Moz Q&A is closed.
After more than 13 years, and tens of thousands of questions, Moz Q&A closed on 12th December 2024. Whilst we’re not completely removing the content - many posts will still be possible to view - we have locked both new posts and new replies. More details here.
Radius Size around GMB location for google local search
-
We are a digital marketing agency
Our clients are (virtually all) retail automotive dealerships.
We compete in various market places coast to coast (USA).
Since Google puts retail automotive dealerships under Local SEO umbrella, is it known ( published ) how large is the radius around my client's Google My Business rooftop's address? How wide is their search 'reach' according to Google?
Asked another way, in a triangular, three SEO geo area, with one city being at the epicenter of the population dispersion, and my client, versus my client's competitors being different distances from where the majority of the population emanates from, all other SERP factors being equal (assumption) between the two competitors, how far is each clients REACH from a Local Search standpoint.
Is this known? Published by Google.
-
Thanks for the further details, and shalom to your wife and family.
-
Here is LIKE the situation I am talking about. In the Capital District of NY State 'Albany' is the hub. But, 20 minutes east is Rensselaer County with "Troy" as it's hub city and to the west is Schenectady County with the City of Schenectady as it's hub. That's the triangulation here, but, not unique to here ...and we encounter this situation coast to coast ( we have clients coast to coast ). So, as mentioned, I'm using my 'hometown' as an example, because I am most familiar with this locale, but, this applies in other areas too ... an example, Baltimore Maryland and it's suburbs. Oklahoma City, OK and it's suburbs etc. etc.
In the Capital District of NY State the overall population is 1,000,000. 1mm people and 5 Honda Dealerships all sharing that market. So even though 1 Honda Dealership is in Troy (Rensselaer) and 1 Honda Dealership is in Schenectady and 1 Honda Dealership is in Albany, they are all close enough together that they all sell cars to people who live and work in the competitors market. 20 Minutes apart at the points of the triangle more or less.
MY client is an outlier. It's GMB address and physical location is "Latham" NY. Not Albany Schenectady or Troy. Another outlier that falls in the into the same scenario is Saratoga Honda. They are a bit north ... but very competitive and the same marketplace / same customer demographics. Clifton Park has a lot of buyers - nearer to Saratoga ...but no dealership is there. Now our area is big enough and Honda is a big enough brand, that I am just talking about HONDA in the "Greater Capital District" as an example, but, you could do the same thing with Nissan, or Toyota, or Ford, or GMC ....etc.
So, I am being 'specific' with my example, but it applies more generally. Now in your reply it seems you may have thought I was talking about USED car dealerships. Yes, in any area this size they are a dime a dozen and we don't represent too many used car dealerships. We are too pricey and they don't have the budgets for us. So, even though we are not, as a place of business, rooftop, address representing a client with the best advantage point, we are 'good enough' that we can rank our client ... not IN the Albany or Schenectady or Troy location, but, in the Local Pac 2 or 3 in any of those areas ... cuz ...we're good.
Good discussion ... but gotta run now. The first night of Chanukah, my wife is Jewish ... shalom.
-
Thank you so much for taking the time to answer, and yes, I understood exactly what you are describing.
So, the one common exception I have seen to the rule of thumb that you can't rank where you don't have a physical presence is when Google doesn't have enough results within a single city. So, if you're one of only 3 gas stations serving 10 towns in a rural area, you have a very good chance of ranking for all 3 towns.
I'm not sure how competitive your XYZ area is, Gary. Where I live, any town with an "auto row" has tons and tons of dealerships. So, I wouldn't expect a dealership in town X to show up in the results for town Y, because town Y has 15+ dealerships of its own. What's the situation where you are?
-
Yes.
Yes we do see what you described. Backing up, the our client being client X in the XYZ triangulation that I described and you referenced / questioned ... the 'example' I am using is a real life 'hometown' example. As it is our near our agency's location, I am intimately familiar with the geography. I am using it as an 'example' in posing my question(s) (which your thoroughly answered thank you very much) but I am using that same scenario to extrapolate to other geographic areas we serve where have new car manufacturers of ABC make and competitor #2 and competitor #3 that also rank and serve in the same geosphere. And yes, while our client may rank #1 in their hometown city, they may also rank #2 or #3 in the competitor's city, which is GOOD (for us and them). And, the question that you asked, in reverse, yes, while our client is ranking #1 in their hometown geosphere, the other competitors of the same ABC manufacturer may rank #2 or #3 in our client's hometown. So there don't seem to be any anomalies in the WAY Google does it. And, the way you described Google does it makes sense and is 'fair', I am just trying to find a way to gain an advantage (totally whitehat way) ... not to game the google search methods, but to play my hand as best I can to give MY clients ... the upperhand. Didn't spend much time wordsmithing this reply so I hope it all makes sense.
But, yes, we can rank (but not number one) in their backyard as it were.
And they can rank, and do, (but not number one) in our backyard.
And yes, your explanation is confirmation of what I thought I had learned and understand, but, what I REALLY wanted was for there to be a radius ... a defined distance in miles or minutes (driving) that would constitute what IS my client's 'backyard' ... so I could devise strategies to sneak into my competitor's backyard, maybe under the dark of night, without them seeing and 'steal' some pagerank.
Anyway, thanks for the confirmation/answers M.E. Hope my reply made sense to you. Gary@OOMDO - Digital Marketing Defined ... using Michael Donovan's sign in (he's the bossman). Thanks So Much
-
Hey Michael,
Nice to know my name is one your cherished family members had (may they rest in peace), and thanks for the kind words in your reply. I'm sorry if what I was describing was a bit basic - stuff you already knew, but it does sound like that city-specific ranking bias of Google's is the cause of what your clients are experiencing in the more populous area you've described. One thing I am curious about, and would like to ask you as you've been looking so much at the results in this tri-city area. Let's say your client is in city X in the XYZ of this triangulation. Do you ever see competitors in city Y ranking in the local packs for cities X and Z, or competitors in city Z ranking in the local packs for X and Y? Just curious.
I know what you mean about spurious agencies offering your client the impossible, and yikes, the client taking the bait. So frustrating when that happens. Likely, the best thing to recommend to the client in city X is to invest in Adwords so that they can show up in the paid results for cities Y and Z.
Enjoyed your reply very much!
-
Great Answer Miriam! I thought of you as / after I wrote it. I also thought it would be rather presumptuous of me to write to you directly, so, I was rather pleased when it was you who replied.
I think our paths crossed one other time in the 2.5 years I have been doing this ( SEO-Automotive).
Your answer was very clear and complete and I like to think of its comprehensiveness as 'thorough'.
What you answered I knew - or have experienced - but still greatly appreciated and well explained.
What I didn't know - and now know - is the answer is "NO" .... ha ha ha amused at my alliteration.
What I wanted the answer to be was: 30 miles. Or an hour's drive. I wanted simple - definitive.
But, it is what it is. We have dealers in less populated areas where the OWN the market. Then we have dealers in a geo areas where they are the 'best' dealer in the geo area ( 3 cities 30 mile triangle) but their location is not in the middle of the triangle and not near the most heavily populated area. So, whereas they rank #1 for their city/location it seems impossible to get them to rank #1 in the city/location that has the larger population. From a practical standpoint, they get their share of customer traffic from within the triangulated area, no doubt, and, they rank either #2 or at least #3 in the other city/locations, but, where this comes to a head is when Agency / Competitors of OURS are knocking on their doors and pointing out ( I didn't say promising) ... " hey, look, you don't rank #1 in cityY or cityZ " ... and they imply that their agency could achieve that ranking. Anyway, I blather on ... you get it. I get it. I just wanted a different answer because the explanation you provided can be a little elusive to the Principal that get's selling cars, that gets more organic traffic = more sold cars, that gets more organic traffic is the best conversion rate, that gets organic traffic may be the best ROI ... he / they get all that, but, maybe not the principles of Local SEO ... not so much.
Thanks for your thoroughness ... Miriam was my mom's mom's name (both deceased). Thanks again.
-
Hi Gary,
Great question. The answer is, no, I don't believe that is a "known" quantity, because it would vary for each scenario, each search. How frequently one of your clients appears in the results is going to be based on a) it's strength, b) the strength and number of nearby competitors it has and c) the location of the searcher. So, as you can imagine, that varies, search by search, user by user.
A given in any scenario is that a business is only likely to rank for both truly local and remote searchers for the city in which it is physically located. So, let's say you have a dealership in Dallas. Someone in Dallas searches for "auto dealership" and your client has a good chance to rank for that. Someone in Sugar Land searches for "auto dealership Dallas", and, again, your client can rank for that. But, if someone in Sugar Land searches just for "auto dealership", Google is going to show him Sugar Land results, and your client won't be included in those because they are located in Dallas.
The variables in the scenario relate to the exact proximity of a user to your business at the time of search. A searcher in a Central Dallas neighborhood looks for "auto dealership" on his device, and Google is most likely to show him dealerships that are closest to him. If he then drives over to the Park Cities neighborhood and performs the same search, his results are likely to change to that geographic area of the city. But, if the searcher is, say, 10 miles outside of Dallas, searching for "auto dealerships Dallas", Google defaults to a different type of result for him, which appears to be based more on authority than proximity.
So, those are basically the elements that you have to take into consideration in trying to understand the reach of a given business. You have to consider the location of the searcher, as well as the level of competition both right next to the business, and within its entire city or zip code.
Not a simple answer, I know! But, I hope it helps.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Using PO Box/Virtual Address for local citations, but not GMB?
Hello. So, I am aware that it is in violation of Google My Bussiness's terms of service to use register a PO box/virtual address with GMB, but is it problematic to use such addresses for general link building with local citations, such as local directories and resource pages? Would the cons outweigh the pros (more backlinks)? And what about using one of these kinds of addresses on my website, but not GMB? Is it all so interrelated nowadays that I should steer clear of publishing a virtual address anywhere? That just seems hard to wrap my head around as PO Boxes have served a valuable function for small businesses for some 150 years. Thank you, Jon
Local Listings | | custardextract0 -
How do I rank for a different business categories on google local?
Hello, How do I appear on the local listings for google in different categories or services that I offer? For instance, we're a physical therapy clinic by trade but we specialize in orthopedics, sports medicine, and lower back pain. Thus, how do I rank on google local for these types of services? Currently, we rank for physical therapy but we also miss out on a big part of our business by not ranking for these listings on local. Any help or suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Cheers, Scott
Local Listings | | scottgray06200 -
HELP! Google Local dropped!
I noticed that my Google Local page does not show in any search results anymore. Looking at Moz Local, it appears that I had 250 views on August 30th and 0 after that. It just dropped overnight. I looked at Google My Business and I noticed that I had a duplicate listing (no idea where it came from). It wasn't verified though. I deleted that. I also noticed that my address has been changed to Drive instead Dr. I was very careful in making it the same everywhere, but it changed without me changing it. Perhaps someone so kindly "suggested an edit" and I didn't see that happen. Anyone have any ideas. My organic search ranking is still strong. #3 for most search terms. And we have a very strong Google Local reviews. I mean, it even shows business that have been permanently closed over me!!! And we have photos, great reviews, and regularly post to Google+. I seriously need some help. I am a small business owner that does all of my own SEO because I can't afford a good SEO. 😞
Local Listings | | CalicoKitty20000 -
Different Phone Numbers in GMB/onsite
Hello All! I have an issue. I have a local business with multiple addresses, In order to start doing some conversion optimization I need to know where are the leads coming from, my assumption is that part of the leads come from phone calls directly from the google my business listing that appears in the local pack and some come from the website itself. Here's where the problem lays, I cannot understand how many calls come from each platform, Google My Business analytics provides a very high number that doesn't fit with my reports (i have a CRM that can track calls), the numbers are inflated in hundreds of %. The solution i thought of was implementing a different phone number in my website to track the leads, the problem is the NAP, which will be different. Another solution I thought of was implementing an additional phone number in Google My Business, and adding that additional phone number to the local landing page, displaying the new phone number as the main number on the page and leaving the old number in the schema markup. Does this solution seems fit? do you have another suggestion?
Local Listings | | OrendaLtd0 -
Google My Business - bulk location upload vs. single upload
Hi there, I have a question regarding Google My Business listings: We currently have a business with few offices (less than 10). Each office has it's Google listing under the same Google account.
Local Listings | | OrendaLtd
We plan on opening new offices at a certain pace, let's say two a month, which means we'll have more than 10 listings in the near future.
As far as I recall, Google allows up to 10 listings per account, which means it won't suffice. On the other hand, We do not have 10 offices at the time being, which means we're not eligible for a bulk upload. Any ideas how to handle this situation?0 -
How to deal with wrong location in Google SERP
Hi, If I understand correctly, Google provides search results based on the location of the user. That's fine, because most of my clients are local. But if I look at my own search results, Google thinks I'm in a totally different town. Most likely based on my IP address. Of course I can solve that for myself, but the same goes for my potential clients. Is there a way to deal with this, from an seo perspective? For instance find out where most of the the IP providers are located and target that location?
Local Listings | | Houdoe1 -
Will changing my business location affect my ranking for localised searches in my original area?
I run a mobile outdoor personal training service in London, UK (i.e. no bricks and mortar gym). Or, rather, my business is in London (all my clients and the freelance trainers that work for me) but I'm personally due to move out to the county of Suffolk. As I work from a home office and my company's registered address is my home, that means I have to inform Companies House and various government agencies that the company has moved. Does this mean: a) I also must tell Google the company has moved, and; b) if I do will Google start to see my website as being for a Suffolk-based company? I really don't want this to happen: my clientele are mostly in London., I still want to market to Londoners. And if I want to expand the areas covered by my company, Suffolk is not high on my list. You'll excuse me if this is a simple question! Thanks for any help you could give
Local Listings | | fionadoggett0 -
How can I manually build local citations for a client?
Note: I am not interested in paying for services to build citations for me. I am managing building a client's citations. On many sites I am asked to create an account and verify my information. I have tried to create accounts using my client's email address and specified password so that they can manage their citations down the road should their NAP change. However, many sites require further verification such as security questions or a phone code. It isn't practical or effective to ask a client to confirm and verify all of these accounts. What is the most effective way to manually build local citations for a client? How can I get around the issue of email and phone verification?
Local Listings | | BlairKuhnen0