, to attract the click away from others around (or above you) and to get your unique selling points across.
Google can never do a better job at that than you.
-
I'd rather have as much control as possible over how my result is displayed in the SERPs. I think if you make your meta description relevant enough to your page that Google doesn't consider it not as good as theirs (at least for the more obvious queries. Can't please all those longtails), then you can use the description to really sell the page to the searcher.
I think Matt's saying though that it's better to specify no meta description at all than use duplicate descriptions across multiple pages.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
We've a client that wants to repurpose some of the content on there site but not lose rankings. However its changing the content to an alternative to ....
The Current URL Example would be test.co.uk/prodcut-catogory/product-1 . This side of the business is being sold however they have products elsewhere in the range that can be used as alternatives to the product range that will be moved, so they want to amend these pages with an " alternative " slant. Example idea would be to change to the following : test.co.uk/prodcut-catogory/alternative-to-product-1, trying not to change the URL to much, keeping the majority of the content the same but adding new copy stating the benefits of using the alternative product. So it becomes a comparison between the two. I appreciate I will have to amend the URLs, titles, meta, H1s, add new copy & preform a 301's. Option 2 Simply write a second page which is all brand new content talking about it being an alternative to the products and doing a 301 from the original page but not amending that. Be great to get peoples feedback on this approach and if there is anything else that I could do to minimise the drop in rankings once I complete the changes. Thank you D
Conversion Rate Optimization | | SDOwner0 -
How to fix canonicalization so Google shows our company's website and not LinkedIn
I work for a company that builds and manages apartments. I would like to know how we can fix canonicalization. You see, we have been posting our company's blog articles not only on our company's website, but also on LinkedIn. When people search for one of our articles, Google is displaying the article for LinkedIn. Except, that's not what we want. I'd prefer for Google to display our company's website, to drive more traffic to our website and not LinkedIn. For instance I just Googled the title to one of our company's blog article "Great Leadership is about Influence not Authority." The first thing to show up was a link to see the article on LinkedIn. There was nothing referring to our company's website. Here is a link to the LinkedIn account where we have been posting the blogs: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/great-leadership-influence-authority-mike-kaeding/ Here is a link to the same article, but on our company's website: https://www.norhart.com/blog/2018/08/08/great-leadership-is-about-influence-not-authority/ Why is Google showing the article for Linkedin and not our Company's website? Might LinkedIn have canonicalization over Google? If so, how might we be able to reverse this and drive people to our company's blog instead. Any ideas I'd greatly appreciate it! Thanks.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | mikleing0 -
Please can anyone recommend any GOOD 'TRAFFIC BUYING COMPANIES ?
Hi Guys I really need some help here I am looking for some good traffic buying companies where we can buy traffic from that can will help us to generate leads from our own website. We want to 'buy traffic' that is targeted and generate leads from our website. We are running Google ad words but it is now becoming more and more expensive to run! Please can anyone recommend any good companies ? Thanks Gareth
Conversion Rate Optimization | | GAZ090 -
Magento Plugin that speeds up loading time - Too good to be true??
Hi everyone, Has anyone ever used this plugin http://templates-master.com/magento-page-cache-extension.html? I am looking for solution for my Magento websites. They all seem to be a bit slow no matter what web host I use. Thanks Carla
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Carla_Dawson0 -
Google Analytics: Do 'Goals' actually work?
Hi, Hoping someone can clarify this for me. I've set a goal up whereby the rule is to pick up all pages with "Thank-you" in the destination URL (regular expression). So, when someone fills out a form, it will count as a lead. I'm about 8 weeks in to the campaign now and measuring the last 4 weeks I've had a total of 30 goals completed. I have two issues with this and I really hope someone can help clarify: Using a custom report I can see that I've actually had 52 Visits to the Thank-You pages, 49 Unique Visits and 60 pageviews. Where is Google getting the goals from? I have 51 leads in my inbox from the campaign so far. So, much closer to the above stats in the custom report than in the Goal report. Why is this? Thanking you in advance!
Conversion Rate Optimization | | IndustrySteve0 -
What's the Best Method of Content Distribution
This question is both specific and open ended. I have a new web project I've been working on content for. I paid to have a really sweet research article written and I am in the process of turning it into an info-graphic as well. Being that the the website is so new it doesn't have many customers and few to no blog readership. Now that I will soon have great content for the site should I : A. Post on the Blog ? ( Its a Blogger on a blog. domain.com ) B. Post as a static page on the website ? (domain.com/content) C. Something Else ? Whats the easiest to promote and push traffic to?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | CDUBP
Which will rank best?
Which will rank longer?
Which will rank faster? Any other suggestions to get the content in front of the niche market?0 -
Best Practices in Choose The Right "Meta Description Tag"
Hi there! In the "Meta Description Tag" we use some relevant-descriptive-useful-for-the-users keywords and we keep the length about 155 characters. In your opinion guys, is a good idea to add at the end of the "Meta Description Tag" a strong "call to action"? Maybe with some capital letter? Does it sound strange to Google? Even if this improve the Click Through on the SERPs? What are the best SEO practice to deal with "Meta Description Tag"?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | YESdesign0 -
How to Optimise Meta Descriptions
Following advice here on Seomoz we have managed to boost rankings of several keywords onto page 1. However, this welcome visibilty has revealed some weak meta descriptions. We also run an adwords campaign and are familiar with best practice in writing adwords copy which can be monitored via ctr. However other than testing which can be a little lengthy and given that we have 1000s of pages (www.pretavoir.co.uk) as a ecommerce store, what is best practice in writing meta descriptions to increase organic ctr? Thanks
Conversion Rate Optimization | | seanmccauley0