Changing existing URL's to improve SEO
-
Here's a general question: At what PR/page rank (or Moz 'page authority') would you no longer change an existing URL that's cryptic to one that includes the related page keyword or at least relevant terms? Does using a 301 redirect to the new URL preserve the page rank? Thanks!
-
Patrick - Great response, really appreciate the effort you put into that and the solid strategy. I do have a spreadsheet where I've mapped each page and related analytics, i.e. traffic to each page over time, meta tag info, PR, age, url, etc, and very few are driving any significant traffic so those are easy decisons. The few that ARE getting some decent traffic just make me think it's worth any temporary slippage for longer term benefit of being better optimized, presenting a clear theme for each page for both visitors and search engines. Knowing I'll retain 90% of the trust/authority by doing the 301 redirects makes it seem clear that's the right call.
I've added several of the link references you included in your response to my reading list for this week, they look like great resources. Thanks!
-
Thanks Umar. I'd call these 'last benchers' (like that phrase), they are relatively aged but really aren't carrying much weight. They're mainly content pages but are fairly obscure right now, so I'm hoping by putting the 301 redirect in place, and optimizing the new page/url, we'll get a little better visibility then we can work on collecting a few links to each of them.
Thanks for your response!
-
Hi Jason,
Thanks for the response! None of the pages are what I'd consider as critical. They're basically content pages produced by a law firm that speak to various topics their clients may be interested in, but they're essentially un-optimized, i.e. only the firm name in all the title tags, no clear keyword focus, nothing relevant in the URL, poor H1 tags, etc. Most of the pages get little traffic, but there are a few that get 30-40 views/month.
I only want to change those that are relevant to good keywords I want to optimize them for, and retaining 90% of the trust/authority is good enough. I'm thinking the benefit of optimizing will outweigh the 10% detriment from changing the currently indexed url.
Thanks again!
-
Hi there
I agree with what Umar says above. Besides the points he has for reason why you should or would change a URL, it'd be great to have context!
Alot of this is going to require research, conversations, and gut instincts - remember, whatever you plan on doing, you need to have a plan that can be explained clearly and concisely. We always hear from clients that they changed URL structures when in reality they just needed a little TLC.
Check the following:
-
All KPIs that matter most to your visibility / performance
-
Your site's goals over time
-
Google Search Console performance over time (impressions / rankings)
-
Take a look at your competitors
-
Is Google valuing domains that have a different or more categorized URL structure?
-
Not a reason to change yours, but it could help categorize your site a bit more
-
Check your on-site SEO
-
Check your backlinks
-
Check your content
-
Check your information architecture
-
Learn more about your audience
-
Are you capturing your audience at the right points? Do you have content to do so?
-
Are you doing everything you can do develop your brand(s) right now?
The reason you should check all of the above is because sometimes the URL structure is fine, it's a matter of other elements that could be hurting your organic visibility.
If you do your research and find that that a URL structure change would help, I would focus on the following:
URL Structures (Moz)
Information Architecture for SEO (Moz)
Moving Your Site (Google)
Website Migration Guide (Moz)All of these resources above will help you move your site in a SEO friendly way and help you preserve as much ranking equity as you can.
Would love to hear the context though! Hope this helps, good luck!
-
-
Hey Michael,
I would like to know what's the main reason that forcing you to change the existing URL? Is it because of the ranking? If yes, then how old is your current URL's format? And what about the traffic stats of this page, is it among the high ones or a last bencher? If everything is alright then I don't think you need to take a risk of changing/updating your URL.
You can change/update the URL if:
- It's a polluted URL (contains codes, special characters, parameters and other garbage)
- You're no longer offering those services specifically but as the Page Authority is good you don't want to remove that page.
In the above cases, you can consider for changing the URL with a 301 redirect. As the Jason said, 301 does preserve the PR and other metrics.
Remember, you might see a temporary ranking drop after implementing the 301 redirect. So make sure to have a proper action plan before.
Hope this helps!
Umar
-
301'ing the old page to the new page will keep about 90% of the trust and authority as the old page.
Regarding your first question, how critical is this page to the long-term success of you business?
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Changing commenting platforms...will deleting old comments hurt SEO?
Hi everyone, We've decided to move away from Disqus and use Facebook comments on one of our blogs. Our users prefer it, and we saw traffic increase when we did it on another site. My question is, will removing old comments (we have hundreds of them per post) hurt my seo? I've scoured the internet for an answer but can't find anything up to date. Old best practices said to keep old comments. What do you think? Thanks!
On-Page Optimization | | TMI.com0 -
URL Structure Suggestion
Hi
On-Page Optimization | | sandeep.clickdesk
My site url: http://goo.gl/AiOgu1
We are working on URL structure of our website. I have one query about URL structure.
Which one is good URL structure according to user and SEO prospective.
The targeted keyword for the particular page is "wordpress live chat". Is it worthful to rewrite the present url "https://www.abc.com/wordpress" to "https://www.abc.com/wordpress-live-chat" Please suggest.0 -
What's better for SEO a page per review or a page with all reviews?
Was wondering what's better for SEO. We have a platform where consumers can read and write reviews. But the question is: is it better to give one page per company with all the reviews on it? Or should we have different pages for the specific company? Example: Itunes has a company page with all reviews on the page, but not the whole review. You have to click further to view the whole review (new page), at the moment this the current situation. What if we place the whole reviews on the company page, so you don't have specific pages for the reviews? Hopefully can someone help us out. Contact me if it's not clear or you want more extended information. Kind regards
On-Page Optimization | | MozzieJr0 -
Keyword repeats/presence in url's & over-optimisation
Hi I'm about to launch a redesigned site and worried about overdoing kw presence on-page, primarily using in url's since will already be using kw in titles as well as page content. What's current thinking re over optimisation: If kw is in titles and page content is it best not to repeat again in url structure i.e. less is more, even though this will cause things like SeoMoz on-page grade score to fall, or better to keep them/add them ? Personally i think it makes sense to include kw in url again since helps make the page relevant, and so long as matches the content should help as opposed to hinder rankings for the pages target keyword. However when i look into this some say don't do this since is over-optimisation The sites generally ranking quite well for its target kw which i obviously don't want to lose after re-launch & hopefully improve further, in the case of this example they are 'Sports Centre Services' & 'Sports Centre Equipment Rental'). The sites current url structure is similar to this below example: frankssportscentres.com/services/sports-centre-equipment-rental Would it be better to keep following existing/above format or to go with either of the below options i.e. more kw rich urls or less: frankssportscentres.com/sports-centre-services/sports-centre-equipment-rental Or frankssportscentres.com/sports-centre-services/equipment-rental Or even less frankssportscentres.com/services/equipment-rental Many Thanks in advance for any helpful comments Cheers Dan
On-Page Optimization | | Dan-Lawrence0 -
SEO for luxury brands!?
Hi all, It is widely known fact that you will be a bit in trouble if you will need to do SEO for luxury brand that is not willing to sacrifice design, layout etc. for SEO purposes. So basically - there is no content to optimize and there is almost no keywords to rank! 😉 Just wondering - how would be the best to approach such kind of terrible situation? Regards, Jungle
On-Page Optimization | | Jungles0 -
URL Rewrite
(By Google Traductor) Hello, I wanted to ask about some changes that we are evaluating for the issue of passing the url with variables to be more descriptive, for example: http://www.agroads.com.ar/detalle.asp?clasi=139592 tohttp://www.agroads.com.ar/humedimetro-para-cereales-draminski-gmm-139592.html In this case corresponds to the breakdown of a product if you have long published andcan be well positioned to change the title of this position would be lost unless youmanage it with a 301, as one would manage when you have more than 30000 products and title may change several times? There are tools to manage this? Finally, we must apply this to all listed with their respective filters, recommends doingtheir part with 301 redirects and analyze what funciene well to continue with the rest or implement a complete change? I hope I can bring a little light to implement this. Greetings and thanks! Roberto
On-Page Optimization | | romaro0 -
SEO Change/Version Control
Hi. Can anyone suggest apps that might be applied for SEO change/version control? I've tried using Excel and Word in the past but both fall short when dealing with multiple client sites. Nothing suitable pops up so far. Specifically I want to be able to log any on-page changes that might impact SEO for historical analysis and possible roll-back (manual) eg change date, page title, headings, url, anchor text, alt image txt, body copy etc. The ability to have one view that can be filtered in various ways including by client and by url would be ideal. Maybe this is something SEOmoz is considering for Pro campaign management? Surely there's demand... Thanks Andy
On-Page Optimization | | Bluesnapper0