Hi Mike,
I did not mean to be at all confrontational or disrespectful or confrontational or mean that you are disrespectful. I know Matt and could understand where he was coming from.
I am not in any way trying to be confrontational I simply believe from my many years of SEO that while somebody who has then a part of your niche in the past or still is may have more insight into your day-to-day business however when it comes to how websites deal with Google it has never mattered at all whether or not the person actually has worked in the industry In which the website focuses on.
I think you're right if one party says red any other said blue sometimes green wood be the answer however it is not the norm.
Having said that I believe all good SEO's should have to explained their reasoning as to why they believe something that the client has a differing opinion on.
Believe me I did not mean to make that personal and I know that you want what is best for your site and you have every right to question people's opinions.
I wholeheartedly apologize for my remarks if they offended you in any way.
I'm happy to move on and continue helping you find a solution if you would like me to. The reason I said don't get mad at me was when people feel strongly about one thing or another and this is an important thing and it would be wrong of me to tell you something I didn't this right was correct but if we disagree there needs to be a common ground as you stated. I understand you much better now and I don't want to leave you hanging.
You asked me how I got your robots.txt
because what I posted is different from going to your site and looking at the standard robots.txt
I do believe that any of these companies can fix your website site. I know that because I have worked with many of them and these are people who get results time and time again.
I can tell you that I don't just recommend anyone and I cannot comment on what they would charge you don't know.
I can tell you most likely they're going to charge you for such assessment it would be in the thousands most likely
Then once they have come to their decision as to the best course of action you would receive the main quote.
Now normally and it's bad practice to guarantee anything in stringent opposition because Google can make a change overnight and nullify everything.
With that said and this is a precaution people take because I'm sure you understand is an attorney your time is worth something to you.
I am a chemical engineer by trade I still am in fact I have a company that manufactures release liner blown film extrusion in New Hampshire.
I do this because I honestly enjoy it gotten to enjoy it too much.
You shared a bit about yourself I thought it would share a little about myself. Just to know each other.
I can tell you without a doubt that these guys can fix your site. If you want my own opinion of what I would do seeing as how I have looked at quite a bit of it I would save myself a lot of money and use a managed WordPress host they're going to be able to fix a lot of things that other people in charge a lot more for. I have seen people pay for things that companies like WP engine, Zippy kid, Web synthesis & Page.ly will do for free table make sure that your site is up and running with the robot text for instance I know that the guys that the hosts I've named will handle that for you free of charge. If you're hosted with them.
I can't even tell you that WP engine and Zippykid each have had the company automatic the one that owns WordPress invest in them. Those two both share technology as well so you get a lot. In my opinion web synthesis this is is an excellent host as well and pagely would be a big improvement over what you're on right now http://steadfast.net/
I'm not knocking your host just letting you know that anyone who specializes in WordPress and only WordPress knows a lot more about it than the guys who post everything.
I don't mean to get too off topic but you favor and look at each of the companies I have listed one thing that you might find bothersome for not is most of them do not have phone support only one zippy kid offers 24 7 phone support WP engine only when you spend $250 plus on their larger plan however both are excellent web hosts. In fact they're all excellent at customer support answering tickets. If you want to host that will literally take care of a lot of the WordPress issues you have might want to consider one of the above hosts and I say this because I have an account with each and every one of them.
Here is a site that is built out of hundred percent HTML 5 based on Genesis 2.0 WordPress it is optimized extremely well so well in fact that in Europe it still maintains site load speeds of under one second this particular site is now hosted on Zippykid with dual CDN's F5 load balancers, private cloud architecture with a Cisco enterprise-level firewall along with the option for a free optimization every site is optimized by Net DNA or Google engineer designed around the Nginx Web server instead of Apache the amount of memory saved his incredible.
for illustrative purposes, serving 10,000 simultaneous connections would only cause Nginx to use 2 megabytes of RAM whereas Apache would probably consume hundreds of megabytes (if it could do it at all).
the result it's fast take look at a site that just was brought over.
http://www.gregreindel.com/
with HTML 5 and all that brings to the table it is extremely search engine friendly and if you have any of these issues in the future the host will fix it
Getting back to what you are looking for. I would definitely recommend any of the companies below and if you're asking me are they going to pay you back the fee if they cannot remedy your problem. It would all depend on would deal you made mostly what you consider your problems to be. They're not going to guarantee anything with Google knowing well that is not going to lie to you. Honestly if somebody does guarantee you rankings run there impossible to guarantee. If somebody guarantees that they can fix something on your website in order to make it more search engine friendly that I could see a possible guarantee.
However don't think you get any of them to look at site for free and to be completely up front with you a lot of them or probably not available they're very good at what they do.
I think if you want Matt to do the job then I would discuss that with him he's a great guy and I think the one thing. When run into with all SEO's is not we can't figure this out it's going to be we will figure this out and give you a price. in this case because you are not saying well I need you to work on a campaign to any of them I can't tell you that it would be a free examination of your site. I really doubt it would be.
I know that unless continuous work is done to keep Google happy essentially campaign then a ongoing relationship that keeps your website to where you are making a positive ROI otherwise it should really not worth it right?
"You state great certainty that any of them would fix the problem. Would that mean that these SEO consultants would be paid part after completion of the fix and the problem solved? If so, it's a no brainer and I'd hire them immediately since the return on investment pays for continued investment. But I will tell you that from my experience most spoke with same certainty of fixing the problem as you do along with great projections but they didn't reflect that same degree of certainty when it came time to talk about billing."
It is completely possible to set a goal and offer 50% up front and 50% when the goals met I don't see the harm in asking I would be very specific about what you consider fixed is
http://evolvingseo.com
http://distilled.net
http://www.portent.com/
http://Internetmarketingninjas.com
http://www.seerinteractive.com/
Now one thing you mentioned was you like Yoast I do too.
Why don't you use is service it seems like this might be the perfect answer for what you need right now.
Want to Improve your Website but don’t know where to Start?
https://yoast.com/hire-us/website-review/
Regarding your robots.txt
I used a tool that pulls any robot text on the website sometimes it's a more than one place for instance somebody can putt two plug-ins that each control the same function robots.txt in this case
And the tool formats it correctly it allows you to make adjustments if needed.
Essentially I've used it pull from your domain not just robots.txt
Here is the link I suggest you check it out and put your domain or if you like as the instructions say you can just put in http://www.thelaw.com/robots.txt
http://www.internetmarketingninjas.com/seo-tools/robots-txt-generator/
I would change to this
1
User-Agent: *
2
Disallow: /wp-content/plugins/
http://yoast.com/example-robots-txt-wordpress/
Robots.txt is a way to tell a search engine which pages it’s allowed to spider, to “see”, and which pages it cannot “see”. Because of that, robots.txt differs from meta name="robots" tags, which tell search engines on those individual pages, whether they can include them in their index or not. The difference is subtle, but important. Because of that, the suggested robots.txt in the codex is wrong. Let me explain:
Google sometimes lists URLs that it’s not allowed to spider, because it’s blocked by robots.txt, because a lot of links point to a URL. A good example of this is a search for [RTL Nieuws] (disclosure: RTL is a client of mine). rtlnieuws.nl 301 redirects to the news section of rtl.nl. But… rtlnieuws.nl/robots.txt exists… And has the following content:
1
User-agent: *
2
Disallow: /
Because of that, the links towards rtlnieuws.nl don’t count toward the news section on rtl.nl, and Google displays rtlnieuws.nl in the search results. This is unwanted behavior that we’re trying to fix but for now it’s a good example of what I wanted to explain. By blocking /wp-admin/ and /trackback/ in your robots.txt, you’re not preventing them from showing up.
Unfortunately, recently the /wp-admin/ block was added to WordPress core, because of this Trac ticket. In the discussion on that ticket, I’ve proposed another solution in this patch. This solution involves sending an X-Robots-Tag header, which is the HTTP header equivalent of a meta name="robots" tag. This would in fact remove all wp-admin directories from Google search results.
WordPress Robots.txt blocking Search results and Feeds
There are two other sections which are blocked in the suggested robots.txt, /*?, which blocks everything with a question mark and as such all search results, and */feed/, which blocks all feeds. The first is not a good idea because if someone were to link to your search results, you wouldn’t benefit from those links.
A better solution would be to add a tag to those search results pages, as it would prevent the search results from rankings but would allow the link “juice” to flow through to the returned posts and pages. This is what my WordPress SEO plugin does as soon as you enable it. It also does this for wp-admin and login and registration pages.
I’m aware that that is different from Google’s guidelines on this topic at the moment, which state:
Use robots.txt to prevent crawling of search results pages or other auto-generated pages that don’t add much value for users coming from search engines.
I’ve reached out to Google to get clarification on whether they would say my solution is acceptable as well, or perhaps even better .
Blocking /feed/ is a bad idea because an RSS feed is actually a valid site map for Google. Blocking it would prevent Google from using that to find new content on your site. So, my suggested robots.txt for WordPress is actually a lot smaller than the Codex one. I only have this:
1
User-Agent: *
2
Disallow: /wp-content/plugins/
I block the plugins directory because some plugin developers have the annoying habit of adding index.php files to their plugin directories that link back to their websites. For all other parts of WordPress, there are better solutions for blocking.
The other WordPress Robots.txt suggestions
The other sections of the robots.txt as suggested are a bit old and no longer needed. Digg mirror is something for us old guys who remember when Digg used to send loads of traffic, Googlebot Image and Media Partner are still there but if you only have the above in your robots.txt you don’t need specific lines for them in your WordPress robots.txt file.
I also think the site map is set up incorrectly it should just be simply one index sitemap_index.XML I don't know that you even need one for your form however that's something I would needs more time on. However I would ideally put into the same index.
http://www.sitemaps.org/protocol.html
http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/forum/vbulletin-4/vbulletin-4-questions-problems-and-troubleshooting/426502-is-an-xml-sitemap-that-crucial-for-forums
I will do this if you would like please feel free to call me tomorrow I have an appointment at 11 o'clock Eastern time I'm not looking to try to get business trust me however I feel that when people discuss things over the phone they tend to get worked out much faster than any other method. If I can be of help to you in any way I would be happy to do that. I will also be happy to explain to any reasons I feel you should go one way if you feel that is not the right way.
I will send you a private message and the choice is yours I would strongly suggest using one of the companies I suggested. you can also get Yoast to look over your site for $1100 and tell you what's wrong.
All the best,
Thomas