Is an email signup form more effective than a button?
-
I'm very confident it is. But I'm looking for a study I can use to tell my conservative bosses that if we replace the button with an email entry field and button, we'll improve conversion greatly.
If anyone has a link to a study on how much you can further improve clickthrough by having an overlay form appear, I'd appreciate that as well.
Joel
-
I have to agree with EGOL when they stated, "You are asking if Method A is better than Method B. I am willing to bet that the implementation is more important than the method."
I think either of these methods (button v. form) can work better, but this is dependent on a few things. You will need to consider what the industry is, who the viewers are, and what they are more likely to do. Aesthetics and verbiage will also make a major impact—so it really comes down to multiple factors. For instance, someone who is younger might be more inclined to simply hit a button for ease of use. Making it less clicks will always improve your conversion. But an older person might prefer to fill out a form—but they might also not want to give out their information. My biggest suggestion would be to sit down and ensure you are thinking about your audience, not necessarily what you think would convert the best.
Hope this helps!
-
You are asking if Method A is better than Method B. I am willing to bet that the implementation is more important than the method.
So, I would do some of each and keep track of what does best. Every situation is going to be unique and the more varied the stuff that you throw at the wall the greater your chance of seeing something big stick.
-
If you're looking for specific studies, I know there's some out there about CRO on payment forms. Kyle Rush talked about the one he did for the Obama campaign for campaign donations at MozCon in 2013.
-
HI Joel,
I can understand wanting a study to convince someone of something. Thing is, Erica is right.
You figure 100% of the people on this page are on this page. Some smaller percent will by definition be on the next page with the sign up form.
So, unless there is something magical about the button that adds to their commitment to filling out the form or some amazing content (that should be on page one if it's so amazing), I can't see how more visitors would fill out the form on page two. It would have to be so many more that it makes up for all the people that didn't click the link or button.
If the signup form is too huge for the content already on page one, you may want to try asking for just name and email on page one and the rest of it on page two. That way, you would at least get enough to keep marketing to them later if they bail on page two of the form. Of course, test that to get the data you need.
What the page two form advocates have is a hypothesis. Such is the stuff tests are made of.
Sorry about not having a study, but it really is not very debatable. Of course, every site is different and who knows what variables in information or channel you're dealing with.
Best of luck!
Mike
-
You definitely want to make any customer/community information you're collecting as easy as possible for the person entering it. Making it less clicks will always improve your conversion.
Got a burning SEO question?
Subscribe to Moz Pro to gain full access to Q&A, answer questions, and ask your own.
Browse Questions
Explore more categories
-
Moz Tools
Chat with the community about the Moz tools.
-
SEO Tactics
Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers
-
Community
Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!
-
Digital Marketing
Chat about tactics outside of SEO
-
Research & Trends
Dive into research and trends in the search industry.
-
Support
Connect on product support and feature requests.
Related Questions
-
Best Day of Week & Best Time of Day for B+B Email
For business to business email, should we avoid sending on Mondays and Fridays? The nature of the service is commercial real estate brokerage for office space in New York City. We are mailing to corporate decision makers in various industries (technology, finance, law). Should we avoid mailing during certain times of day? Or is there a best time of day to send the email. Thanks,
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Kingalan1
Alan1 -
Tracking Adwords users who sumbit a contact form after clicking through my Landing page.
I have a user, Jane, who comes to my landing page through an AdWords campaign. She click off my landing page, browses the website, then submits a contact form on one of the other pages on the site. My problem is when I receive the email from the contact form, there is no identification that this user came through adwords. If she had submitted the contact form on my landing page this wouldn't be a problem, but she submitted the form from elsewhere on the site. I know that I can see a NUMBER of how many goal conversions were achieved this way in Analytics. This is not what I want. I need something to identify it on the CONTACT FORM so that the intake staff in my office can credit that lead to the correct campaign. Any idea on how to achieve this. Technically, I am using the latest version of Wordpress and the Contact Form 7 plug-in. I can change plug-ins if needed.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | McShaneFirm0 -
Multiple Thank You pages with one Contact form - PPC
Hi everyone,
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Carla_Dawson
I am running a PPC (Google Adwords Campaign) and it is pretty big. I have about 25 landing pages each with a Contact Form. I need the contact form to go to a unique thank you page for each landing page to measure conversions via Google Adwords. In other words I need the contact form on submission to redirect to a specific and unique thank you page that I can define. The contact form needs to be the same for all landing pages to avoid having to produce 25 landing pages. I am ok with producing 25 Example
http://www.maindomain.com/landing-page-1 redirects tohttp://www.maindomain.com/thank-you-1 http://www.maindomain.com/landing-page-2 redirects tohttp://www.maindomain.com/thank-you-2 http://www.maindomain.com/landing-page-3 redirects tohttp://www.maindomain.com/thank-you-3 Can someone help me with this?
Thanks https://wordpress.org/plugins/contact-form-7/0 -
Is putting an email address in the page title a good idea?
As our Contact Us page title was a little short I added in sales@example.com So "Contact us : Sales@example.com" We don't get a lot of spam and it hasn't noticeable increased since we did this. Tynt suggests that a reasonable number of people have copied and pasted the email - presumably to contact us Is it worth experimenting with further or a waste of time?
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Zippy-Bungle1 -
Contact form at the end of all posts
I notice a lot of sales blogs have contact forms at the end of all their posts. Can anyone give me some information on the effectiveness of this tactic? Case studies, examples, or your experience from adding contact forms and what it did to conversions? I imagine it would help increase conversions. It would reduce a step from moving to a new page, but might turn off some visitors? Any information would be appreciated.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | Oren.0 -
What is the best day of the week for email surveys?
Wondering what the best day of the week is for emailing surveys. Also if there are different best days for B2C & B2B.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | bozzie3110 -
Shorter checkout form converts better? Or can it be harmful?
I've frequently read that the shorter the checkout form the better. My checkout form has the following fields: First name Last name Email Username Password Retype password Card number Card expiration date CVV code Billing street Billing city Billing state Billing zip Here's the thing. Since it's a web-app, I don't need the "billing address" as I'm not physically shipping them anything. Should I remove it? The no-brainer answer seems to be "yes", but I'm wondering if folks don't see any billing address fields, it may look suspicious. Conversions for having it and not don't seem to make much difference, so I suppose I'm looking for some tie-breaker opinions. The "password" and "retype password" fields could be eliminated by emailing the user's a system-generated password. But once again, could a user see this as odd or suspicious and then abandon? Even if I tell them I'll be emailing them a password? They could be sensitive thinking we'd email the wrong email address due to system error or their own typo. I could also eliminate the CVV and not validate against that. But once again, could a user seeing the CVV gone become wary? As much as I'd like to have "guest checkout' it's not feasible. The app is tied to a logged in account, which would also make eliminating the "username" impossible. Based on all the above, I could trim down the form considerably, but would I be doing more harm than good? I could A/B test it, but I don't believe I have a sufficient number of users to test against. Everything I buy, physical or online app, has an address field, so perhaps folks are accustomed to filling out this stuff and I should just keep it to align with user expectations? Thanks.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | bluekite770 -
Lookiing for examples of local "small biz" sites with phone or contact form conversion points
Hi Guys, I'm looking for any good examples of small business sites that you've come across that do a good job at converting potential visitors to clients. I'm primarily thinking about service oriented business such as Doctors, Dentists, Salons, Clothing stores, small restuarants, car detailing services, local photographers, etc. I'm just trying to digest other examples and look for new inspirations.
Conversion Rate Optimization | | DotCar0